3 councilors walk out from city, school budget talks

AUBURN — Councilors and school officials foreshadowed an emotional showdown Monday night, sparring over the school department's proposed 5.2 percent budget increase.

"I want to do what's right for the kids and I believe in their education, but my hands are tied," said Auburn City Councilor Belinda Gerry. "I wish you had come to us with a lower budget that made changes gradually, in stages because we cannot give you what you request."

The evening included a presentation by school officials explaining how they hope to modernize Auburn's education system. Three councilors left the meeting, one at a time — first Ward 1's Mike Farrell, then Ward 3's Dan Herrick and finally Ward 5's Ray Berube.

Herrick said he saw little value in the district's presentation, and he wanted to discuss numbers and not philosophy. And Berube said the three watched the presentation via the council chamber's closed circuit television in a back office.

"We didn't miss a thing," Berube said.

That didn't stop school officials and their supporters from criticizing the three.

"I'm very upset that these three people didn't give us the decency of just listening," said School Committee Member Francois Bussiere.

Aho presented his draft budget to councilors last week. The municipal side calls for a $983,004 increase in spending combined with a $475,768 reduction in non-property tax revenues. Combined, the city-side of the proposed budget would need an additional $1.5 million from property taxes.

Monday, councilors reviewed the school-side of the budget. School officials have requested a $1.8 million increase in costs combined with a $165,999 reduction in non-property tax revenue. Combined, the schools would need an additional $1.9 million from property taxes.

The two increases — and a $33,209 increase in Androscoggin County's share of Auburn property taxes — call for $3.2 million more from property taxes. That amounts to an increase of $1.78 per $1,000 of value increase in property taxes. That's an increase of about $258 for a $145,000 home.

For the schools, proposed spending increases include adding 16.5 positions district-wide — including a Somali school liaison, a school nurse and four reading teachers — to staff a summer school program. It also includes $90,000 each at Auburn Middle School and Edward Little High School to update technology, curriculum and improve learning.

School Superintendent Tom Morrill said the budget is necessary to transform Auburn's education system into a modern one using 21st century technology and using 21st century ideas. The department has hired a coordinator to direct a "multiple path learning project" at the high school. That would let the school offer curriculum that is specific to each student.

But Councilor Herrick said he wanted to focus on the budget numbers and the proposed budget increase and complained that school officials had not provided a printed version of the budget — even though it has been available online.

"Without a printed version, I won't support any school budget," Herrick said.

And Herrick said he would not support the budget as it stands now.

"I'll tell you what I want to do," Herrick said. "I want to give a reduction to the Auburn school system by $2.5 million."

Councilors also discuss proposed budgets for Public Works, engineering and Parks and Recreation.

Budget discussions are scheduled to continue at 5:30 p.m. March 28 with a review of Planning and Permitting, Human Resources and the city's salary and fringe benefit spending.

staylor@sunjournal.com

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Comments

michaelbreton's picture
verified

What increase?

Based on what I have seen the past few years, the Auburn School Department has had either a flat budget, or a decrease in their budget. Why, when they ask for a 5% increase, do most of the people who comment seem to think the school department is trying to get a large increase?

If inflation averages 4% each year, one could argue that the proposed 2011-2012 budget is actually less money than they had a few years ago, when adjusted for inflation.

I do not know how many of the people who added comments to this article have children in the Auburn school system, but I have three. Every teacher my children have had have been excellent. I think these teachers should be compensated fairly for their work. I do not know if cost-of-living pay increases are in this proposed budget, but I think there should be if there is not.

I am disappointed with those three city councilors, one of which is in my ward, and I will not be voting for them when their term is up. They should have the decency to listen to the school board's proposal without walking out on them. I feel that was a rude thing to do.

joe gray's picture
verified

It's not about teachers

Most of us who object to increases in school budget do so for two reasons - we can't afford ANY increase in taxes and our tax dollars are being wasted.

The school department wants us to be emotional and simply yell about how this will affect our teachers and our youth. How we need to spend and spend and spend to "save our children's future". But that is not what this is about. The city council cannot stipulate where the funds are being spent. They simply have to write a check to the school department and hope the money makes it to the students.

Understandably there are concerns with how our money is being spent. When the top tier of earners in the school department are making $80,000 plus a year and not in a classroom, that is something to question. When they spend more than $500,000 on 12 parking spots, that is something to question. Parents need to stop being defensive of the school system and teach their children that a healthy skepticism is a good thing to possess. Our schools are trying to be everything to everyone. If a students won't motivate themselves to complete the school year on time, we are expected to fund a summer school and an August graduation so they can do the work over the summer. Is that the way it works at your place of employment? Can you simply forget about deadlines and expect the boss to give you more time?

There are no simple answers here. But knee jerk reactions and blind defensiveness don't help. We need to attend the school board meetings and make sure we have a say in how our school dollars are being spent.

If we need to remake the city council, we certainly need to remake the school board as well.

James Andrews's picture
verified

Auburn Schools/propperty taxes

Sorry, but reality is reality. Many of us working folks have not seen a raise in years, and things only seem to be geting harder. It's so easy for people on the public payroll to get raises and COLAS, but what about the rest of us? This country is in a huge financial crisis, as are most of the states, and continually raising taxes is NOT the answer. It is time for governments on every lervel to realize this, do the right thing, and DOWNSIZE. If you are doing well enough to send your community a sizable donation, then GO FOR IT. The rest of us have had enough!

Gary52's picture
verified

The proper thing for those

The proper thing for those three councilors to do would be to politely tell Tom Morrill and David Das and company to take their proposed budget and cram it where the sun doesn't ever shine, and then come back with a budget that isn't based on a scene out of Fantasyland. When will these people realize that most taxpayers simply have no money left to be squeezed out of?

james fom Maine's picture
verified

school board

I once asked the Portland School Committee to see an Organization chart comparing 1980 to 2005. The audience looked at me as though I had three heads. I never got that either. I support public education but it needs to be responsible and respectfully f those that fund it

timpat's picture
verified

schoola and taxes

this story about councilors and school boards is all to familiar schools want more and more promising a better education and not delivering, where are the test scores to back up what they say, ever sence the dept of education was formed the schools have got more and more money for tachers and administration and our students are getting dumber and dumber and we prove it every day on the world stage. When we attended local small schools under local control we created the modern industrial revolution and went to the moon now you cant hire a teen to make change in a store unless the register tells them hoh much and companies can't find qualified help. Sure there are exceptions but they are few. Everyone wants to keep spending and spending, when is the middleclass going to get a break, scools and goverments at all levels have to cut spending why cant they see that, they are all for it as long as its not them. Taxes are just to much of a burden on the average tax payer. And dont say to increase the taxes on business and the rich they are the ones that supply the jobs, not goverment, they are the ones that produce tangable products, not goverment, goverments at all levels only use money off the backs of US the citizen

James Andrews's picture
verified

Taxes

You brought up some seriously good points Chris! enough is enough-time to start fighting for the working class, PRIVATE sector taxpayers. I don't know about you, but the past couple of years, things have gotten tougher, worse financially. Taxes, fuel prices, insurance costs have been skyrocketing, while my average yearly income has been steadily declining the past two years. It's time to shake things up, and say NO to any more tax increase-especially property taxes.

James Andrews's picture
verified

Taxes

Just when are loacal and state governments going to wake up to the reality that many of us are broke, or nearly broke, and that we CANNOT afford any MORE tax increases? People i Auburn had huge property tax increases not too long ago! Enough is enough-it's time to STOP raising taxes, and wake up and look around you. Cut positions, or cut whatever needs to be cut-but I'm sure that most peope in Auburn don't want to see, and many probably truly can't afford, any property tax increases.

Naran's picture
verified

Definition, Please

From the article above:
"School Superintendent Tom Morrill said the budget is necessary to transform Auburn's education system into a modern one using 21st century technology and using 21st century ideas."

This "21st century" term is the same meaningless phrase we're hearing from our own school board (RSU 21), in support of massive new spending. I wrote to our school board, and asked for a definition of the term "21st century," and some independent criteria proving our schools didn't already meet that standard (whatever that 'standard' might be).

Crickets.
No response.

The reason being, they don't have any independent criteria, because it's not a real standard - it's nothing but a catch-phrase. The real meaning is "We want more money, and this sounds good, so we'll keep saying it until you hand over the big bonding."

Our schools already have every techie gadget and gizmo and program known to God and Apple. We have virtual learning, laptops, computer labs, Smart Boards, pottery kilns and foreign language programs for kindergartners, and everything else you could imagine.

Regardless, the push for more new spending just keeps coming. It's time for our school districts to recognize that the fiscal well is dry, and make do with what they already have.

tron's picture

Did it ever occur to you that

Did it ever occur to you that the reason you hear crickets when asking your questions is that they're incredulous that someone is actually asking such a ****** question?

Naran's picture
verified

If you knew anything about

If you knew anything about state law, you'd know they have an obligation to respond. It doesn't matter whether they "like" the question, or not. As a taxpayer, I have the right to ask a legitimate question about their proposal to spend up to $60 million tax dollars based on a feel-good catchphrase.

As an elected board, they have an obligation to base their decisions and spending proposals on real, factual criteria. They have an obligation to respond to the folks who pay the bills, when those folks ask legitimate questions on spending proposals.

If you're content to simply hand over your wallet because your elected officials just "say so," go right ahead.
Not me.

Robert61's picture

Naran, never ever feed a

Naran, never ever feed a troll. they will sit and point fingers and then be the worst abusers of the rules...

BWright's picture
verified

Great question Mr Reed. Ray

Great question Mr Reed. Ray Berube has been a councilor for far to long. Problem is, he runs unopposed. Auburn needs another real shakeup.

Robert61's picture

3 Councilors in a back room

3 Councilors in a back room away from the public eye and no one is questioning this....someone is clearly alseep at the wheel here..the publics business should be conducted in public and they were NOT in executive session so what gives...were minutes recorded of their meeting...

Advertisement

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...