Anguish flows as the jobless share sorrow

We sometimes hear people — always people who are fortunate enough to have jobs — speculate that many people receiving unemployment benefits really don't want to work.

These people, they say, are simply content to sit back and collect checks until their benefits run out.

That probably happens, but they are likely the people who were shiftless and lazy before this recession started and will remain so when it's over.

But we refuse to believe that about most Americans.

That belief was confirmed last week by an extraordinary outpouring of support that accompanied the story of one unemployed American.

Dominick Brocato of Kansas City is one of more than 70 people who told their stories to DW Bison for his book and documentary film "Not Working." 

His story appeared on the website of the New York Times.

Briefly, Brocato is 58, has lived in Kansas City all his life, and his appearance remains immaculate, according to Gibson's introduction.

He spent 20 years as a human resources supervisor at DST System, a tech company with 11,000 employees whose website says its "most valuable asset is the dedication of its associates."

In 2009 a new CEO arrived with a new idea: reorganize, restructure and eliminate employees.

In February of 2010, Brocato got the call he feared and his career was over.

Then he began doing everything right:  He joined job clubs, went back to school, got advanced training, put in resumes, networked and went on interviews.

Two years later he was still looking for work.

Now he's told companies are not interested in anyone over 50 or anyone who has been unemployed for more than six months.

Recently a rare cancer he had overcome in 2007 returned. Now he is without medical insurance or a job.

But the saddest thing about his story in the Times was what followed: screen after screen after screen of comments, Americans telling their own heart-wrenching stories of unemployment.

The stories flow like an endless river of personal anguish.

One commenter said he was being trained for a job that may allow him to emigrate to Canada, where he can finally get health care for the first time in three years.

Even people with advanced technical degrees told of losing their jobs and being unable to find another. One said an interviewer told her she had the necessary skills but would not be a good "cultural fit," which she took to mean "too old."

Others told of tapping their retirement savings to survive — and paying a 10 percent tax penalty to do so. One hoped to get a job by the end of the year just to pay that tax bill.

One told of applying for a temp job and being told the agency received 300 such applications a day.

"It's a downward spiral," one man wrote, "a death of a thousands cuts. Every day it gets worse."

Sad stories. Frightened people. 

But they help us recognize the reality: This recession has left millions of hardworking, experienced people without jobs — many for the first time in their lives — and with little hope of finding one soon.

Millions of other Americans, meanwhile, lie awake at night wondering if they will be next.

rrhoades@sunjournal.com

The opinions expressed in this column reflect the views of the ownership and the editorial board.

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Comments

Pirate's picture
verified

46 million Americans are on

46 million Americans are on food stamps; only 28 million were on the program when current POTUS took office. An increase of 64%. Jesse Jackson says being the 'Foodstamp President" is a badge of honor. Glad he'll never be president.

Pirate's picture
verified

Half the the country must

Half the the country must think it's all o.k. because half the country, if not more, is ready to hand oBAMa the keys to the white house for a second term. "We hate it, but give us four more years of it!!", clamored the uninformed, ignorant masses.

Jason's picture
verified

...or....

Or they realize that the economy was properly screwed before Obama took office. This isn't blaming anyone. I'm not saying Bush was responsible. But the unemployment rate bottomed out at 10% in the first year of his presidency, and is now down to 8.1%

Now you may disagree with his stimulus package, but whether you do it through spending or tax cuts, you need to pump money into the economy, which he did. Now, just like rising dough, he needs to be hands off and let it rise on it's own.

Pirate's picture
verified

The 8.1% is a bogus number.

The 8.1% is a bogus number. It doesn't include the unemployed who have stopped looking for work. DUHH?

Jason's picture
verified

Then how do you explain gallup's numbers?

Gallup, which DOES INCLUDE people who stopped looking for work, shows unemployment at 8%. Under employment is at 17.8% and full employment is at 65.4%

Pirate's picture
verified

If you'll Google "What is the

If you'll Google "What is the true rate of unemployment" and go to the Enterprise Blog, or the Huffington Post you'll find that the rate of unemployment can be whatever you want it to be depending on your political agenda. Even the Huffington Post admits to a 'true' rate of at least 9.6%. The Huntington Post; a liberal rag.

Jason's picture
verified

Are you saying Gallup has an agenda?

Gallup I have found to be pretty neutral. I mean, if there is a reason why their numbers might be off or evidence that they are juking the numbers, I want to know.

Pirate's picture
verified

I'm not saying that at all,

I'm not saying that at all, although I wouldn't be the least bit surprised to find out they do. They are pollsters, not economists or labor force government data specialists. They rely on the lies people will tell them.

Had an interesting visit at home yesterday from a young lady who was 'gathering' information on how people felt about same sex marriage. After about the fourth question I found that she was trying to get me to validate my position rather than simply document it. A question like, "When you got married 34 years ago, why did you get married"? She was, at that point, told that her interview was over. That was the second interviewer that had entertained the Pirate in less than two weeks. They're not quite as thick as the black flies yet, but they're working on it.

Jason's picture
verified

Easy Answer

Answer the door in your boxers. Works wonders for me =)

Anyway, all the numbers are educated guesses, so you have to take them at that level.

Pirate's picture
verified

Good one. Either that or I'll

Good one. Either that or I'll have the parrot go to the door. I'm sure he has opinions on the subject.
I agree on the numbers. They are guesses and they can pretty well be made to show what you want depending on what you're willing to add or omit. It sucks, really, because it becomes more and more difficult to get truthful and factual information regardless of the source. Perception has become reality; it really sucks.

2077822587's picture
verified

I would never do this on purpose....

If anyone out there is contemplating not working, DON'T DO IT. Its not all it's cracked up to be.
I know its not the same situation, but I am well aware of the feeling of desperation, of losing a job. Having worked in the trucking industry for twenty five years or so, I have been laid off numerous times. Its part of the job, you almost expect it. In my new career, I didn't expect to be laid off, but I was a year after landing a job in Portland. I bounced back from that one, and went back to work. I was making great money, all the benefits, I was on cloud nine. Then I got back sided.
I got sick, simple as that. There was no way of seeing this ahead of time. Over a period of two years, I became totally disabled. There's no cure, no treatment, no work. Something I have never faced on a long term basis before. The finality of what those doctors were saying didn't really hit me at first. I had to learn a totally new way of life. I had to maintain my life style with a lot less than what I had before.
Everyone says how nice it must be, not having to get up and go to work everyday. Well if there is a HELL on earth, it's not working and knowing you can never work again. I've had to rethink my priorities and restructure my life. I kind of wish I had a leg fall off or something. People can't see my disability, as a result of that, I'm constantly explaining myself to people.
The bottom line is, I can't work. I wish I could. If anyone thinks this lifestyle is fun, or easy, I'm here to tell you it's not. I just can't imagine anyone wanting to be in this situation. I can sympathize with people who want to find work but can't, I can't imagine being in this situation and liking it.

Centarie2000's picture
verified

that is almost the same

that is almost the same story as my brother. after years of working 2 sometimes 3 jobs to support his family, he became a truck driver. while in his early 40's, he was in a serious truck driving accident which left him with 4 crushed vertibrea and a head injury. luckly his wife is a nurse, so they were able to get health insurance when she returned to work full time, and their kids are old enough to help. he struggles with depression because of spiraling finances and he can't do anything to help, he just feels like a burden. i feel for you.

hawaiian's picture
verified

Anguish flows as the jobless share sorrow

Rex et. al., 12.05.26 19:19 HST Saturday
. . It's true . Nice editorial √
People who have never been un , or , under - employed ( with children esp. ) don't know the anguish some of us we have been through . You single parents know , too . A lot of people earn their money the old fashion way . They inherit it . But we refuse to believe that about most Americans . We are the 99%
It's so easy to point the finger and say , " Yeah , well , that would never happen to me. " Maybe so , perhaps not . There by the grace of God go us
Now , let's not all adopt a holier than thou attitude , also , ( all us followers of the one God , Jews, Gentiles amnd Muslims alike ;) , and get all puffed up about about our many accomplishments and lofty situations in life , awards and such
Pride always goeth before a fall . You can't take it with you any way . Ask MJ or Whitney ( R I P you two :)
Personally , i have never met a homeless , destitute person or family ( yes - families ) who consciously chose that path
It's a lot Iike Forest Gump said to that guy marketing smiley face T-shirts ,
" **it happens . "
That's the beauty of America , too . It's not what you got . It's how you use it
Just ask Forrest . ;) /s Steve , widower w/ 4 kids
btw - my other fav. Gump quote is, " Life is like a box pf chocolates . You don't know what you got . " ( until you stick your finger in it :)

Pirate's picture
verified

Good post, Steve. However, me

Good post, Steve. However, me thinketh thou quoteth Gumpeth to mucheth.

Centarie2000's picture
verified

i hear that holier then thou

i hear that holier then thou stuff too. we have a friend and his wife staying with us because they had to relocate for a job after a period of joblessness. they had no savings left, and pretty much just the cloths on their backs and one vehicle. another friend's husband commented about how they could have a tv but no job. i had to bite back the comment since it was his kid's birthday party. but what i wanted to ask him was what his big plan for his house on 20 acres and stay at home mom wife should he lose his job or become disabled especially since i know that they are paycheck to paycheck as it is. we all struggle in this world and it's not all just due to living outside your means.

Centarie2000's picture
verified

i hear that holier then thou

i hear that holier then thou stuff too. we have a friend and his wife staying with us because they had to relocate for a job after a period of joblessness. they had no savings left, and pretty much just the cloths on their backs and one vehicle. another friend's husband commented about how they could have a tv but no job. i had to bite back the comment since it was his kid's birthday party. but what i wanted to ask him was what his big plan for his house on 20 acres and stay at home mom wife should he lose his job or become disabled especially since i know that they are paycheck to paycheck as it is. we all struggle in this world and it's not all just due to living outside your means.

Advertisement

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...