Few Mainers to see health insurance rebates

LEWISTON — About 10,000 Mainers will benefit from a provision of the federal Affordable Care Act that went into effect Aug. 1, forcing health insurance companies to spend less on administration and more on the delivery of health benefits.

Nationwide, insurance companies last week issued more than $1 billion in rebates to about 13 million Americans.

Only one company, Connecticut General Life Insurance Co., known as Cigna, is required to issue rebates in Maine, said Doug Dunbar of the Maine Department of Professional and Financial Regulation.

Dunbar said in an email message that Cigna was required to issue about $2.6 million in rebates for 10,600 policies in their large group business in Maine.

"Because most employers pay a portion of the premium, the rebate will be split between the employer and the employee," Dunbar wrote. "The rebate can be a premium credit or reimbursement."

But while those on private insurance plans in many other states are starting to receive those checks or credits toward their insurance premiums — in some cases as much as $500 — most people on privately funded plans in Maine will see nothing.

This is particularly true for Mainers who purchase their own insurance policies and do not belong to a large group plan. Part of the reason for that is, in 2011, the state requested and was granted waivers that allowed companies selling insurance in Maine to spend more on administration than was allowed under the ACA.

The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services granted Maine those waivers because it was concerned that if it didn't, based on information provided by Maine, one of the largest providers of those types of policies — MEGA Life — would stop selling and servicing policies in Maine.

Nearly 37,000 Maine residents in 2010 obtained health insurance through the individual health insurance market, according to the federal DHHS.

About 14,000 of those policies were issued by MEGA Life. The company's threat to leave the market here if forced to meet the new federal standard pushed the state to seek the waiver.

In general, the new federal law requires insurance companies to spend at least 80 percent of the amount they take in from premiums on actual health care services. That means only 20 percent can go toward a company's administration of the plans and/or for profit.

The waiver for individual market providers in Maine, like MEGA Life, allowed them to spend only 65 percent of what they take in from premiums on services, with the remaining 35 percent going toward administration costs and profits. As they met those reduced standards, MEGA Life and other individual market insurers in Maine were not required to issue rebates here, Dunbar said.

The state agreed to request the waiver at the time because Maine's individual insurance market was deemed too fragile and the loss of MEGA Life would have left thousands without health coverage, said Mitchell Stein, policy director for Consumers for Affordable Health Care, an Augusta-based health care advocacy group.

Stein said Mia Koffman, commissioner of the Maine Bureau of Insurance at the time, was "between a rock and a hard place." If the state didn't request the waiver, more than 13,000 policies would have been put in jeopardy and people would have lost their health care coverage.

State waivers are only in effect through 2013, although there is a provision in the waiver that could allow the state to extend that exemption in 2013, Stein said.

He said that in 2014 it's possible Mainers would start seeing rebate checks or premium credits, but he hoped that wasn't the case.

"My bottom line on the issue of the rebates is the best possible outcome is that no one receives a rebate because all of the insurance companies are devoting an appropriate amount of their premium dollars toward paying out claims," Stein said. "So no one gets a rebate because everybody is playing by the rules."


What do you think of this story?

Login to post comments

In order to make comments, you must create a subscription.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must hold a valid subscription allowing access to this website. You must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your SunJournal.com profile. To subscribe or link your existing subscription click here.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned from posting comments.




Two, no three, reactions

1. Did Cigna forget to send in their contribution to the Republican party?

2. Why did the feds cave in to the LePage adinistration's request for a waiver. The appropriate response would have been, "When pigs fly."

3. This is a perfect example of why the insurance companies and their surrogates on both sides of the aisle should not have been allowed to kill the public option insurance that was first a part of the Affordable Health Care bill. Better yet, it is a great reason for the expansion to all Americans of full Medicare (no Medigap needed - that's where those nasty insurance weasels nibble at your wallet). Since private (for profit) premiums are no longer paid, there is no "huge" increase in cost - an inconvenient, therefore ignored by conservatives and the media truth.

FRANK EARLEY's picture

Does DHHS have a speciel gun for shooting themselves in the foot

First their own administrators totally screw up their own accounting at the expense of tax payers, recipients, anyone else but those who are responsible. Now we hear they decided, in the interest of allowing a company keep fifteen percent more profit, to bend the rules to appease the CEO's. Yes I meant to say profits. Administrative expenses, is big business for "PROFITS". I'm beginning to hope Romney wins the next election. If he loses they may hire him to run DHHS, they have so much in common. If you do it for one industry, their all going to expect the same treatment, nice going state administrators.......

Robert Groetzinger's picture

Seems the Gov has taken money

Seems the Gov has taken money out of the pockets of the citizens and put it in the pockets of the Ins.CEOs

Betty Davies's picture

Benefits go far beyond a rebate

Under Obamacare, you can no longer be forbidden insurance due to a pre-existing condition.

Mllions of people who had no access to affordable health insurance, that includes preventive care, now will have it.

Women can't be charged substantially more than men for insurance.

Seniors in the doughnut hole get discounts on brand-name medications. In 2011, 11,892 Mainers saved an average of $530 in discounts - $6.3 million in all, according to the federal DHHS.

Seniors get an annual wellness visit, mammogramn and colonoscopy. About 226,000 Mainers have received preventive care without copays or deductibles thanks to Obamacare.

If your young-adult son or daughter hasn't yet found a job with health insurance, you can keep them on your own pan a while longer.

New tax credits in the law are saving hundreds of thousands of small companies thousands of dollars each on their insurance costs. Independent experts such as Rand Corp. say more employers will offer coverage 2014 — as it did in Massachusetts after health reform was passed — when small-business owners have the choice of shopping for health coverage in new competitive marketplaces.

Your insurer can no longer cut you off if you develop a serious, long-term illness that's expensive to treat.


Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...