The buck must stop somewhere

It's time for this country to have a serious conversation about debt.

On Friday, the Los Angeles Times reported that homeowners with perfectly good credit scores, affordable homes and affluent incomes are "strategically defaulting" on their mortgages at rates unpredicted and unpredictable by any available financial information.

What this means is that homeowners, who can easily afford their debts, are just walking away from them at astounding rates and without notice. This casts a different light on the nation's foreclosure crisis, which has largely focused on impoverished homeowners captured by unaffordable, predatory loans.

Those are still a problem, of course. But the notion that foreclosure is not an unfortunate end, but rather a means to an end, is new and unaddressed. The national credit bureau Experian commanded a study of this behavior, and found it happens more often that we'd have thought.

And, incredibly, twice as often as the housing industry thinks it happens — almost 600,000 times alone in 2008, according to its analysis. (In Maine, new state data says foreclosures are increasing at modest rates, but this is only a snapshot of activity. The state only watches Maine-based lenders.)

How many of these might be "strategic defaults" is unknown. What is apparent, however, is this strategy controverts the entire principle of indebtedness, and indicates the punishment for failing to make good on debts are far too weak, or have become watered down.

This could be the end result of our bailout culture, in which those responsible for creating and amassing incredible financial liabilities — such as investment banks, automakers, whoever — have not suffered the consequences for their actions. For all intents and purposes, these entities have gotten away with it.

Not totally, of course, but in principle. These high-profile examples of escaping their fate have apparently permeated down to otherwise respectable homeowners. If they can get away with it, the internal argument might go, so can I. Why should I pay, when they do not?

Yes, this is pure supposition. It's not unreasonable. Parents try to teach their children that every bad action has its consequences, for example. What happens when this basic premise is violated, and the threat of punishment is removed from the equation?

There used to be debtor's prisons, for example — a strong incentive to pay. Now, the threat is to credit and one's future ability to borrow. So the punishment for strategic default is a slightly lesser chance of doing the same thing again?

Nothing good, we think. Which is why we need, as a nation, to talk about debt. Debt is an obligation to be met, not a regulation to be skirted. If we are operating under the assumption that debt shall never be paid, or doesn't need to paid, or can be ditched, something is wrong.

The buck must stop somewhere.
Right?

editorialboard@sunjournal.com

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Displaying comments, from newest to oldest

big daddy's picture

This is what happens when

This is what happens when people treat the banks the way the treated them. The Republican's will be proud.When I started my job I was paid $6.36 hr. in 1987 and now 21yrs. later businesses have the nerve to offer $8.00 an hr. That's why the middle class is shrinking to low income.

mad dad's picture

Who has had to pay a Federal

Who has had to pay a Federal Income Tax Rate of 90%?? I'm 75 and haven't paid that much in my lifetime. I have always paid Federal and State income tax and still do.

tron's picture

How much were you making

How much were you making when you were 25? The upper rate then was 90%. I don't think you were in your peak earning years, yet.

jalbrecht1's picture
verified

If this editorial was

If this editorial was intended to strengthen a culture of obligation. Fine. People should pay their bills and its no excuse that others aren't. If people can afford it this is a good time to meet their obligations. But this is not the time for the nation to reduce its debt. With growth rates below 1% and the chance for double digit inflation or a double dip recession now is not the time to reduce national debt. When growth is 3% reducing the debt slowly in sync with growth is absolutely necessary. We have committed 11.6 trillion dollars. Without a program to control that debt, economic chaos may be soon to follow.
Jon Albrecht Dixfield

sheesh's picture

Your RIGHT, people should

Your RIGHT, people should pay their obligations! It's people who don't that are making it harder on everyone else because it's driving up the interest rates etc. It makes me mad when I pay my bills and some one I knows sits and laughs cause they think they screwed over the credit card company when in fact they just screwed me over...

jalbrecht1's picture
verified

"they just keep spending the

"they just keep spending the taxpayers money and raising taxes." When went out into the labor market Federal Income Tax's top rate was 90%. Today its 35%. That doesn't sound like "they just keep .... raising rates". Maybe, just maybe something else is wrong about "mad dad" and fixit001's conclusions.
Jon Albrecht Dixfield

mad dad's picture

jPoliticians have no shame,

jPoliticians have no shame, no morals, or pride, they just keep spending the taxpayers money and raising taxes. It's all about the power and the Party, to hell with the people who elected them. They have passed laws and procedures to keep themselves insulated from any monetary or physical problems so theyare able to live in a world of their own. They don't know what it is to lose a job or be late on a car or house payment. They don't care if electric or heating oil bills, or the price of gasoline skyrockets. They have completely lost touch with the real world and act accordingly. That includes BOTH political parties. The voters should be really upset with the wholesale wasteful spending of both the state and national goverment and vote them all out. They are all millionaires so they won't have any trouble being retired.

jebbie47's picture

You make some very good

You make some very good points which I do agree however the corruption of government goes way back, but this admin. is the pinnacle of corruption.

fixit001's picture

How much did MBNA pay you

How much did MBNA pay you for that editorial???? Many have no option but to walk away why because you fail to mention the graft for which our politicians (whores) that allow the plunder of all citizens such as medical insurance which has climbed at the same alarming rate that the politicans coffers have and the oil also the same as well as the financial sector do you see a clue as to the fault here??? DUH so yeah many are so pinched by this sickening events they have no choice but walk away hell the state and city just keeps rasing thier taxes while giving themselves AND thier family 100% health coverage Do you know what the value is of that?? about 1500.00 a month this is a crime!!! When our public servents are paid 30% better than the average taxpayer and no end in sight as well as the amount of employees which the State and city will not combine jobs and eliminate hell they will bend over backwards and give pensions and still a salery why do you not complain about that or the highest cost in the WORLD for prescriptions THE WORLD!! OH SORRY THAT MAY HURT YOUR AD CLIENTS HUH???? Your a RAG WITH A ONE SIDED OPINION AND WILL ALWAYS BE JUST THAT!!!

Advertisement