GOP standoff: National Republican panel, Paul supporters fail to reach compromise

Robert F. Bukaty, Associated Press

Republican presidential candidate Rep. Ron Paul, R-Texas, campaigns in Freeport in January 2012. At a raucous GOP state convention that was taken over by Ron Paul forces, supporters of the libertarian-leaning Texas congressman captured 21 of 24 of Maine's delegate seats to the national convention, set for Aug. 27-30.

AUGUSTA, — A national Republican committee offered a scathing analysis of Maine’s GOP convention at which a slate of Ron Paul supporters was chosen to represent the state at the national convention in Tampa next week. As a result, the full Republican National Committee voted late Thursday morning to support a compromise that would seat 10 Maine delegates pledged to presidential candidate Ron Paul and 10 alternate delegates who support Mitt Romney.

The vote follows a Committee on Contests ruling Wednesday that flaws with the way Maine’s state GOP convention unfolded in May and invalidated the selection of 20 Maine delegates committed to Paul.

“The convention was riddled with serious credentialing, ballot and floor security issues affecting the election … of delegates,” the 26-page report concluded. The problems started, the report said, when the convention doors opened at 8 a.m. Saturday, May 5 and a line of people waiting to check in stretched a quarter mile across the parking lot.”

Brent Tweed, one of the contested delegates, who served as chairman of the Republican State Committee in May, said Thursday night that despite the Committee on Contests’ report and recommendations, he and other Paul supporters from Maine have not given up and were pinning their hopes on a RNC credentialing committee hearing scheduled for Friday morning.

“We’re going to propose that all the original 20 delegates be seated,” said Tweed, who was in Tampa on Thursday. “We think that facts and logic are on our side. We think we have a fair shot at seating all our delegates.”

Tweed said he hadn’t read the Committee on Contests’ report closely, but had heard during the day Thursday what it contained — namely an indictment of the way the state convention was held.

“They’re saying the convention wasn’t properly run, that we didn’t follow up on procedures,” he said. “That’s complete opposite of what happened. We held a proper convention. I think this decision is just a political decision because we don’t support the right candidate.”

The report identified a number of problems with the process that unfolded at the state convention. The credentials committee at one point during the two-day convention said 336 delegates were in attendance from Aroostook County. A delegate said this was absurd and the committee later said there were 79 delegates from The County, the report said. The delegate said that was also absurd and that the most The County had ever had at the convention was 46 delegates. A motion was made, and accepted, to change the number of Aroostook County delegates at the convention to 46.

Immediately after, a motion was made to reduce the number of delegates from Franklin County from 70 to 57, the report said.

As a result of this and other problems it chronicled, the report said, “the committee is not satisfied that the conduct of the state convention allowed the will of the body to be able to be known and expressed on the election of the … delegates from the state of Maine.”

The contest committee suggested a new slate of delegates split between Paul and Romney supporters.

The move represents another setback for Paul supporters who seek to seat all 20 Maine delegates pledged to the libertarian-leaning U.S. representative from Texas at the national convention.

Ashley Ryan, a Paul supporter who was elected Maine’s new Republican national committeewoman during the state party convention, is at the national convention site in Tampa, Fla. She reaffirmed Thursday morning that her group will not agree to any compromise.

“We were all duly elected and we should all be duly seated,” said Ryan. “When you look at the case, it would be an embarrassment to the party, to [presumptive presidential nominee] Mitt Romney and to Maine if we’re not seated.”

Peter Cianchette and Jan Martens Staples, longtime Maine Republican party leaders and Romney supporters, challenged the results, arguing that lax credentialing and security at the state convention allowed unqualified participants to cast votes.

The contest committee urged Republican leaders and Paul supporters to work out a compromise. Maine’s delegation remains the lone holdout not to have reached an agreement on how many of the disputed delegates will be recognized at the national convention.

The 20 Paul delegates remain united in rejecting any compromise proposal, Ryan told the Bangor Daily News by phone Thursday morning. The Paul delegates have received no new compromise proposal and are not in regular contact with Republican party officials or representatives of the Romney campaign, she said. Lawyers representing the Maine delegates continue to work on their behalf.

On Wednesday, Matthew McDonald of Belfast, a Paul-backing Maine delegate, told the BDN, “No compromise: Seat all of us or seat none of us.”

On Thursday, McDonald reiterated his position that the Paul delegates would not compromise and characterized the Committee on Contests decision as a “recommendation.” He noted that Gov. Paul LePage has promised not to attend the convention if the Maine group isn’t seated.

When contacted by phone Thursday morning, Brent Littlefield, a political adviser to LePage, declined to comment on whether the governor would attend the national convention. “At the point when I have a comment, I’ll issue a public statement,” he said.

Pete Harring, a Paul delegate, will attend the convention. His flight leaves Saturday morning.

“I was a duly elected delegate and I’m going to Tampa,” he said Thursday morning. He intends to be on the convention floor Monday. “It looks like this is going up to the last minute,” Harring said of whether he will be recognized as a delegate.

Ryan expects a decision from the credentials committee by Friday. If that panel rules against seating all 20 Maine delegates committed to Ron Paul, “We’ll have a meeting of the delegation to decide what we’ll do next,” she said.

If they do not receive credentials, Ryan and Harring said Thursday that the Paul delegates from Maine would explore finding someone to make a motion from the convention floor to seat them.

The Paul campaign hopes that it can have enough delegates seated to place Paul’s name into nomination during the convention, which would allow him to make a speech.

Earlier this month, Webster offered a compromise to the Paul delegates. His deal would have let them attend the convention but obligate them to vote for Mitt Romney if Paul doesn’t have sufficient support to be nominated for president.

The Paul supporters rejected that plan.

Last week, Maine delegates who back Paul sought an injunction against the Republican National Committee to stop it from investigating whether they were legitimately chosen to represent the state at the GOP convention.

Bangor Daily News writer Christopher Cousins contributed to this report.

What do you think of this story?

Login to post comments

In order to make comments, you must create a subscription.

In order to comment on, you must hold a valid subscription allowing access to this website. You must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. To subscribe or link your existing subscription click here.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned from posting comments.



Jim Cyr's picture

Compromise ??

Why compromise when you are right ? All the "establishment G O P " is trying to do is do all they can to keep Rep. Paul from speaking at the convention. "They can't stand the truth" being expressed so more can hear it. Shame on Cianchette and Staples !! The only good that will come of this, is maybe a lot more people will see the great benefit of drinking more TEA !

Steve  Dosh's picture

GOP standoff: National Republican panel, Paul supporters fail to

all, 12.08.23 10:30 hst ƒlyday
Decide to decide ?
The g o p can't find their way out of a paper bag
hth ? /s Steve

Edward S Phillips 's picture

Leaving party

Will go to town office today and unregister as an Republican.
The 2 so called leaders or RINOS do not lead me or speak for me.
They can not understand that we no longer want the people who helped put this country and state in such terrible shape to think they are the know it alls.
Not a Ron Paul supporter but he has more good idears about solving the problems than the RINOS. Good buy party. Will not vote for Mitt only others on the ballott.

Amedeo Lauria's picture

Very interesting...

Gee whiz, so what does the Democrats unwillingness to stand behind their nominee for US Senate mean. They have abandoned her in favor of "Independent" Angus King for political reasons. The sausage making of politics applies to both sides, I guess I must be reading different media, conservatives look to the state of Maine with hope that it can be duplicated in their state. Join me in November in voting for conservative candidates who understand that people work hard for their money and don't want it redistributed by the local, state or federal government, unless it is for the common good, and not to build a voting base.

Steve  Dosh's picture

Amadeo , ƒlyday Cleaning

Amadeo , ƒlyday
Cleaning up after the elephants ?
No , t y v m <3
/s, a registerd Democrat from the birth state of our President , the former good senator from Illinois and his family

FRANK EARLEY's picture

When, When, When....

When is the Republican party going to stop making the state of Maine, the biggest joke in the nation. Could someone explain to these idiots, that they are wasting valuable time on a non-issue. Maybe something constructive for the state might be of more value. What am I saying? That goes against everything they stand for.....

Steve  Dosh's picture

Frank , . A; l8tr .

Frank ,
. A; l8tr . .not earlier . 2020 ¿
/s. Steve
ref :


Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...