F. Lee Bailey, a longtime attorney who has represented many high-profile clients, including O.J. Simpson and Patty Hearst, was denied a bid to practice law in Maine.
Bailey, 79, passed the Maine Bar Examination in February. He had been licensed in Massachusetts and, later, in Florida. But he was disbarred in both of those states in the early 2000s following a Florida Supreme Court ruling on seven counts of attorney misconduct stemming from his handling of a case involving an accused marijuana dealer.
Bailey spent 44 days in federal prison before he was released after repaying millions of dollars worth of stock in a pharmaceutical company he had transferred from his former client's assets.
"Mr. Bailey has not met his burden of demonstrating by clear and convincing evidence that he possesses the requisite good character and fitness necessary for admission to the Maine Bar," five members of the State of Maine Board of Bar Examiners concluded in a 22-page decision in November.
Four other members of the board wrote a minority opinion in a seven-page dissent.
In it, they said that Bailey had demonstrated "by clear and convincing evidence that he has the moral qualifications, competency and learning in the law and has otherwise satisfied the factors established by the Maine Bar."
The majority members pointed to a number of factors that guided their decision, including the disbarments, recurring income tax questions and Bailey's uncertain residency status.
Bailey appeared before the Maine Board of Bar Examiners on Oct. 31 to "resolve doubt regarding Bailey's good character and fitness to practice law in light of the past disbarments," the majority members wrote.
At that hearing, Bailey presented several witnesses who testified on his behalf, including Deborah Elliott, his partner, with whom he lives in Yarmouth.
He also offered to be supervised by Maine attorney Stephen J. Schwartz, who had agreed to confer monthly with Bailey regarding case management and clients' funds.
According to the Board's written report, Kenneth Fishman, an associate Justice of the Massachusetts Superior Court who had worked with Bailey as a law partner and continues their friendship, said the case resulting in Bailey's disbarment was an "aberration" and that "Bailey's demeanor since (the Claude) Duboc (case) is now less arrogant and 'far more humble' than before."
Bailey also submitted numerous affidavits and letters that spoke to his good character, including former Maine Gov. John Baldacci.
The majority report cites a Maine Bar rule that says it treats an attorney who has been disbarred in any other state "as if the attorney has been disbarred also in Maine."
One of the six factors the Board is required to consider in determining whether an applicant should be readmitted to the Bar is whether "the petitioner recognizes the wrongfulness and seriousness of the misconduct."
The majority of the Board concluded that he had not recognized the wrongfulness of his past conduct.
"Rather than accepting that he was disbarred because of his own misconduct, Bailey continues to place blame elsewhere," the majority wrote.
The Board members also wrote that Bailey was "less than forthright with this Board throughout the admissions process."
The Sun Journal was unable to reach Bailey for comment Monday.