Gubernatorial candidate Woods proposes eliminating 108 Maine towns

Troy R. Bennett/Bangor Daily News

Steve Woods, president and CEO of TideSmart Global and a gubernatorial hopeful, explains his vision for bolstering Maine's economic future at in his office in Falmouth. His plan would involve eliminating 108 Maine towns that consume five times as much state resources they are able to contribute.

FALMOUTH — Gubernatorial hopeful Steve Woods unveiled an economic strategy Tuesday that could result in the closure of more than 100 small Maine towns and redirect their state dollars — and potentially their residents — toward more urban centers.

Woods said the state now invests too much maintaining infrastructure to reach a widely dispersed population and it’s unsustainable. In his report, Woods states that 108 Maine towns receive five times as much in state and federal subsidies as they generate in local taxes and fees.

In short, the study contends the state’s “underlying problem” can be summed up as “more than 100 Maine communities that cost hundreds of millions of dollars a year to sustain while making very little contribution to the wealth and capacity of our state.”

While the theory behind Woods’ plan was substantiated, at least in part, by one of Maine’s best-known economists, the strategy didn’t sit well with the manager of Milo, the only small town cited in the report by name.

The study, titled “Maine Forward: 2020 Vision for Maine’s Economic Future,” is only 11 pages but was developed using data culled from thousands of pages of statewide municipal budgets going back at least a decade.

“I’ve realized as the chairman of the Yarmouth Town Council that governments are not commercial businesses, but some measure of business mathematics still applies,” Woods told the BDN on Tuesday. “If your expenses continue to exceed your revenues, you become insolvent. You can delay that by taking on debt, and you can mask it by seeking out more in grants and other subsidies. But I’ve found that there are 108 towns which — by no fault of the leaders there and by no fault of the people who have lived there, sometimes for generations — are basically insolvent.”

And those municipalities are drawing down state resources that could be used to make Maine’s urban centers — such as the Portland, Bangor and Lewiston areas, which already are home to 93 percent of new capital investments in the state, he said — more competitive on the global market.

Woods said the main thrust of his plan would be to level out tax disparities among municipalities around the state, meaning those communities he said are absorbing five times as much in state and federal subsidies as they’re generating in local tax revenues would begin to see less aid from Augusta.

In addition to cutting funding to those towns, he would seek to reduce the number of roads and highways — among other infrastructure obligations — the state is responsible for maintaining. Woods then would seek to support programs that would make it easy for residents in those targeted towns to pack up and move to more populated areas, perhaps through giveaways of publicly owned properties and tax waivers.

Woods declined to name the 108 towns he identified as underperformers, but used the 2,300-person Piscataquis County town of Milo as a case study in his report. Woods, who penned the report himself with the help of two research volunteers, wrote that while there are 377 jobs in the town, 576 residents receive state aid and 855 receive Social Security payments.

David Maynard, town manager of Milo, said Woods is “on the fringe of the fringes” with his new economic plan.

“As a town manager who has specialized in small towns all over the country … I’m very much aware that there is a portion of the American public who loves and cherishes small towns,” Maynard said. “I think it’s fair to say there’s a decent amount of people who would seriously resent a plan that would move their lives and businesses out of town. Not everybody wants to live in a city.”

Woods acknowledged Tuesday that giving the towns more infrastructure to pay for and less money to pay for it with, as well as encouraging mass relocations, could essentially create “ghost towns.”

“I don’t want to say, ‘Hey, I want to close down 108 towns,’” Woods said. “My plan is to give people in those towns more options.

“I’m not suggesting in any way we mandate people move,” he added. “You can have your 2-acre plot [in an underperforming rural town], but somebody in Lewiston-Auburn shouldn’t have to be subsidizing it.”

During a visit to Milo during the weekend, Woods wrote that he met a retiree who “lives a comfortable but by no means affluent life,” as well as two waitresses — an unwed mother in her mid-20s who is aspiring to qualify for subsidized housing and a 17-year-old who plans to move to Portland as soon as she graduates high school.

Those individuals, he suggested, represent drivers of the downward economic spirals he said are facing communities such as Milo. Young people, who are statistically more likely to be entrepreneurs and support education, relocate from the towns and leave behind mostly retired people or those who don’t have the means to leave.

“We are putting a disproportionate amount of resources into economic zones that are not performing,” he said. “We are giving just enough support to some of these places to suspend them in economic despair.”

Charles Colgan is chairman of the University of Southern Maine’s Muskie School of Public Service’s Community Planning and Development Program and is one of the state’s best-known economists. Colgan said on Tuesday he’s familiar with Woods’ plan and “I agree with him on parts and disagree with him on parts.”

“I think he’s right in the sense that most of the growth in Maine has been and will continue to be in the urban areas, and that does require a fair amount of attention toward how urban areas are going to grow and what resources that will take,” Colgan said. “Having said that, I don’t necessarily think the way to do that would be at the expense of the rural areas.”

Colgan said he believes the state’s rural outlying communities “have a lot of life left in them.”

“We’re going to face a point in the next 10 or 20 years where you’re looking at a group of very small towns with almost entirely elderly people in them, and we may have to make some decisions about how much in the way of resources we want to devote to those places,” the economist said. “But we tend not to say as a first order of business we’re going to abandon those places. I think we talk about maybe combining them and about how we’re going to serve them more efficiently.”

About 150,000 people combined live in the 108 towns Woods described Tuesday as “underperforming,” at an average population of less than 1,400 per municipality cited. That means more than 1.1 million Mainers would not be initially affected by the plan, Woods said.

“For every mile that you separate people from important services, like education and health care, you add resources and time,” he said. “Everything about the new economy — whether you’re talking about banking, labor, commerce or technology — is tied to speed and efficiency. The farther you go away [from urban hubs], the less speed and efficiency you have.”

In his document, Woods notes that the resource-based industries that motivated the dispersed settlement of Maine 100 or 200 years ago, such as timber harvesting and commercial fishing, have fallen on hard times, and the new science- and technology-driven economy depends on clusters of highly educated skilled workers.

In addition to his Yarmouth Town Council service, Woods is CEO of the Falmouth technology and marketing firm TideSmart Global, which lists powerful international clients such as the Lowe’s home improvement store chain, Walmart and digital camera maker Olympus.

Woods ran as an independent in 2012 for the U.S. Senate seat ultimately won by former Gov. Angus King and now he’s running as a Democrat for the Blaine House.

Incumbent Republican Gov. Paul LePage and independent Eliot Cutler also have registered as potential 2014 gubernatorial candidates with the Maine Ethics Commission, while Democratic 2nd District U.S. Rep. Mike Michaud and former Gov. and Rep. John Baldacci have said they are mulling runs for the job.

Democrat David Slagger and Alex Hammer, who is unenrolled, also have filed with the ethics commission.

The upcoming gubernatorial race could be crowded, but with his newly released — somewhat radical — economic platform, Woods is hoping to differentiate himself from many of the better-known candidates in the pack. For better or for worse.

“This is the ultimate inconvenient truth,” Woods said. “Every time I bring it up, people say, ‘You’re absolutely right, but people aren’t going to vote for you,’ or ‘People are going to be angry.’ I’m not trying to make people angry, but our elected officials should be expected to make decisions that are sometimes uncomfortable. There’s nobody in the political landscape who wants to do this, because in my opinion, it’s the hard path.”

Milo Town Manager Maynard had a warning for Woods and any other candidate who plans to reduce state aid to municipalities.

“Any candidate who thinks he can run roughshod over the rural part of Maine probably has another thing coming,” he said. “They vote in the cities, but if you stomp on the rural population, you’ll likely know it at the polls.”

What do you think of this story?

Login to post comments

In order to make comments, you must create a subscription.

In order to comment on, you must hold a valid subscription allowing access to this website. You must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. To subscribe or link your existing subscription click here.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned from posting comments.



PAUL ST JEAN's picture

So, if Mr. Woods has his way,

So, if Mr. Woods has his way, the sign at the state line will read, "Welcome to Maine.The Way Life Used to Be."
Doesn't sound quite right, does it?

John Ponte's picture


Mr Woods and Karl Marx have a lot in common.

Only Communist regimes do just what Mr Woods would like to do to the people
of the small towns in MAINE!

Mr's woods thinking is right out of the Communist Manifesto of Karl Marx!

If people living is large city bring a + tax base to the citys ,then why are most all of the big citys ,not only in Maine but in a lot of other states hurting just as bad ?

The fedral goverment had to step in with money to bale out New York City a few years ago , because New York could not pay it's bills !!

Truly it is because people just as Mr's woods ,have bought up the companys that where in these small towns and move then to some small town over sea's or into some small country in Latin America.
That is what has happen to the Tax base in these small towns !

I don't know of any election that was won in this state with out the rural vote ..
All of the citys didn't vote for LePage and he won because of the power by the people in small town Maine .
Don't know where you got your facts about elections in Maine ,but the citys don't do it .
Any way the Mr's Woods has shot him self in the foot with this idea of his ,as if he would be elected .
I don't even think the people in these citys would want the rest of the people in Maine to move in on top of them .

Plus where would all the people work?

These isn't enought work for the people is these citys to keep all of the people in the citys working .

The the State largest cluster of unemployed and the largest pay out in welfare is in the citys ,not the small towns .

Small town do have a problem coming up with the money form the state mandates .
Maybe the State should stop telling the towns what they need to spend mony on.

Mr's Wood's even wants to shut down roads into the small towns .
The roads belong to the state in most of these town .

But for last but lease Mr' Woods should know that his idea is never going to happen because we live in a country of freedom!
We as a people can live any where in this state or country we want to as citizens of the United States .

Maine is not in the old USSR or even Red China!!!

Thoes are the country's that MR' Woods Idea may work but I don't think so .
Our Freedom is worth a lot more than any amount of money .
There is a lot more to life than the botton line of a bean counter's spreed sheet!!!

Glenn Aho's picture

Is it just me or does his

Is it just me or does his idea smack of Agenda 21?

Alice Barnett's picture

small towns

expenses continue to exceed your revenues, you become insolvent. You can delay that by taking on debt, and you can mask it by seeking out more in grants and other subsidies.

or you give tax payers the choice; town plows for $ or u do.

John Ponte's picture

Woods is so smart that he is really stuip!!!

Just where did you grow up in a building that is twenty stories or more .
I ,for one live in Maine in a small town .
As if you, or anyone that wants to shut down3/4 of Maine's town's is going to be voted into any office here in Maine .
There is a lot more to life in Maine ,than money .
Money is not going to fix any of the so call problems, of not haveing more money for goverment to spend.

The real problem is there isn't any one strong or smart to say lets stop spending till we have the money to spend in Gorvement!!!.

There is no way you will ever get the people in Maine to live in one or the other bigger citys,as you want an turn our small towns dust .

Truly if all the people did move on top of each other in these citys the citys would go broke also .

The last I knew the bigger citys are hurting also they don't have the money to support there school systems at all . .

The tax rates in the big citys have gotten so high that the people that have live in these citys, all of there lives, have to move to the country so they can live on there retriment check .

I think you need to stop smoking what ever you are smoking because you are really blowing smoke .

I am 62 years old and this idea of yours is the most stuiped idea I have ever heard of to this date .

I can't even laugh at it ,because it's so stuip .

Do something else to do with your money because there is no way you are going to sit in the govermor's office or any office in this state .

People like yorself is why the middle class is hurting you guys are allways looking to strip the middle class of what they do have to better yourselfs .

Jason Theriault's picture

Oi vey

First off - if you're going to call someone stupid, you can't misspell it.

Secondly - the Office of Governor is statewide popular vote. So if more than 50% of Maine's population lives in the cities(which they do) you can win without rural Maine voters.

Third - The real problem is there isn't any one strong or smart to say lets stop spending till we have the money to spend in Gorvement!!!.
Isn't that what he advocating? He wants to cut off funds to rural Maine because it isn't self sufficient.

Fourth: Truly if all the people did move on top of each other in these citys the citys would go broke also .
No, they would get more tax revenue, and they would prosper.

PAUL ST JEAN's picture

You use a hackneyed term like

You use a hackneyed term like "oi vey" and you call the guy out on his spelling?
Parrot, wax up the plank!! We have a walker.

FRANK EARLEY's picture

Just what we all need.....

Just what we need, another difficult decision maker. We have one already who's only difficult decision is which segment of the poor he is going to screw next. Now we have a guy who wants to relocate everyone into cities, I couldn't imagine moving to Maine, and wanting to live in a small town, what are those people thinking? Put "em" all in downtown Lewiston, That will teach them to seek peace and quiet.
I'm sorry, but I would like to know where Mr. Woods is from, or more precisely, which parallel universe did he cross over from? I doubt he originated on this one. I moved here thirty years ago, I moved to escape the growing hustle and bustle of Massachusetts. Go down there today and see what happens when everyone lives in an urban area. In a few weeks I'm moving back out to the boondocks, I like it out there, I just hope it's not one of those towns threatened with Mr. Woods extinction. I would hate to have to move further away. Although I've always had a liking for Jackman.....

PAUL ST JEAN's picture

Go for it.

Go for it.

FRANK EARLEY's picture

I can't wait...

In my frail condition, I can only handle peace and quiet, slowly, one level at a time, besides i can't move until my boat trailer melts out of the snow bank out back.....

CAROL PARKER's picture


When did we become Soviet Russia?

PAUL ST JEAN's picture

It began when LBJ decided to

It began when LBJ decided to form "The Great Society".

Thomas Hamilton's picture

Is he serious?

Joseph Stalin would be proud. How about the small farms in Maine that are struggling, shall they form collectives so they can run more "efficiently"? Maybe all the old folks could be forced into "retirement homes" so they could be more efficiently cared for. Perhaps all of rural Maine could then become a big wilderness park for occasional visitors from the ever-expanding cities.

Well at least this gets Woods some press coverage.

PAUL ST JEAN's picture

"How about the small farms in

"How about the small farms in Maine that are struggling"....
They could grow corn which could be used in the processing of ethanol which would entitle them to corn subsidies from the federal government. 0O:-)


Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...