Violence is not a family value

Leanna Norris confessed to police that she drove her 2 1/2-year-old daughter to a remote road in Newport on June 23, gave the child two or three syringes of Benadryl to make her go to sleep, placed duct tape across the child’s nose and mouth and then covered the toddler with a blanket. Norris didn't want to look at the child's eyes as she suffocated.

The chilling confession was contained in a search warrant affidavit that was unsealed by a Penobscot County Superior Court justice Friday.

That warrant is a narrative of family violence and the reality is far worse than it appears.

The child’s father knew something was wrong the day before his daughter died, and tried desperately to find her, calling police for help and posting desperate pleas on Facebook.

By the time his daughter was found, she was dead.

Violence in families is often associated with domestic violence, which is violence between intimate partners, but family violence is more far-reaching than that and there are far fewer services and programs available to help these victims or to identify offenders.

The victims of family violence include children and the elderly. The offenders are parents assaulting children, siblings assaulting each other, children assaulting their aging parents, and many other scenarios.

The Norris case is not unique. We’ve seen too many deadly family violence cases in Maine, including the tense 18-hour standoff on Minot Avenue in Auburn in 2007 during which 42-year-old James Michael Peters shot his mother in their driveway. He was killed hours later.

In 2008, Scott Poirier of Sabattus was convicted of manslaughter in the shooting death of his father, Roland Poirier. According to police, the son shot the father as payback for his father performing a sex act on him when he was a teenager. Poirier was facing a murder charge, but the jury considered his depression and abuse and convicted him of a lesser crime.

And, in 2011, Mainers were shocked by the discovery of the body of 6-year-old Camden Hughes alongside a road in South Berwick. His mother Julianne McCrery, lived in Texas, and later pleaded guilty to her son’s death. She admitted driving far from home to hide her crime. Like Norris, she was believed to have been suicidal at the time.

According to the U.S. Department of Justice, family violence accounts for about one in every 10 incidents of violence in this country. Of those crimes, about half were crimes against spouses — fitting the domestic violence definition — 11 percent were sons or daughters victimized by a parent, and the remaining cases were crimes against other family members, including the elderly.

According to Legal Services for the Elderly, an estimated 5 percent of Maine’s elderly population are victims of abuse, but a startling 84 percent of elder abuse cases go unreported because the elderly are often dependant on their abusers, which can include adult children, friends or caregivers.

Similarly, a large percent of crimes against children go unreported because children are often intimidated by and dependent on their abusers.

And, many other family crimes are not reported because the victims love and want to protect the offenders.

According to the most recent Department of Justice figures (compiled in 2005), most family violence victims in this country are white. “Most” means a whopping 74 percent.

And, most family violence offenders are white: 79 percent.

Of the victims, 66 percent were between the ages of 25 and 47.

Of the offenders, 62 percent were 30 years or older.

And, unlike other types of violent crimes that are most likely to occur in public places, most family violence crimes are committed in the victim’s home, in secret.

And, unlike other types of violent crimes, family violence offenders are far more likely to be under the influence of drugs or alcohol when committing these crimes.

The family violence data the Department of Justice examined most recently was collected between 1998 and 2002, which indicates a lack of study when compared to the annual study of domestic violence crimes.

A decade ago, according to the DOJ, of all the murders of women in this country, family members were responsible for 43 percent of them. And, eight in 10 murderers who killed a family member were male.

The average age of children killed by a parent was 7 years, and 4 out of 5 victims killed by a parent were under the age of 13.

Of the crimes family violence offenders serve prison time for, 78 percent of the crimes were against women, more than half were against a child under the age of 18, and more than a third were against a child under the age of 13, which means young women are more likely to be victimized by a family member than others.

The DOJ statistics indicate, during the years studied, that family violence crimes dropped from 1993 to 2002, but that’s the last year the department reported the data. It reports data on domestic violence crimes every year.

Since such a large portion of family violence crimes occur between partners, that greater level of attention to partner violence seems warranted, but not at the sacrifice of studying the contributors to family violence, so we can figure out how to control it and spare more victims.

Loh Melody Grenda, the little girl who was killed in Newport last month, was one of those victims.

She died in the dark, drugged and struggling to breathe.

We all owe her and other victims of family violence whatever help we can muster as a society, and as individuals.

Our families should be sanctuaries, not killing grounds.

The opinions expressed in this column reflect the views of the ownership and the editorial board.

What do you think of this story?

Login to post comments

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned from posting comments.



Steve Dosh, maybe we should

Steve Dosh, maybe we should ban syringes of Benadryl, and duct tape. (sarcasm)

Steve  Dosh's picture

Bob , Sunday 14:40 Happy

Bob , Sunday 14:40
Happy Bastille Day !
Violence is and has been a social norm here since Lafayette helped us out against the British after ƒirst landing in Annapolis , MD , the Treaty of Paris was negotiated and signed by Ben Franklin in Paris , Europe , that sucesfully ended our own particular revolution ( we are revolting , after all ) , and L'Enfant designed the District of Columbia conveniently for us ( much like Pairs , in fact - a low , small , southern & smelly city with plenty of round - a - bouts just going around in circles )
hth ? /s Steve
btw - i know about enough ƒrench to get my faced slapped :D

Steve  Dosh's picture

Violence is not a family value

W o w . Who'd a thunk ? Guns , families , kids & child abuse , and now Florida
My whole career was spent in the tropics ( Africa , Micronesia and Guatemala ) and we live here in Hawai'i now . We used to converse about ' jungle rot ' and ' brain rot ' in the tropics , ( 20º - 20º south of the equator ) , usually with reference to crazy and the foolish goings on they'ya
i was in FL last March for a visit with my dad ( in Tampa - St. Pete ) and was continually woken up at night by gunshots and people doing burnouts in their cars and loud , drunken revelry of that nature . In March . They have weird laws there , also
Repealed . It is illegal for a doctor to ask a patient whether they own a gun.
We'll stick with Maine rather than Flori-duh when ir comes to guns , families , kids & child abuse even though there is bronze statue of my grandfather , a newspaper editor , located in Ocala
Violence - is - a cherished family value and a social norm on the mainland US of A , it seems , judging by recent headlines
/s , Steve :D


Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...