Let God be the judge

I will vote "no" on Question 1 because I believe a person should have the right to marry the person he or she loves, regardless of sexual orientation.

Three of my children have celebrated the rite of marriage. My youngest, however, is denied this opportunity. He is committed to a loving relationship with another man. Together they have created a safe and loving home for my youngest grandchild. They share the same joys and sorrows of any other family. Yet, they are denied a legally recognized marriage. They deserve better.

It is not easy for me to speak out, especially when it means feeling alienated from the church that I have always considered a second home. I feel the door is closing on me and my family. It saddens me that the Catholic Church is fighting for the defeat of this law. Today, my church and I stand apart.

The law before us affects real lives, real people. Can any of us really judge the value of an individual union, heterosexual or homosexual? Each union is as unique as the individuals within it. To categorically assume a gay union is inferior is mean-spirited and not founded in reality. Let God be the judge.

Preserve the law that protects the right to marriage for all Maine citizens. Maybe then, doors will open, church pews will fill again, and we will all be welcomed home.

Yolande H. Dumont, Lewiston

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Displaying comments, from newest to oldest

wjnichols's picture

Another letter by a Catholic

Another letter by a Catholic who does not understand that her religion is about the salvation of souls. Don't let sex rule your life Yolande, bend your neck to the yoke of Jesus, whose burden is light.

Hook's picture

Who wrote Yolande's letter

Who wrote Yolande's letter for her? Certainly, she couldn't have done it herself. The woman's number than a pounded thumb.

Furthermore, she seems to know little about marriage. Let's just say that same-sex marriage is "anatomically-incorrect."

nutmeg's picture

I am an Episcopalian. Right

I am an Episcopalian. Right or wrong, if a couple is not religious why should I tell them they can't have a legal union? On the other hand, if they aren't religious why isn't a legal union good enough if it provides the same benefits? Why a marriage in the church? There are many people in the Christian church who don't have an issue with same sex couples choosing legal unions. But marriage is often performed in the church by pastors, priests, ministers (of various denominations) who are to be carrying out God's will (as is made known through the scriptures) and granting God's blessing on the married couple. So there are many I've talked with as I've tried to get all angles on the subject who seem to take this view-civil unions are okay but not marriages in the church. The bigger issue for me is that many denominations (especially mine) are going the way of political correctness and drifting away from the teachings of the church, those very principles the church was built on. If the Episcopal church believes, as it has stated, that there is nothing wrong with same sex unions from the perspective of religion, then they really ought to go back and change their own canons (tenets, articles whatever they are called). The Episcopal church today isn't really the Episcopal church at all. It is a new church and thus needs to come up with a new set of articles to represent her (can I say' her 'still?) stand on the issue of marriage as well as other things. Until they rewrite the articles of faith the Episcopal church of today is NOT really the Episcopal church, it is a new church. Instead of changing the Episcopal church why not write up a new set of articles of faith and maybe change the name while you're at it.
As for the comments about the Catholic church, how is that not hate speech? The church is made up of people, just like any other group, so the remarks above are directed at people, not at an institution. In some of the comments above the writer has done the very thing you accuse the church of doing. Whether you agree or not it IS a religious issue and the church has the right to take a stand on something so important. As for the Catholic church losing people, per Wikipedia it is still the largest Christian denomination with 1.147 billion members in 2007.

gdls1's picture

Nutmeg, This has nothing to

Nutmeg,
This has nothing to do with religious marriage; it has to do with civil marriage. Every couple who marries is issued a marriage license by the state, whether they are married in a church not. A marriage license automatically grants many legal, civil and financial rights and benefits. No church will be required to perform a marriage between two people of the same sex.

nutmeg's picture

The Episcopal bishop from NH

The Episcopal bishop from NH comes to Portland to speak in favor of the NO vote (one of the sponsors being the cathedral of st. lukes) and it has nothing to do with religion? there are plenty of fine speakers who are gay and NOT part of any religion who could have been asked to speak.

LewistonNative...'s picture
verified

I whole heartedly agree

I whole heartedly agree with, John28. My brothers, sisters and myself were raised by parents who were lesbians for much of our childhood lives. They didn't bother forcing religious on us. They left us free-thinking individuals to pick and choose as we see fit. That is why out of the 5 children 1 is Muslim, 1 a Buddist, 1 is an Athiest, 1 doesn't clam a religion and I myself am a Christian. As a Christian I have been associated with Baptists, Methodist, and Protestant churches, but have and never will claim or be associated with the Catholic church. Gays and Lesbians are good people and deserve a chance to be married to eachother just like any other couple who decides to do so. Vote No on 1.

Yolande what you wrote was quite touching and rather insipring, thank you.

Hook's picture

Sorry LewistonNative.

Sorry LewistonNative. Yolande can't write. Someone did it for her.

Hook's picture

Sorry LewistonNative.

Sorry LewistonNative. Yolande can't write. Someone did it for her.

jalbrecht1's picture
verified

So much of the discussion is

So much of the discussion is about religion is because after years of discussion the Yes side has produced not one rational reason to vote yes. All they have is their violent distorted misinterpretations of the Bible. If God is who they say he is then he is gay, straight, man, woman, black, and white.
God would vote NO.
Jon Albrecht Dixfield

Daymnnibmem's picture

What misinterpretations of

What misinterpretations of the bible are they using?

Rougamagree's picture

While these discussions of

While these discussions of religion and "what God wants" are interesting, this has to do with human dignity and spirit, and whether the State of Maine ought to recognize the same rights and privileges on homosexual unions as it does heterosexual unions.

When Maine passes a law allowing,say, hunting, it doesn't consult the Catholic Church or the Bible or some other religious text. It doesn't have one set of laws for Jews and another for other religious groups. In other words, Maine isn't beholden to any particular religion's set of core beliefs.

Does God have views on homosexual marriage? That's an interesting conversation, and the Catholic Church can lend its voice to THAT debate. But it's views are no more or less valid than Yolande's. Ultimately though, THAT debate isn't what is before the people of Maine.

This debate is about whether Maine wants to discriminate against some of its citizens on the basis of sexual orientation. You do not have to be gay -- in fact, you don't even have to like gays -- to be concerned about this kind of government-sanctioned discrimination. In fact, all it takes to vote "no" is a commitment to the ideals of freedom and equality for all. If you think about what those words mean, and you really believe in those concepts, then you know what to do.

gdls1's picture

Kman, I like the points you

Kman, I like the points you made in your post. Thank you.

jalbrecht1's picture
verified

The family is not the

The family is not the foundation of society; its the foundation of the church. Its also hiding place of male supremacy which is sanctified in the church and its dogmas. Male supremacy like white supremacy is a cancer in society and needs to be exorcised.
Jon Albrecht Dixfield

Daymnnibmem's picture

Pick your own church where

Pick your own church where you will get your ears will get tickled. Who needs sound doctrine, and principals? Plenty of liberal churches everywhere, take your pick!!!!

Tfunk's picture

Why does everyone keep

Why does everyone keep bringing God into this? HELLO people!!! God created all people!!! No matter sexual preference!!! Leave them alone and let them be happy together!!! What gives any church or person to decide what is right? If they feel it is right they get married... if it doesn't work (like many of opposite sexes) they get a divorce... I say NO on 1!!! Let them be happy!!! Are you?? Obviously some are not happy in their own marriages that they have to have something else to complain about! Find a new hobby!!! Go to church and do what you do but leave them alone!! This has gone on long enough!!! P.S. look up the word MARRIAGE in the dictionary... says nothing about man and woman... just united in happiness!!!

jchick's picture
verified

Yolande, As followers of

Yolande,

As followers of Christ, our beliefs should be based on the truth of God's Word. When we deviate from his instructions, we are no longer following the path that he has shown us, rather we are choosing our own way. God's design for marriage is, and always will be, one man and one woman for life. That will never change no matter how the vote turns out in November. God's will and his plan will remain the same. He has made it very clear in his Word as to what he (God) thinks about homosexuality. Nothing we do or say will ever change that. The good news is that while God hates sin, he loves sinners, so if we repent, i.e. turn away from our sin and toward him, he is ready and willing to forgive us and receive us into his family.

John A. Chick

"If a nation expects to be ignorant and free, in a state of civilization, it expects what never was and never will be." -- Thomas Jefferson in a letter to Colonel Charles Yancey (January 6, 1816)

Mac antSaior's picture
verified

People have fought, killed,

People have fought, killed, and died for their gods long before the Semitic tribes were found in the sand. Ruins still stand; erected by peoples who were certain THEY had the unalterable truth, only to fall beyond memory leaving nothing but sandstone carvings and foundations. The two thousand years Christians claim to have a lock on all of history for is but a blink of an eye in the life of a religion. Baal was worshiped longer.

It is the undauntable thought, my friend. The one that says, "I'm right!" ~Bobby Sands

John 28's picture

jchick The PATH I've chosen

jchick
The PATH I've chosen is to follow Jesus Christ teachings!! As simple as his words are: "Love one another as I have loved you"!!
How more simple can you get. Why so much hate on your part of God's children? I just can't understand you and people like you. LOVE is the word!! I've already voted NO on 1 by absentee ballot and I urge all to do the same.

nikita80's picture

One problem mankind has is

One problem mankind has is many people like to follow the god that they created rather than the God that created them.

Robert61's picture

Jami, by far regardless of

Jami, by far regardless of which side of the aisle anyone is on for this subject, that is the most intelligent, profound thing I have read in weeks on this blog, thank you.

Lil's picture
verified

God? Buddha?

God? Buddha? Allah?
______________________

"A conservative is a man with two perfectly good legs who, however, has never learned to walk forward."
Franklin D. Roosevelt

Mac antSaior's picture
verified

I don't seem to remember the

I don't seem to remember the Goddess Brigid saying anything on the matter.

It is the undauntable thought, my friend. The one that says, "I'm right!" ~Bobby Sands

Nancy1's picture

Good letter, Yolande, I

Good letter, Yolande, I appreciate the courage and love you show.
I believe one of the real reasons the Catholic church is against gay marriage is because same sex couples are a lot less likely to produce more Catholics. Anything that reduces their numbers, power, and money flow is a sin in the eyes of the church.

John 28's picture

Nancy, I so agree with you.

Nancy,
I so agree with you. The straight couple have a child, they have him/her baptized, but not always and that's the last that child will be in a church. I've seen it time and time again in our large family. Before long, they won't even have enough people to attend even one mass at any of the remaining 3, so they will all close, once the elders are have passed away. The next time they go into a church is to get married, to make it look good, then that is again the last time they go to a church and now this Bishop is kicking the rest of us out!!

jeanninetkevin's picture

God indeed is the judge and

God indeed is the judge and he has told us that the true sin of being gay is the pride against his word !

FC_Observer's picture

Wow, God told YOU that! Or

Wow, God told YOU that! Or did you get that from the same book that tells us to sell our daughters into slavery and that if our sons are stubborn and rebellious, they should be stoned to death.

gdls1's picture

Yolande, You are brave to

Yolande,
You are brave to take a public stand in support of marriage equality. Thank you for doing so.

Advertisement