Passing on 'dumb' joke not a smart idea

Maine is the dumbest state in the nation. 

The Internet says so.

Just Google "Maine dumbest" and see what comes up.

There's a very colorful map currently making social media and blog rounds for probably the second or third time, with the title: "The United States of Shame," and it purports to list what each state is worst at. And, apparently, the map's creators have determined that Maine is worst at being intelligent. Emblazoned across the blue-tinted state of Maine is "DUMBEST STATE."

It also proclaims North Dakota the "Ugliest," Ohio the "Nerdiest," and Nevada the ... well, state with the highest porn usage. 

Oh, OK. So, it's a joke, right?

But the map is also accompanied by a "statistics and rationale" section which states, authoritatively:  "Most stats taken from http://www.americashealthrankings.org/ and http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/rankings.html (unless otherwise noted).

Oh, OK. So, it's not a joke? 

Here's a little test: Google "Maine dumbest."  We did. And of the 10 results on the first page, the top three were headlined: "Maine: 'dumbest state' in the U.S., but at least we're not the ugliest;" "Is Maine the dumbest state in the Union?," and "Maine is the Dumbest State."

The first one was from the Bangor Daily News blog, the second from the website For the Sake of Science, and the third was from the Maine radio state WWMJ 95.7.

Eight of Google's top 10 results referred to this article; only two referred to articles about "dumb criminals" and "dumb laws." 

Now Google "California dumbest," or "Vermont dumbest," or "Ohio dumbest." Most of the time, the closest you will get is dumb state laws, or the state being called "dumb" by an editorial writer.

In the case of Vermont, the sixth result isn't really about Vermont: It is headlined: "Maine dumbest state" and refers to the Bangor Daily News blog about this map, published last week, where the writer happens to mention Vermont.

So, is it a joke or a serious list based on facts? What is this bit of trivia that no doubt has been consumed and passed on by millions over the two years since it was created?

The item was originally posted on, and is sourced to, the humor website pleated-jeans.com,  in January of 2011. The writer introduced the item this way on his website: "Whether it’s a fat population, high rate of STDs or excessive tax rate, it turns out that every state ranks dead last in at least one unsavory category." 

So was Maine the "dumbest state" in 2010? Well, it did come in last in SAT scores, according to the College Board, the source cited by pleated-jeans.com  But, that's not the whole story: Maine, which requires all students to take the SAT test, at 93 percent, had the highest percentage of its students taking the test in the country. Most of the 20 states with the highest scores had student participation rates only in the single digits. 

So, does that make it a "fact" that Maine is the dumbest state?

What is a fact, for sure, is that Maine now has that designation all over the Internet, and many of the references sited in Google don't refer back to the humor site where it originated.

What is also a fact is that most people who see this item — with its brightly colored map and snarky list — pop up on their Facebook page or inbox aren't going to think twice about where it came from or whether it's based on fact. They will just snicker and pass it on.

The fact is, some so-called "facts" on the Internet really aren't. Pass that on. 

hmccarthy@sunjournal.com

What do you think of this story?

Login to post comments

In order to make comments, you must create a subscription.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must hold a valid subscription allowing access to this website. You must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your SunJournal.com profile. To subscribe or link your existing subscription click here.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned from posting comments.

Advertisement

Comments

MARK GRAVEL's picture

Maine is the dumbest state. I

Maine is the dumbest state. I can understand that conclusion - SM...

PAUL ST JEAN's picture

A young lady from Calais was

A young lady from Calais was pulled over by a Maine State Trooper for exceeding the speed limit. When the trooper asked the young lady, "Do you have any I.D."? She said, "About what"?

Larry Mayes's picture

DUMBEST STATE

In some ways Maine is a tough competitor for the dumbest state, because of the many people we elect to office who cripple our society. Many of the elected strive beyond belief to compete with California for outrageous use of tax dollars. Congressional misfits gave us the mostly failed Stimulus and the pending disaster, Obamacare where the total expense to the nation will far outweigh the delivered product and will put many people out of full time work. Many doctors will opt out of practice good practices, or retiring from the profession and skilled staff let go to seek other jobs, perhaps flipping burgers.

Legislators of both parties have spent to the hilt many times over and refused to exercise reasonable caution or use valid numbers to budget for the things we need. They annually abdicate their responsibility to ballot initiatives so not to leave their thumbprints on the package driving up the cost of government.

Don’t take it to heart on these “Dumb” reports unless you only vote for tax and spenders or you have to lie to win a debate to justify unsustainable spending! That leaves us with token leaders unnecessary debt on children who will leave the state for a chance at success, rather than pay for Maine’s relentless folly.

Mike Lachance's picture

Maine's Dumbest Article

Pass it on...

CAROLYN LIBBEY's picture

Why is the Sun Journal

Why is the Sun Journal wasting space on this?

MARK GRAVEL's picture

Perhaps because the shoe

Perhaps because the shoe fits.

Advertisement

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...