Woman hit by puck sues city

AUBURN — A Lewiston woman who said she was hit in the face with a puck during a hockey game last year is suing the city of Auburn.

In a complaint filed this week at Androscoggin County Superior Court, Jennifer A. Richardson, 39, said she was at a hockey game between Messalonskee High School and Leavitt Area High School at Ingersol Arena on Jan. 5, 2008. Her son played for Leavitt, which used the arena as its home base.

Richardson served as timekeeper and scorekeeper during the game. When a puck lifted from the ice surface, it struck Richardson in the face, according to the lawsuit. She sustained "serious bodily injury," the suit says. She has incurred medical expenses as a result of the accident and will incur more. She also has lost income because of the injury and will continue to lose pay. She has suffered pain, mental anguish and loss of enjoyment of life. She is permanently impaired by the injury, the suit says.

Richardson's attorney, Anthony Ferguson of Lewiston, said his client suffered several fractures to bones under her eye socket, requiring surgery. She also suffered mild, traumatic brain injury, he said.

The accident resulted in permanent scarring and numbness, Ferguson said.

The complaint alleges that the city "negligently" built, designed, operated and/or maintained the timekeeper/scorekeeper's box where she sat during the game. The arena, in Pettengill Park, has been renovated since then.

City Manager Glenn Aho said Tuesday he hadn't read the complaint. It was forwarded to the city's insurance representative at the Maine Municipal Association. A spokesman for MMA said lawyers who handle such cases for the association don't comment on claims in process.

Richardson already sued the school's insurance carrier for payment of medical expenses, Ferguson said. The two parties reached a settlement, he said.

In 2004, Richardson filed suit against the Mid-Coast Recreation Center in Rockland, seeking damages in connection to injuries she received at a hockey game at the recreation center's ice arena in 2003. At the time, Richardson was attending a game and, as she moved to sit on the stands, stepped in some fluid, slipped and landed flat on her back on the concrete, according to that lawsuit.

Richardson, who was suing for medical bills, lost wages and impaired earning capacity as a result of the incident, settled that claim.

cwilliams@sunjournal.com

 

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Comments

Centarie2000's picture
verified

So in 2003 she slipped in

So in 2003 she slipped in someone's spilt soda which was done because of the center's negligence and fell on her backside and got some money from the Rockland Mid Coast Rec Center. Now, Auburn is out to get her by purposefully designing and building and maintaing a timekeeper/scorekeeper box just so that she can get hit in the face with a puck. She should stay away from sporting arenas because they are all out to get her. But then, how would she get attention and free money?

Robert61's picture

Well I was thinking I should

Well I was thinking I should sue Pepsi Co for making the twist off caps that hurt my wrist when I first open them - put on too tight. And then I'll sue Papa Johns, Dorito's and Snickers for the weight I gained due to their products (make them have a better disclosure - kinda like cigarettes). next I could sue almost any city in Maine for the anxiety caused by having to drive with some of the poor drivers in this town and for poor road conditions during a storm. We've become a suit happy society and are quick to sue whenever possible to make a quick buck - while not knowing any more of the story here I can't say what happened but last time i checked the back of the tickets at most sporting events has a disclaimer barring you from suing for injuries caused such as this. Unfortunately some people (and attorneys) understand that the threat of a suit can get you lots of money even if the suit would not prevail because no one wants to spend money on a court setting. I say make em go to court and if they lose, they pay court costs - that would significantly reduce the number of frivolous suits filed each year.

Wondering Aloud's picture

This woman has already sued

This woman has already sued the insurance company and decided to settle. If she wanted more money she should have continued her suit. She should not be allowed to sue other entities after already collecting on one suit for this incident. What next after Auburn? I think she should sue the student that shot the puck. How about sue the manufacturers of the game equipment? Let's sue the estate of whoever invented the game.

C'mon. This woman is sue happy and willing to get money anywhere she can.

Stores often post names of people that cannot buy with checks or credit cards that are proven to be no good. This woman should be posted at all Hockey arenas with a warning not to allow her in.

GreatApe's picture

this woman is clearly a

this woman is clearly a dirtbag

DonaldR's picture

I don't understand how she

I don't understand how she got hit if in the timekeeper's box??? The area is enclosed with plexiglass.

BillTheGorilla's picture
verified

And People wonder why

And People wonder why insurance costs so much !!! Makes you wonder what this loser will do next

yeah right's picture

so she may have really

so she may have really gotten hurt at this one, getting the ins. co to pay should be enough i would think... Ferguson needs his money too. Sounds like he loves suing people too.

garden master's picture

You are all idiots - Yes,

You are all idiots - Yes, she definitely planned on someone shooting a puck right at her face. Come on....

Centarie2000's picture
verified

I bumped my elbow today. I

I bumped my elbow today. I put it in a sling because it hurt soooo much and couldn't work. Can I sue to city and get money too? Life shoots lemons at you, you make lemonade and get a life and move on.

Blue Eyes's picture
verified

I'm with Bob67.......sounds

I'm with Bob67.......sounds like this woman makes a living doing this kinda thing. How ironic she has had these sort of lawsuits in the past. How many people is she going to sue over this puck incident? She already sued the school's insurance carrier, now she's suing the city. Next she'll sue the company that the materials came from...then on and on.
She's a con artist.........someone needs to wake up here!

Centarie2000's picture
verified

Are they sure all of the

Are they sure all of the injury comes from the puck? Should, say, a tooth that was already covered during a previous lawsuit and became looser from this incident be covered? This is why there should be a limit to the amount of times a single thing can be sued over. Yes, she has to live with the consequences for the rest of her life, but she should just move on before it begins to cost her money and respect. Perhaps a cap on the number of times a person can sue in a year? Some people add greatly, if not completely live off of, this sort of thing. It becomes addictive, free money for just getting a boo boo. People like this put too much strain and stress on all organizations and businesses and take so much away from events.

Turier's picture
verified

This is totally bogus! Just

This is totally bogus! Just another person looking for a free ride at the expense of others. She is an embarassment to her son who played on the team as well as to the Leavitt hockey family. My wife and I acted as timekeeper and scorekeeper on numerous occasions when our sons played hockey for Leavitt or the midget teams and we cannot picture how this woman could have been injured. The entire area was surronded by plexiglass with the exception of a hole in the glass just large enough for the officials to communicate with the timekeeper/scorkeeper. Unless she poked her face up against this hole during play, which is uncalled for, there is no way she could have been injured. Ingersoll arena is set up like all ice arenas throughout the country. It is peoples like Jennifer Richardson and Anthony Ferguson who make it difficult for recreational facilities to operate without increasing cost to those who rent the facilities to cover frivolous lawsuits. Shameless!!!!!!!

Ugh's picture

Do you think she planned for

Do you think she planned for someone to send the puck to her eye? Come on people, this was an accident and clearly she was hurt. These things do happen and she probably did lose work - note, it said she lost work, so she must work.

sredmun's picture

Sounds like she should stay

Sounds like she should stay away from hockey. She has really bad luck when she watches hockey.......

ojhuig's picture

How true, Emma!

How true, Emma!

ojhuig's picture

How true, Emma!

How true, Emma!

Lillian Kennedy's picture

Wow, this is incredible! I

Wow, this is incredible! I really hope that Auburn fights this!! I don't want my tax dollars going to pad the wallet of an obvious scam artist like this!!

Ginger1's picture

It's all fun and games till

It's all fun and games till someone loses an eye.

fixit001's picture
verified

she sounds like she is most

she sounds like she is most likely on the state and the taxpayers pay for her already but she likely needs smokes so what better way right people like that and the amblulance chasing lawyer make me sick sounds like we need to look at the medical work done as it could have been plastic surgery (free thanks to us) then again it could have been staged or self inflicted a full investigation into this should start to see if she is a con artist.

DR's picture

No kidding. Let's all start

No kidding. Let's all start attending Mainiacs games and claim injuries!

verified

Sounds like she makes a

Sounds like she makes a living doing this!

Advertisement

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...