Country needs real health care solutions — now

If the Obama administration has a strategy for passing health care reform, we certainly don't understand it.

First, the president reaches across the partisan divide to invite Republicans to a health care summit, scheduled to begin later today, and says he wants to hear ideas from all sides.

That's cool. Let's put some Republican stuff in the bill.

Then, three days before the summit, he resurrects — in nearly exact detail — the same plan that dead-ended in the U.S. Senate the month before.

Republicans, meanwhile, say they have a plan and will present it Thursday.

We hope they do, and we hope it includes something beyond tort reform and allowing health care insurance to be sold across state lines.

While those are both laudable ideas, and should be included in a final plan, experts say they will only put a small dent in what ails the U.S. health care industry.

As we've said before, there is a health care cost and access crisis, and we need look no further than the daily headlines to see it.

Anthem Blue Cross has drawn fire for announcing more than 20 percent rate increases in several states, including Maine. The requests probably reflect two things:

First, that Anthem has become accustomed to getting half to two-thirds of what it requests.  In other words, its executives in California probably feel a 25 percent rate increase will be whittled down to 12-15 percent by regulators, who will then declare victory and move on.

The pattern in Maine has been much the same. In 2009, the insurer requested 18 percent and got about 11.

This year, it has requested a 23 percent increase. What do you think? End up with 12 or 13?

Second, the exhorbitant requests really do reflect that health care costs are out of control, increasing an estimated 10 percent last year alone.

And this has been happening year after year, decade upon decade.

In 1970, U.S. health care spending was $75 billion, or about $356 per U.S. resident, and was 7.2 percent of gross domestic product, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation.

In 2009, we spent $2.5 trillion on health care, $8,160 per resident and it was 17.6 of GDP.

By 2018, if current trends continue, that will douple to $4.3 trillion, $13,100 per person and account for 20.3 percent of GDP. At that point, one in five dollars in our economy will go to health care.

Consider again our current 17.6 percent of GDP, then consider these numbers: Canada, 10 percent; France, 11 percent; Germany 10.6 percent; Japan 8.1 percent; United Kingdom, 8.4 percent.

Worse, research shows that these nations cover more of their people, have better overall health care outcomes and their citizens are happier with their care.

Can we afford a second-rate system that costs nearly twice as much?

Democrats may think they can ram an unpopular program through Congress. They could, but they shouldn't.

Republicans may think they can jam everything up until the next election. Again, they could, but they shouldn't.

The country needs leadership and solutions today, not posturing and bickering.

editorialboard@sunjournal.com

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Comments

DR's picture

Stonewalling is not an answer

Between the Republicans  in general stonewalling health care reform and that one pinhead from Kentucky cutting off unemployment benefits, I think even the blind should be able to see that Republicans care about nothing or nobody but themselves and their own wallets. So long as they have health coverage, to heck with everyone else. So long as they have jobs and income, to heck with everyone else.  We all know what happened to Marie Antoinette after she flippantly said of the poor, "let them eat cake".  The Republicans may find themselves eating crow in the next elections.

SSDD's picture

Government does things

Government does things significantly better and much more cost efficiently than private enterprise. Health care is just one example. Again I'll post this bit so you see how necessary a healthy government is:

A day in the life of an American.......

Ernest flipped on the lights in the pre-dawn dark.  He wouldn't have any lights(1), of course, if it wasn't for the TVA(2) that supplied electricity to his home which was wired many years ago (3)as a result of bringing electricity and telephones to rural America(4).  

He put coffee into the filter(5), poured water into the coffee maker (6) slipped some bacon into a frying pan(7), turned on the gas(8), and got a couple of eggs from the fridge(9).  While he was waiting for the coffee he decided to catch the morning radio show (10) then went to the bathroom where he did what most people do in the morning(11).   

1.  Regulations govern the voltage and frequency of the electricity, the safety of the delivery system and the appliances, the rates that can be charged, the recourses available as a citizen if the utility doesn't perform properly.  Four items and the guy's feet haven't even hit the floor!
2.  The TVA also made the Tennessee River navigable, besides supplying electricity. Two.
3.  Building codes make sure that the electrical wiring is correctly engineered and installed. 
4.  Beats oil lamps and tin cans on strings.  Thank you, FDR.  Two.
5.  The coffee made it to Ernest's table because of international trade laws, fair weights and measures, and federal trucking regulations.  Three.
6.  The water was safe to drink because of state and federal regulations.
7.  Ernest paid for a pound of bacon and got a pound, not less.  It was safe to eat, he would not get ill from it. Two.
8.  The gas was delivered safely and economically via a complex system of hardware and regulations. Two.
9.  The eggs were likewise of known quality and size.  Two. 
10.  The radio show came in without interference from other stations because of federal regulations allocating the frequencies available.  

Ernest hasn't even gotten to the bathroom and his life has been positively influenced 
by at least 20 areas of progressive policy and government regulations!

11.  See #3.  

Ernest plods back to the kitchen, fishes in the cabinet, and pulls out a few pill bottles.  He takes his vitamins and his prescription drugs for high blood pressure (12).   As a matter of curiosity, he looks on the tub of margarine to see how much sodium is in the spread (13).  He sighs and decides to scramble his eggs today.  

After he takes his shower, he selects his clothes (14), gets dressed, picks up his keys and other routine items, and heads out to his car.  After starting the engine (15) Ernest backs out of the driveway and heads to The Big City (16)  While he is driving, he enjoys the smooth road and gently rolling hills with its forests and meadows (17)(18).

12.  No doubt the pharmaceutical company that created the drug used large amounts of "pure" scientific research that was funded by the government through universities, research often considered worthless as it has no immediate practical application.   The effectiveness and purity of the drug was assured by the Food and Drug Administration.  Two.
13.  The FDA likewise mandates all food to be labeled so that Ernest can make informed decisions and avoid foods harmful to his health.
14.  Unfortunately, the government could not prevent Ernest from making horrible fashion mistakes.  However, mandatory information on tags of his shirts and pants told him that he could not just throw those wool pants into the washing machine.  So he takes them to the local dry cleaner, whose use of carcinogenic "perc" is highly regulated so that it doesn't get into the air and water. (Even though a lot has prior to environmental awareness.) Two.
15.  Ernest's engine started because the quality of the gasoline is tightly regulated.  It is also lead free thanks to the necessity of pollution control's strict diet.  He also paid for ten gallons yesterday and he got ten gallons. Two.
15.  No cars were driving on the left side of the road that morning, his headlights were at a proper height and aim, and he knew that he should stop at stop signs and follow the rules of the road. All of this "non-event" is due to enforced state motor vehicle laws. A BIG one.
17. Ernest's gasoline purchase included taxes to build and repair the safe roads that he used. 
18. What Ernest did not know is the bucolic scenery he enjoyed every day was once stripped of all trees, overgrazed, and caused a major flood.  The CCC built flood control dams, planted trees and grasses, and other agencies bought the land which never should have been farmed in the first place. (Based on a true story from Elbert County, Colorado.)

At the office, Ernest got on the elevator and was whisked to the thirtieth floor (19).  He stopped by the mailroom and found his paycheck direct deposit receipt.  Opening the envelope, he sighed again when he saw the mandatory deductions: Federal and State taxes, Social Security contribution, and Medicare.  He walked to his desk, and as he did every day because he was A Good Son, called Mom.

"Hi, Mom."
"All is well.  Well, almost.  I just get so tired of all of these taxes.  Why, I don't work for myself, I work for the government!" (As you will see, he was more correct than he thought.)
"Did the doctor (20) figure out what was wrong? ...... Good.  Will Medicare (21) cover all of it, or do you need some money?"  (I told you, he is A Good Son!)
"Yeah, I know, Dad's (22) pension (23) didn't leave you much, but with Social Security (24) and what Bud and I are willing to chip in, you'll always have money for bingo, mom!"  They both laughed.

19.  Elevators are inherently unsafe, yet they are safe due to oversight and regulations.
20.  The doctor, the nurses, and all of the medical professionals had to meet strict educational and practical standards.  Ernest's mother could reasonably expect, and got, quality medical care because of those regulations.
21.  Medicare!  It was only a generation ago that many seniors weighed whether to eat or see a doctor.  Fought by the AMA as "socialized medicine", the medical community discovered this was a whole new income stream!  Don't all Americans deserve as much?  Oh yes, administrative costs are about 9% of the total cost.  Private plans run about 25%.  Government inefficiency?
22.  Dad was a public school teacher, a tax supported vocation.  Ernest benefited from this.
23.  Dad's pension was strictly controlled as to the investments, oversight, and then making sure that payments to his widow are made reliably. 
24.  Social Security!  The other biggie.  While SS has its problems and is barely adequate for many, it is the foundation that prevents many seniors from begging on the streets.  Or living with the kids!

Ernest has been up for a just a few hours and hasn't even started his work day (Mom wanted to talk awhile.) In this short time frame, Ernest did not have to worry about many matters of health and finance.  He just took the lack of need to attend to these matters as a given. And, indeed, they were given to Americans by Progressive laws and regulations.

Thirty seven easy to identify ways Ernest's life was made good by these laws!

During the course of the day, Ernest's life was helped in many more ways that his bias prevented him from seeing:

25. When he went on line to check his investment portfolio, he could make investment decisions because he could trust the information he got, thanks to the SEC. (Note: this has been increasingly difficult since 2000 due to emasculation of the regulatory process by Ernest's own party!)
26.  When he called his travel agent for a flight to The Bigger City, he reasonably expected that he would arrive there safely, thanks to the FAA's enormous roll in making this happen.
27.  He didn't even know or appreciate the immense roll of the Weather Service and the GPS satellites in his travels. Two.
28.  Ernest could read. (Obviously his public school experience was some time ago!)
29.  Ernest had attended an excellent state university, one of the many that are the envy of millions around the world.  Ernest's education was heavily subsidized by taxes, and he was able to get federal loans at low interest rates to help further.  Two.
30.  When Ernest lost his previous job, he qualified for Unemployment Insurance for six months.  Although times were tough, he was able to keep his house.  He also found his current job with the help of the state job agency. Two.
31.  While Ernest was on line, he checked his bank account.  It was safe and secure, thanks to banking laws.
32.  The air Ernest was breathing while he was in The Bigger City was better than it was thirty years ago despite more people and cars. Thank you, EPA!
33.  Ernest worked for a software developer, who in turn, got business from government agencies and other businesses.  One of those businesses had large contracts to built radar systems for the US Air Force.  So, a lot of his company's income depended on government tax monies! Two.

And for a bonus 51st example:
34.  Of course, Mom's bingo parlor was under the watchful eye of the state!

Gee, it's not even lunch time yet!

Pirate's picture
verified

Can't you all see? It's just

Can't you all see? It's just a republican scam to divert our attention while, in the dark of night, they increase the price of postage stamps to 46 cents. Those conservatives are so shallow, aren't they, T? Hey, tell us about how the republicans almost lost WWII for us because they wanted to bomb Canada instead of Japan?

tron's picture

What arrogance?  The voters

What arrogance?  The voters elected the Democrats and their agenda.  When Republicans were elected their agenda was allowed to pass by the Democrats because we realized that's what the electorate wanted.  Republicans didn't have a filibuster proof Senate, but their massive tax cuts for the wealthy was passed because the public voted that way.  Now the Democrats are in charge the Republicans refuse to allow anything to be done.  It cannot continue this way, because when republicans regain control, which they will these things run in cycles, the Democrats will imitate the Republicans and refuse to allow Republican agenda to happen.  The most the minority party has done in years past is to mellow the majority's agenda.  The Republicans have instituted a new policy of stopping the Democrats at all costs.  It's a terrible system.

rstonge's picture
verified

Tron, I will agree with you

Tron, I will agree with you that the Republicans can now stop the Democrats in the Senate. Please explain how the Republicans could have stopped any of the Democrats ideas prior to the election of Senator Brown.

tron's picture

You're looking at this all

You're looking at this all wrong, WHY do you want to stop health reform?  It is needed, even the most blind republican realizes that.   But what you fail to realize is the Democrats never had 60 votes, they had 58, which an avowed socialists and moderate republican voting with them most of the time.  However if some reasonable republicans had joined in earnest to pass health reform the most extreme vulgarities would not have been added to the democrats bill, i.e., giveaways to Louisiana and Nebraska.  When you must have 60 votes to do anything, that leads to blackmail.  That's what happened and the republicans laughed all the way to the polls.  Eventually the public will realize what happened.  They may do so soon, because if republicans don't compromise now, when they must if anything is to happen, the electorate will understand who is to blame.  Instead stop all this posturing and let the reasonable people get things done.  I thought when the republicans where in power and the gang of fourteen was formed it was great, reason  prevailed.  However when the Democrats took power, all the republicans in the gang of fourteen, i.e. McCain et al, decided it wasn't a great idea anymore.  So compromise is only reasonable when republicans are elected.  The people know that the republican agenda failed us for eight years and elected democrats to change direction.  They did not elect republicans to stop it, merely to moderate the change.

Scotty_O's picture

No, you're looking at it all

No, you're looking at it all wrong.  Health insurance is evil?  Even if the Anthem CEO was paid 300 million dollars it would be a drop in the bucket compared to the government waste that awaits us  (Hey, isn't that one of those kickback figures, Louisiania Purchase I believe).  Here's a novel idea:  don't buy health insurance.....but do buy a rubber mallet, because you're going to need it to pound your eyes back into their sockets when you get a bill for a 5 minute doctors visit.  And then you'll stomp you feet and say "Not Fair" and postpone your 150 dollar Windows 7 upgrade....hey, wait a minute,  isn't Bill Gates a Billionaire?  Are those profits excessive?  Are we paying too much for Windows?  OMG, Tron you have opened my eyes!  We need Operating System Reform Stat!

BenHarrison's picture

Them DEM@$$ want ram their

Them DEM@$$ want ram their Way Leftest Agenda down america's throat!!!  To Far to the LEFT No good, To far the the RIGHT no good our elected officials need to find common ground!! Both Parties are to Blame The Dems wanted to exclude The RePubs From the Debate UNTIL they realized they couldent get anything done without enviting them to the table. To bad they wasted a year and a half triing to prove they could do it on their own!! And for gods sakes Health care reform will never work as long as they only see it as an insurance problem!! The Fix is in the costs billed by the Hospitals bring down the costs and insurance rates will follow!!! $1000.00 for 6 stitches Crazy!!! $10000.00 for a broken leg NUTS!!! $25000.00 To have a baby Insane!!! Not to mention $79.00 For a single Tylenol!!! These are the real problems making Healthcare unaffordable to The American People!!!

veritas's picture
verified

John  "ReaganRepublican"

John  "ReaganRepublican" Pronovost writes: 

"The government has not shown any ability to manage anything responsibly and I should hand over the decisions about my health care treatment to them?"

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

I certainly had to hand over my 'Health Care' decisions, in addition to many others to the the government, when I enlisted in the military, John.

It appears you've never gone that route then, John - and wouldn't recommend anyone else enlist, for that matter.

So that's what 'Reagan Republicans' believe in?  Nice example you set.  That's all "ME, ME, ME"

Sounds more like a selfish little kid.

Or a hippie. 

- But I'll give you the fact that Reagan couldn't pull off "Iran-Contra" without getting caught.  He said he just couldn't remember it.

 

ReaganRepublican's picture
verified

And what's your point?  You

And what's your point?  You actually prove my point completely.  Enlisting  in the military is a VOLUNTARY act, something I also did from 1987-1991, surrendering yourself to the government for four years is understood in the package when I CHOSE to sign up (I am not quite sure I see the relevance in that relative to this discussion, but whatever).  I would never discourage anyone from enlisting in the military but I would also never force someone to do it, either.  The Obama health plan, as proposed by Pelosi and Reid et al. is MANDATORY.  All about me?  No.  It's all about freedom.  Freedom to choose my own health care or no health care if I choose.  Everyone should have that freedom, not just me.  Selfish?  Because I don't want a group of 538 people in Washington D.C., who have never met me or my family, make health care decisions for me with a plan they won't even take for themselves or their families?  Guilty.  Your reactionary labeling of me is funny but you are still avoiding the question, a great Saul Alinsky tactic.   And, by the way, you never answered my question...typical of you liberals.  So I will leave it again..."The government has not shown any ability to manage anything responsibly and I should hand over the decisions about my health care treatment to them?"  Would you like to answer that for me, Veritas?   

veritas's picture
verified

ReaganRepublican - So you did

ReaganRepublican - So you did hand over your health care decisions to the government after all.

After representing yourself as someone who would never do that.

Really?

And now you want me to answer the questions of someone who has exhibited the fact he doesn't act in the manner with which he reasons??

Now there's an exercise in futility - You must be nucking futz!!!

 

 

ReaganRepublican's picture
verified

You people have no idea how

You people have no idea how to reason logically...I said no such thing and you stating that I did doesn't make it so.  Yet you STILL avoid my question (name calling is all you folks are good at).  First of all, Obama's health care plan is nothing like military medical care and you know it.  Secondly, being in the military is in NO WAY like being forced to swallow this bilge water that the Democrats are serving up.  If I wasn't satisfied with my care with the military medical facilities, I could go to someone else (and sometimes did)...I didn't surrender anything.  That is not so under the Obama plan.  There is nothing unreasonable about that and your reactionary hyperbolic drivel doesn't make it so.  I most certainly act in the manner in which I reason.  So let me re-phrase this then...maybe you can answer it now..."Why should I surrender my health care decisions to someone who will then forbid me from going somewhere else if that care is inadequate, rationed, or denied?"  

veritas's picture
verified

John Pronovost wrote: "The

John Pronovost wrote:

"The government has not shown any ability to manage anything responsibly and I should hand over the decisions about my health care treatment to them?"

When you joined the military you DID hand over decisions about your health care treatment to government.  If you refused to undergo a procedure or inoculation which you were ordered to do so, you were subject to discipline under the UCMJ.

Nothing so stringent in the proposed Health Care Bill.

That's reality, John.  You can't hide from it.  Your argument doesn't hold water.

ReaganRepublican's picture
verified

If by making sure you use my

If by making sure you use my name in every post you are going to intimidate me, forget it.  But, once again, you refuse to answer my question, choosing instead to superimpose my argument with what you would like to think I said, probably because you think it's makes it easier for you to say that I am wrong.  My argument does not hold water?  You haven't even spoken to my argument or even articulated anything that resembles a refutation.  My voluntary service in the military 20 years ago has nothing to do with entrusting my health care to the government today, I didn't join the military for the health care...it was part of the deal; I was interested in serving my country.  And the fact that I served in the military has nothing to do with the quality of Obama's health care plan, or any other government run health care plan, either.  You can run down as many rabbit trails as you want, "veritas" (I put that in quotes because I question your self-anointing as a designator of truth).   So let me see if I understand you correctly...you think that I should submit to the Obama health care plan because I once served in the military and if I don't then I am being contradictory?  You know, I have to tell you, you disappoint me.  I am a firm believer in mature reasoned debate so that people can learn from each other; no one side has a monoply on the truth.  I had perceived that you were one of those people, with whom I disagree, that can present a reasoned defense of a position that I oppose.  I have mentioned several things in these posts on this issue and you have spoken to none of them.  I have given you several opportunities to tell me why as, I assume, a supporter of the Obama health care plan, why I should.  You appear to only want to argue and attack the poster, avoiding what is a very fair question to ask.  Your only response is that I served in the military, therefore opposing it is contradictory logic.  Serving in the military has nothing to do with it.  And if that is the only thing you can give to support it, I am even more convinced of its flaws and the foundation for my resistance.  As someone who trumpets his resume as a solid foundation for his wisdom, I was hoping for something with a little more substance.  So, I will give one last chance to convince a skeptic...why should I support government run health care?  Surely you're capable of giving me an answer to that one simple question...  

veritas's picture
verified

John; I argue with those who

John;

I argue with those who reason.

You don't reason.

You made a statement which was completely inconsistant with the reality of your own actions.  I pointed that out.  Seeing how you don't even walk your own talk, to debate with you would make about as much logical sense as going down Louis Carroll's 'Rabbit Hole'

I've been around the block enough times to not walk into those traps.

You refer to intimidation when one addresses you by name; yet you think you're up for mature, reasoned debate?

You've got issues.

ReaganRepublican's picture
verified

Great

Great non-answer...again.  You have no answers.  With all the keystrokes you spent telling me how wrong I am, you wasted countless opportunities to tell your side.  Another attack on the messenger, you can't reason, you're not mature, you're inconsistent, you've got issues...blah, blah, blah...  I have given you reasons for my views and I have asked you for yours.  Silence.  You reason, huh?  Where are your reasons?  You don't have any.  You haven't refuted mine and you haven't provided yours.  Vapid.   

veritas's picture
verified

 The Sun Journal

 The Sun Journal writes:

"Consider again our current 17.6 percent of GDP, then consider these numbers: Canada, 10 percent; France, 11 percent; Germany 10.6 percent; Japan 8.1 percent; United Kingdom, 8.4 percent."

Remember that our cost of Health Care includes "Insurance" - which those other Countries don't.

You know.  The 'Protection Racket'  - Guido and the Boys.  Buy it whether you need it or not.  The useless 'Money-Changers' who's azzes J.C. kicked out of the temple.....

Legalized extortion.  The American Way. 

Ernest's picture
verified

Really people would you trust

Really people would you trust the government during any administration in history to organize a cattle stampede and do it right. They would have the cattle running in all different directions. I personally want the government to do nothing absolutly nothing for me other that to protect our borders. That was originally it's sole purpose in life and it should return to that position and nothing more.

SSDD's picture

Ernest - are you in middle

Ernest - are you in middle school? Have you gotten to social studies or civics yet? You obviously have no idea what the point of government is. Sounds like you've been imbibing a bit too much Glenn Beck and Sarah Failin Kool Aid! So the government should just protect us from scary Canada? Here is what your government does for you:

A day in the life of an American.......

Ernest flipped on the lights in the pre-dawn dark.  He wouldn't have any lights(1), of course, if it wasn't for the TVA(2) that supplied electricity to his home which was wired many years ago (3)as a result of bringing electricity and telephones to rural America(4).  

He put coffee into the filter(5), poured water into the coffee maker (6) slipped some bacon into a frying pan(7), turned on the gas(8), and got a couple of eggs from the fridge(9).  While he was waiting for the coffee he decided to catch the morning radio show (10) then went to the bathroom where he did what most people do in the morning(11).   

1.  Regulations govern the voltage and frequency of the electricity, the safety of the delivery system and the appliances, the rates that can be charged, the recourses available as a citizen if the utility doesn't perform properly.  Four items and the guy's feet haven't even hit the floor!
2.  The TVA also made the Tennessee River navigable, besides supplying electricity. Two.
3.  Building codes make sure that the electrical wiring is correctly engineered and installed. 
4.  Beats oil lamps and tin cans on strings.  Thank you, FDR.  Two.
5.  The coffee made it to Ernest's table because of international trade laws, fair weights and measures, and federal trucking regulations.  Three.
6.  The water was safe to drink because of state and federal regulations.
7.  Ernest paid for a pound of bacon and got a pound, not less.  It was safe to eat, he would not get ill from it. Two.
8.  The gas was delivered safely and economically via a complex system of hardware and regulations. Two.
9.  The eggs were likewise of known quality and size.  Two. 
10.  The radio show came in without interference from other stations because of federal regulations allocating the frequencies available.  

Ernest hasn't even gotten to the bathroom and his life has been positively influenced 
by at least 20 areas of progressive policy and government regulations!

11.  See #3.  

Ernest plods back to the kitchen, fishes in the cabinet, and pulls out a few pill bottles.  He takes his vitamins and his prescription drugs for high blood pressure (12).   As a matter of curiosity, he looks on the tub of margarine to see how much sodium is in the spread (13).  He sighs and decides to scramble his eggs today.  

After he takes his shower, he selects his clothes (14), gets dressed, picks up his keys and other routine items, and heads out to his car.  After starting the engine (15) Ernest backs out of the driveway and heads to The Big City (16)  While he is driving, he enjoys the smooth road and gently rolling hills with its forests and meadows (17)(18).

12.  No doubt the pharmaceutical company that created the drug used large amounts of "pure" scientific research that was funded by the government through universities, research often considered worthless as it has no immediate practical application.   The effectiveness and purity of the drug was assured by the Food and Drug Administration.  Two.
13.  The FDA likewise mandates all food to be labeled so that Ernest can make informed decisions and avoid foods harmful to his health.
14.  Unfortunately, the government could not prevent Ernest from making horrible fashion mistakes.  However, mandatory information on tags of his shirts and pants told him that he could not just throw those wool pants into the washing machine.  So he takes them to the local dry cleaner, whose use of carcinogenic "perc" is highly regulated so that it doesn't get into the air and water. (Even though a lot has prior to environmental awareness.) Two.
15.  Ernest's engine started because the quality of the gasoline is tightly regulated.  It is also lead free thanks to the necessity of pollution control's strict diet.  He also paid for ten gallons yesterday and he got ten gallons. Two.
15.  No cars were driving on the left side of the road that morning, his headlights were at a proper height and aim, and he knew that he should stop at stop signs and follow the rules of the road. All of this "non-event" is due to enforced state motor vehicle laws. A BIG one.
17. Ernest's gasoline purchase included taxes to build and repair the safe roads that he used. 
18. What Ernest did not know is the bucolic scenery he enjoyed every day was once stripped of all trees, overgrazed, and caused a major flood.  The CCC built flood control dams, planted trees and grasses, and other agencies bought the land which never should have been farmed in the first place. (Based on a true story from Elbert County, Colorado.)

At the office, Ernest got on the elevator and was whisked to the thirtieth floor (19).  He stopped by the mailroom and found his paycheck direct deposit receipt.  Opening the envelope, he sighed again when he saw the mandatory deductions: Federal and State taxes, Social Security contribution, and Medicare.  He walked to his desk, and as he did every day because he was A Good Son, called Mom.

"Hi, Mom."
"All is well.  Well, almost.  I just get so tired of all of these taxes.  Why, I don't work for myself, I work for the government!" (As you will see, he was more correct than he thought.)
"Did the doctor (20) figure out what was wrong? ...... Good.  Will Medicare (21) cover all of it, or do you need some money?"  (I told you, he is A Good Son!)
"Yeah, I know, Dad's (22) pension (23) didn't leave you much, but with Social Security (24) and what Bud and I are willing to chip in, you'll always have money for bingo, mom!"  They both laughed.

19.  Elevators are inherently unsafe, yet they are safe due to oversight and regulations.
20.  The doctor, the nurses, and all of the medical professionals had to meet strict educational and practical standards.  Ernest's mother could reasonably expect, and got, quality medical care because of those regulations.
21.  Medicare!  It was only a generation ago that many seniors weighed whether to eat or see a doctor.  Fought by the AMA as "socialized medicine", the medical community discovered this was a whole new income stream!  Don't all Americans deserve as much?  Oh yes, administrative costs are about 9% of the total cost.  Private plans run about 25%.  Government inefficiency?
22.  Dad was a public school teacher, a tax supported vocation.  Ernest benefited from this.
23.  Dad's pension was strictly controlled as to the investments, oversight, and then making sure that payments to his widow are made reliably. 
24.  Social Security!  The other biggie.  While SS has its problems and is barely adequate for many, it is the foundation that prevents many seniors from begging on the streets.  Or living with the kids!

Ernest has been up for a just a few hours and hasn't even started his work day (Mom wanted to talk awhile.) In this short time frame, Ernest did not have to worry about many matters of health and finance.  He just took the lack of need to attend to these matters as a given. And, indeed, they were given to Americans by Progressive laws and regulations.

Thirty seven easy to identify ways Ernest's life was made good by these laws!

During the course of the day, Ernest's life was helped in many more ways that his bias prevented him from seeing:

25. When he went on line to check his investment portfolio, he could make investment decisions because he could trust the information he got, thanks to the SEC. (Note: this has been increasingly difficult since 2000 due to emasculation of the regulatory process by Ernest's own party!)
26.  When he called his travel agent for a flight to The Bigger City, he reasonably expected that he would arrive there safely, thanks to the FAA's enormous roll in making this happen.
27.  He didn't even know or appreciate the immense roll of the Weather Service and the GPS satellites in his travels. Two.
28.  Ernest could read. (Obviously his public school experience was some time ago!)
29.  Ernest had attended an excellent state university, one of the many that are the envy of millions around the world.  Ernest's education was heavily subsidized by taxes, and he was able to get federal loans at low interest rates to help further.  Two.
30.  When Ernest lost his previous job, he qualified for Unemployment Insurance for six months.  Although times were tough, he was able to keep his house.  He also found his current job with the help of the state job agency. Two.
31.  While Ernest was on line, he checked his bank account.  It was safe and secure, thanks to banking laws.
32.  The air Ernest was breathing while he was in The Bigger City was better than it was thirty years ago despite more people and cars. Thank you, EPA!
33.  Ernest worked for a software developer, who in turn, got business from government agencies and other businesses.  One of those businesses had large contracts to built radar systems for the US Air Force.  So, a lot of his company's income depended on government tax monies! Two.

And for a bonus 51st example:
34.  Of course, Mom's bingo parlor was under the watchful eye of the state!

Gee, it's not even lunch time yet!

Let's see, the food Ernest eats at his favorite restaurant is safe due to health regulations....
and on...
and on...
it goes!

veritas's picture
verified

Ernest: If you believe our

Ernest:

If you believe our government's sole purpose was to 'protect our borders' - then you obviously don't have the foggiest idea of what the Constitution is about.

Quit wasting your time here and take some decent courses on Constitutional History and Law.  It would be money and time well spent.

Lil's picture
verified

"Let's put some Republican

"Let's put some Republican stuff in the bill." There are something like 190 Republican amendments in the bill. Ignore tort reform - states that tried it have not seen any cost containment. And ignore the whole Republican version of selling across state lines thing, too. Nothing but a race to the bottom like the credit card industry.

cranky yankee's picture

The Republi-CONS continue to

The Republi-CONS continue to say they have a plan, yet we still haven't seen one. Today is the day. They either fish or cut bait. The fact of the matter, as your headline says, we need health care reform NOW! The biggest part of the problem is that all of the recent attention has been on the insurance industry, but they are not the whole problem, or even the root of the problem. The problem is access to health care at the most basic levels because of the cost of these services. When you add to that the cost of "specialized" care, care that used to be handled by a GP in the past, the costs are beyond the reach of most of us. There are those who firmly believe that if you desire to have good health care, you should have to come up with the means to pay for it, and most of those folks are on the red side of the Congressional aisle. They say that it is the responsibility of the individual to find a way to have the income to pay whatever the cost of health may be and that we should not try to put restraints or limits on those costs. They equate access to health care with the choice of whether to buy a used Chevy or a new BMW, M&Ms or Godiva Chocolate, as though living and dying should be a choice on that same level. That's where we're in trouble. We're trying to convince people with that type of mindset that access to affordable health care should be a universal, something they call socialism. And that's their tactic-smear and fear. When the Dems talk universal health care or public option, or some similar concept, they are then labeled as having a socialist agenda as a scare tactic. How is making something accessible and affordable a socialist concept? The Republicans sure don't turn down the insurance benefits they get by being in Congress-benefits EVERY one of us is paying for. Dick Cheney is certainly making good use of his taxpayer paid insurance policy even though his health problems are his own fault. What happened to HIS personal responsibility?

SSDD's picture

Does working for a newspaper

Does working for a newspaper mean you never read the news? The public overwhelmingly favors a public option as part of health care reform because it is patently obvious that insurance companies need stiff competition to lower prices. A public option would provide just that. So when Senator Reid says they pass the public option through reconciliation, or majority rule, Olympia Snowe spews the following bs:

On Monday, Olympia Snowe made herself the fool in front of reporters after the jobs bill vote on Monday when she said, "I don’t see reconciliation as acceptable. I think that that’s a huge mistake, frankly — tactically, strategically and in terms of what is in the best interest of the American people. And I think that that would be a very important step, and gesture, if the president and the leadership removed it, rather than having that as sort of wielding this power, you know, by using an arbitrary tool for purposes that have not been heretofore used."

Funny how she never said anything like this when the Bush administration passed more than 50% of it's bills in the Senate through reconciliation. And where is the Sun Journal to call her out for her idiotic posturing? I hear crickets...........

The Sun Journal is typical of the media problem facing this country, namely that the news orgs are all bought and paid for and irrelevant. Most Americans get their "news" from Fox News and as such couldn't find Earth if you handed them a globe. If you want any truth, you have to read original documents, talk to people involved in the process, and investigate, you know the things the media used to do? On all three of these things the SJ is fail. But again remember this is the paper that thought reelecting the dumbest president in history in 2004 was a great idea - right Ms. Meyer?

Lil's picture
verified

Somebody needs to remind

Somebody needs to remind Olympia that COBRA was passed using reconciliation.

ReaganRepublican's picture
verified

Tron is wrong...as usual. 

Tron is wrong...as usual.  Republicans are most certainly interested...in solutions that don't place our medical care into the hands of bureaucrats in Washington.  The government has not shown any ability to manage anything responsibly and I should hand over the decisions about my health care treatment to them?  No, thanks...I am capable of thinking on my own and do not wish to be dependent on an incompetent bureaucrat, Republican or Democrat, especially government bureaucrats who have run this country into the trillions in red ink (and before Tron goes and blames Republicans for that he needs to remember that there is plenty of Democrat blame to go around, too).  That is the fundamental difference, of course, in this health care debate.  There are those of us who do not wish to be dependent on Uncle Sam and wish to have the freedom to purchase our health care on the open market at my own discretion (this is still a free country, right?).  If supporters of Obama's health care plan wish to be dependent on government, fine, they already have that option in Medicare and Medicaid.  Leave me alone to buy my own from the private sector if I want to.  And, believe it or not, there are those who don't want to have any...period.  I respectfully disagree with the SJ assessment that tort reform and over-the-state lines purchase options will only lead to a small dent in the nation's health care woes.  It would have a significant effect in a free-market economy.  The SJ should have added the Republican plan for tax deductible health savings accounts (HSA's) which allow citizens to save their own money for health care and shop around for the best price in their communities for treatment, forcing Dr.'s and hospitals to lower costs in an effort to compete for our health care business.  But, as government tends to do, and this is a notoriously famous position of the socialists (read Democrats), Washington does not believe that individuals in this country are smart enough to make those decisions and they are adamantly opposed to any industry that is independent of them.  And I don't want to hear the loud whine of how corrupt big business is, either.  No business in history has been run more corruptly than the U.S. government.  Why should we let them run health care, too?  This is an issue of trust.  Who do I trust to run my life?  Myself or the U.S. government?   

SSDD's picture

The problem is you are not in

The problem is you are not in control - the health insurance company is and if the choice is between allowing medical decisions to be made by a private insurer versus the federal government, the majority of Americans choose the federal government (hint: Medicaid)

Shame you wasted all that time typing that post just to be shown to be dead wrong in one sentence.

ReaganRepublican's picture
verified

I am in control.  Good grief,

I am in control.  Good grief, it's basic free market economics.  If I, as a private consumer, am unsatisfied with my health care coverage I am free to take my premium to another vendor...just like any other business in this country.  Don't like the quality of the Toyota you bought?  Buy a Chrysler next time.    And that's the point...I get to choose what is right for ME and my family.  That's what freedom is, or so I thought.  If the government plan stinks, guess what?  I am not only stuck with it but I am FORCED to buy it.  That is not freedom, my friend, that's socialism or, dare I say, tyranny.  Really?  The American people would rather have the federal government making their health care decisions?  Which poll did you get that info from?  The Daily Kos?  Wasted my time making this post?  I'll take my chances...but thanks for the public service announcement.

Lil's picture
verified

I agree, awfully long winded

I agree, awfully long winded for somebody with nothing of substance to say.

tron's picture

Save your ink, republicans

Save your ink, republicans are not interested.  They refuse to help our country, unless they're given the credit.  It may be our country's downfall, all at the feet of republicans.

Pirate's picture
verified

Gee, you're right, T...I'll

Gee, you're right, T...I'll bet there isn't a single Republican in Iraq or Afghanistan fighting to defend your right to bloviate with your inane rants.

BenHarrison's picture

HUM tron How about the

HUM tron How about the Democrats arrogant additude, We are going to jam our Liberal agenda right down the GOP's Throats, HA HA they don't have the votes to stop us it our way or the highway we control the Government. OH WAIT CRAP they have the votes to stop us!! I guess now we might have to pretend to compromise or at least Demonize the GOP for not getting on board with our Spend Spend spend feeding frenzy!!

 

Advertisement

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...