Central Maine Healthcare considers layoffs

LEWISTON — Central Maine Healthcare is looking to lay off employees in an effort to fill a $10 million budget gap left by unpaid hospital bills, MaineCare debt and fewer paying patients. 

Central Maine Healthcare is the parent company of Central Maine Medical Center in Lewiston, Rumford Hospital and Bridgton Hospital.

Spokesman Chuck Gill confirmed Wednesday that the hospital group is considering layoffs. He said he could not yet say how many people would lose their jobs, which departments would be affected or when the layoffs would occur. He expected to have that information "soon."

"I don't have any type of formal announcement about what we're doing for next steps," Gill said. "We're looking at all options now."

Although Central Maine Healthcare is looking at the entire hospital system, its primary concern is CMMC, the largest of the hospitals. Officials believe most layoffs and other money-saving efforts will be centered there. 

Gill blamed the hospital system's financial problems, in part, on $56 million the state has owed it for MaineCare since 2007. That debt is rising by more than $1 million each month, Gill said.

The hospital system is also seeing more MaineCare patients, which is a problem because the state doesn't pay the full cost of caring for people with MaineCare, Gill said. MaineCare is the state's health insurance program for low-income and disabled people. Other people are going to the hospital less often, and those who do are more likely not to pay their bills, he said.

CMMC is building a new, multimillion-dollar emergency room and lab to replace its smaller, outdated ones, but that project has not affected the hospital system's budget, Gill said. Construction costs have been paid with bonds.

In July, Central Maine Healthcare announced it had halted hiring, frozen wages and issued a two-month suspension of its earned-time program, through which employees earn vacation days.

"We had hoped in July that things would start turning around, and they haven't," Gill said.

To save money, the hospital system has renegotiated contracts with vendors and has looked at ways to manage patient care more efficiently, Gill said. It has also "drastically curtailed" administrative spending, travel, conferences and other expenses. Gill declined to say Wednesday exactly how much was cut.  

"I think the better thing is to put it all in context and give you a more complete list (at a later date)," he said.

Despite its efforts, the hospital group has been unable to save the money it needs to balance its budget this fiscal year. Although officials don't have a final figure, they expect to be at least $10 million over budget. Gill said it's possible the figure will be closer to $13 million.

"There's multiple projects under way (to save money)," he said. "The problem is, with the $56 million problem hanging over our heads, we don't have the time to wait for some of those projects — which we think will come through with lots of savings — to happen, because you can't turn anything around overnight."

Gill said the hospital system would soon announce how it plans to deal with the shortfall, including possible layoffs.

"Our first priority is to make sure we maintain the highest possible patient care," he said. "This is an evolving story; we don't have a final answer yet. I would say soon. I don't know if it'll be this week, but I would say soon."

St. Mary's Regional Medical Center, Lewiston's other hospital, has also struggled in the weak economy. Although it hasn't seen a drop in patients, it has seen a 53 percent increase in unpaid hospital bills. It is also owed $20 million for MaineCare patients.

Spokeswoman Jennifer Radel said St. Mary's spent the past year restructuring to save money and make patient care more efficient. Although one senior manager lost his position in the restructuring, St. Mary's is not expecting a round of layoffs.

ltice@sunjournal.com

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Comments

photomatt's picture

imminent

"they also must not irresponsibly excite their readership. This, as one might readily imagine, can be a thin and dangerous line to walk. Today, the Sun Journal failed."

Since the losses happened, it seems this is incorrect. The headline was right.
http://www.sunjournal.com/city/story/913289 I guess they really were imminent, weren't they.

"I suspect that, today, CMMC is a low-morale nut house."
CMMC's fault, not the paper's.

"In my humble opinion, after the print headline, "Layoffs Loom," and the lede, "looking to lay off employees," nothing else in this story is going to resonate with the public, no matter how factual. The Sun Journal has gone for the jugular, all but declaring job losses to be imminent, and that's all anyone is going to take away from this article."

Since the layoffs have been announced, are factual and are happening, doesn't this mean the research and writing was ahead of you? Maybe think about that when you decide to write your next book-long response.

"One screamin' lede announcing that people are about to lose their jobs does more to damage the credibility of the Sun Journal than that of Central Maine Healthcare."

Except when it's right?

Nice try, really - but you should at least have an argument, like "the paper announced layoffs and they were incorrect and inciting panic and low morale" rather than "they reported the truth, just earlier than CMMC made the formal announcement."

Just a few thoughts... I don't disagree with a lot of your ideas for follow-ups. You had some great angles for possible topics - but your argument that this column doesn't work is just silly since the layoffs are now formally announced.

friend1's picture

Is Top Management willing take cuts

Appears that no one is stating from upper management that they are taking a pay cut to save jobs of nurses and other staff. Sounds like they should stop blaming the state and look over there budget again and do a little cuts to top level management. I'm sure they can afford a little less in there pay. After all they have alreay cut employees pay and benefits. Why not show the employees that they are willing to take pay cuts also to help the hospital stay afloat.

FunnyThingIs's picture

Employees often disappear at CMMC...Consultants stay!

CMMC claims to control costs yet often eliminates great hardworking people and replaces them with multitudes of high priced consultants from out of state that they pay to fly in every month, paying travel and per diem. It's astounding that they make good, hard-working local residents suffer only to help out of state consultants make money in sickening fashion. I have a friend who lost her job to consultants, lost her home to foreclosure had to move far away to find work all while CMMC brings in more and more consultants -- where are they hiding those costs in their financials?!?! It happens throughout CMMC... take a look at their computer department as an example!

Look at all of the people throughout the facility that are really good employees that mysteriously end up being no longer employed one day... then replaced by consultants and high priced replacements? It's an interesting thing that seems to go unnoticed by the board of the organization.

This threat of layoffs is a threat to get the state to pay their outstanding bills it's almost funny to see it play out in the media. I completely agree that the state should fund their obligations to the hospital, at least in part. Perhaps the board of directors should consider hiring a local auditing firm to see what is really going on within that beautiful brick tower and down the executive suite hallway, that might make a great story in the local news.

Unless, of course, you are an out of state person who would like a great salary and travel and per diem benefits at the cost of local workers.... then I think the story might be less than favorable.

verified

Central Maine Medical Center's financial problems

Hopefully, the cuts will start with the exorbitant salaries paid to the fat cats, and not from the staff who keep the place operatingefficiently!

mrnpchick's picture
verified

layoffs

funny how this story disappeared off the city section of the online paper.

lawntobemowed's picture

Yes!

Biggest news of the day and they hide the story. There has to be something behind this action. Someone made a comment that they (SJ) didn't like. The truth hurts in the City of Lewiston.

Robert OReilly's picture

"The hospital system is also

"The hospital system is also seeing more MaineCare patients, which is a problem because the state doesn't pay the full cost of caring for people with MaineCare, Gill said. MaineCare is the state's health insurance program for low-income and disabled people. "

Low-income, not no-income!
Quit handing out get-out-of-hospital-bill-free cards to the dirtbags of section 8 who refuse to get jobs! I bet that would take a truck-size chunk out of the debt that is piling up!

KStern's picture

Golly....

What about that HUGE expansion at CMMC? Where is the money coming from for THAT?!?

lawntobemowed's picture

Well..........

the City of Lewiston attracts and welcomes the crowd that doesn't work with open arms. It's not the fault of the working folk. They pay their bills and go to work every morning. Lewiston has cornered the market for "affordable" sometimes know as free housing. Years ago people said that the you know what was going to eventually hit the fan. Eventually is here now! The most honored workers in Lewiston are not doctors and nurses. It's the mail carriers as they deliver the monthly checks.

noseynellie's picture

Great

This is just great....what happens when people who are really sick need to go to the hospital? Perhaps the cuts should start at the top...

wmduke's picture
verified

More to the story

Newspapers have a responsibility to advertisers to craft headlines and ledes that will move the product off newsstands. That goes without saying. But they also must not irresponsibly excite their readership. This, as one might readily imagine, can be a thin and dangerous line to walk. Today, the Sun Journal failed.

I suspect that, today, CMMC is a low-morale nut house. Personally, I'm not so certain a hospital is the place in which I'd most like to incite a panic over job security.

Unfortunately, whether due to lack of resources, or a deficiency of initiative, the Sun Journal took the easy way out on this important story. Just as the paper recently ignored the deep, underlying issues on Lisbon Street in order to present the happy fluff, it appears to have glossed over the complicated details of the Central Maine Healthcare story in order to trade in shock value.

In my humble opinion, after the print headline, "Layoffs Loom," and the lede, "looking to lay off employees," nothing else in this story is going to resonate with the public, no matter how factual. The Sun Journal has gone for the jugular, all but declaring job losses to be imminent, and that's all anyone is going to take away from this article.

However, in my opinion, the Sun Journal still has an opportunity to salvage this story with a compelling and relevant Sunday package. Expand on today's effort with the following:

1. An article by Steve Mistler in which each of the five gubernatorial candidates address how they'd address the MaineCare debt, as well as their ideas for reform, if needed, of Maine's healthcare system.

2. Rural ambulace services in the area report declining revenues from lower call volumes, presumably because people, even if insured, are not availing themselves of the service, out of financial fear. Is the same true of United? Send Mark LeFlamme on a ride-along to talk to patients and EMTs.

3. Is it true that MaineCare users overuse the hospital while regular people, even if insured, are shying away? What are the real numbers? What does this say about the regional economy as a whole, in terms of recovery or double-dip? Send a reporter to find out.

4. It can be argued that CMMC is the economic engine which drives L/A. How about a Bonnie Washuk piece on how the hospital impacts other businesses in the area?

5. Given the furor today's story is likely to create, send Tice to talk to employees, on or off the record, about their fears, or lack thereof, for their jobs.

6. How will the advent of Obamacare impact the hospital's finances and the delivery of services? Is help on the way, or are things likely to get worse? Put a reporter on that.

7. Solicit columns for the editorial page, addresing opposing views of the MaineCare crisis and/or the management of CMMC. Also give the CMMC CEO a chance to address readers directly. Plus, gotta have a cartoon.

8. Is the MaineCare debt a convenient excuse? Tice did a good job addressing the natural question which arises, how does the new construction impact the financials, but questions linger. Is it possible to determin the degree to which management at CMMC is responsible for the system's budget deficit. I bet the Sun Journal has a reporter on staff good enough to find out.

9. We could probably use a follow-up on the board-member salary issue.

10. There's probably a dozen different additional angles the fine editors at the Sun Journal can think of, just off the top of their heads. Call together the staff and pass out the assignments. Sunday is right around the corner, but I bet you can make it. Give us a complete package that really delves into all of the issues at stake, including all the stakeholders involved in the issue.

I think the Sun Journal is capable of delivering something really important which drives and facilitates the public conversation. However, today's story was not it. One screamin' lede announcing that people are about to lose their jobs does more to damage the credibility of the Sun Journal than that of Central Maine Healthcare.

Duke

RNinME's picture

10 very valid suggestions

As an RN at CMMC I feel I have some insight to the views of the staff. We have been aware for months that we are in trouble. No raises this year, no earned time for two months, reduction in the amount of pay of shift differentials, less patients means we are overstaffed so every night nurses and CNAs are on-call. There isn't much we can do about the low numbers of patients seeking care. I feel like at least on my unit we have been kept informed of the financial situation and we've been having many open discussions about the deficits in the budget and ways to cut costs. Some staff were told last week that layoffs were being discussed, and I don't think any one that is working at the hospital right now is surprised.

It was said at work this week that even if the state paid the owed 56 million dollars we would not be out of the woods, but boy would it help! Months ago an article was published about the salary of the execs at CMMC and other maine hospitals as well. Obviously as I am wondering if I'll be losing my job it occurs to me that the higher ups could stand to lose a few dollars and spare some jobs.

And yes, the Emergency Dept is greatly overused for things that would be better tended to in primary care offices- but I would dare to say this is a problem in every emergency department with both private pay and medicaid/mainecare. I have heard that even with many private insurance it only costs $50 to go to the ED no matter what tests they do there, whereas if you have lab tests or xrays as an outpatient you have to pay the copay at the Dr's office and a percentage of the cost of the office visit and the testing.

salemgirl1's picture

HEALTHCARE

This is indeed why we need a BUSINESS MAN running the state..... I have lived here all my life and I love this state, but I cannot stand the way things are going. As far as I can see, my husband and I will have to retire to another state to even survive. This state is taking a nose-dive and dragging down the good people with it. It is only a matter of time that the working people of this beautiful state will crash and burn due to the overload of non working people that are being supported by the abundant waste of all the "GIMME PROGRAMS" Let's get a grip on reality !!!!! We are in desparate need of a hugh financial overhaul.

concerned KD's picture

Fault lies with Baldacci

This is the proof that Baldacci and his MaineCare program is raping the state and bleeding it dry... Without MaineCare these people would be keeping their jobs and the hospital would be on budget and any future patients would in fact be getting the highest quality care available. Proof that the democratic policies are bankrupting this state and it needs to change..
If MaineCare is like ObamaCare then this is a sign of the future problems with ObamaCare.. It simply doesnt work.. The only people who benefit are those who pay NO taxes and get the care for free.. Baldacci should hang his head in shame and personnally apologise to each and every person who loses their job in this layoff.. It should be televised for all to see, and the speach should sound something like " I'm sorry I have failed you and others that will be affected in the future. He should also extend a free meal program at Mama Baldacci's restaraunt for all of those who lost their job .... Maybe he should pay the tab for a while, and feel the pinch of government programs.. We have been feeling it all along and he is responsible for just how bad it is.

RNinME's picture

MaineCare was not created by Gov Baldacci

This is a statewide problem and not only Baldacci's fault. Baldacci's unsuccessful program is Dirigo Health but that is not the issue with the hospitals right now. MaineCare hasn't been paying the hospitals what it owes for years and years, long before Baldacci took office. Every 5 years or so the hospitals have to seek help from legislature and community activism to force the state to pay up. Paying the hospitals needs to become a priority. As it is Medicaid and MaineCare are only required to reimburse at something like 60 cents to the dollar, so my understanding is that in turn the hospital then has to charge private insurance more. Currently we are seeing less patients than ever before and of those patients, a higher percentage are medicaid/mainecare than private insurance.

The entire healthcare delivery and payment system needs to be reformed, there is no question on any side of the issue that what we are doing now doesn't work.

concerned KD's picture

Baldacci has let it get this

Baldacci has let it get this bad with MaineCare.. Wheather He devised it or not. He has had a responsability to the people of Maine to not let it get this bad.. If the quality of our healthcare drops due to this(which it will) the fault lies in the statehouse and starts with him. All the rest can get in line for thier floggings but he is first in line.... Incompetence is the culprit.....

roadwolfwalker's picture

Health Care Costs are a problem everywhere

Spokesman Chuck Gill confirmed Wednesday that the hospital group is considering layoffs. So what you are saying is your health care is not paid soon fewer healthcare workers will be working Gill blamed the hospital system's financial problems, in part, on $56 million the state has owed it for MaineCare since 2007 One part of this problem is places like Wall Mart that makes millions only hire people to work under 40 so they dont have to pay healthcare wall mart certainly not fair to the tax payers of maine to cover their workers healthcare costs WALLMART should be ashame of itself for letting maine tax payers pay for they workers healthcare They are many issues faceing healthcare today that need to be address Hope fully the next governor will address this issue ass baldachi sure didnt GOOD LUCK CMMC

Ugh's picture

Executives get too much pay and spend way too much so,

Yup, let the little guy get laid off as usual. Read the SJ article of 2/14/10 and that will explain it all. http://www.sunjournal.com/node/792174

Advertisement

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...