Populist uprising refuses Dems demands for silence

The best moment of almost every YouTube video of the raucous town-hall meetings on health care is the same: It's the nonplussed look on the face of the senators and congressmen who have rarely suffered such indignity. Be assured: No one talks to them that way in the "members only" elevators in the U.S. Capitol.

Nancy Pelosi and Co. insist that the town-hall protestors are the tools of special interests. Not likely. Almost all of the special interests have been enticed or bullied into cooperating with ObamaCare. The alphabet soup of major players on health-care policy is basically on board — PhRMA (the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America), the AMA (American Medical Association), the AHA (American Hospital Association), AHIP (America's Health Insurance Plans) and the AARP (American Association of Retired Persons).

President Barack Obama and the Democrats may still imagine themselves insurgents storming the gates, but that self-image should have expired last November. On health care, they have played a brilliant inside game. They have used their sheer power to cut deals with craven lobbyists seeking to limit damage to their clients. Everything was set for a cram-down of sweeping legislation — with special interests uttering hardly a peep — before August in a well-executed power play.

Then public opinion intervened. Obama is now on the wrong side of a genuine grass-roots revolt by people who feel ignored by everyone who is supposed to be representing them.

Consider the AARP. It has all but endorsed a plan to slash several hundred billion dollars over 10 years from Medicare. It is providing cover for the creation of a new system that, if it ever succeeds in "bending the cost curve," will have to scrimp on expensive end-of-life care. The AARP is overwhelmingly favorable to a plan opposed by the elderly more than any other age group. Who is the more authentic voice of seniors — the AARP playing along with its Democratic allies, or the elderly at town-hall meetings wondering what the Medicare cuts will mean for them?

The inside-Washington players are easily co-opted and cowed. The AMA came out in opposition to a public option in June, and then — after a stern talking-to by Washington's political barons — immediately backtracked. It ended up endorsing the House bill even though by one estimate it will cost doctors almost $19,000 annually by its third year. Even the vilified insurers have been running gauzy TV ads in favor of reform (although they oppose the public option).

Aggrieved voters don't co-opt or cow so easily. When one angry man stood toe-to-toe with Pennsylvania Sen. Arlen Specter and condemned his "damn cronies," he was the outraged voice of American populism. His beef probably wasn't with Specter or his associates exactly, but with the entire panoply of interests battening on the new era of corporatism and hulking government, from Goldman Sachs to the United Autoworkers to the lobbyists gaming the stimulus and cap-and-trade bills.

Like it or not (and it always has its unfortunate excesses), this kind of populism is part of the idiom of American politics. The same distrust of power that had left-wing activists spinning feverish theories about George W. Bush's eavesdropping has the right agitated about Obama's "death panels." Liberal intellectuals hail populism when the likes of Andrew Jackson, Franklin D. Roosevelt and Obama direct it against "the malefactors of great wealth." They are appalled when it is turned against the grand schemes of Washington itself.

But they should listen. "It's been a mistake for anyone to say that this has been a manufactured effort," Sen. Claire McCaskill of Missouri said after her own rollicking town hall. "This is real. It's grass-roots." Despite all the media tsk-tsking about the tenor of the meetings, a USA Today poll found that independents, by a 2-to-1 margin, say the protests have made them more sympathetic to the protestors, rather than less.

Still controlling the inside game, Democrats will be tempted to steamroll their opponents anyway. In which case, the populist revolt will have just begun.

Rich Lowry is a syndicated columnist. He can be reached via e-mail at: comments.lowry@nationalreview.com.

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Displaying comments, from newest to oldest

Mainah49's picture

The American health care

The American health care system is broken. I doubt you could find many people who would disagree. On the same token, I can't find very many people who want a cure from Washington rammed down our throats without our legislators even knowing what it contains, and how it will affect us all.

If this plan is so great for the American people, why won't ALL Federal employees be on the same plan? If President Obama wants this plan so badly, why isn't he being a true leader and stating on national TV, that he and his family will be the FIRST people to sign on?

And, in case some don't realize it, federal employees including the President are under a PRIVATE health insurance plan.

Barb's picture

Obama took over two car

Obama took over two car companies,( which he has NO legal right to do ) passed a massive spending bill that was supposed to stop unemployment from going above 8% and now it is 9.4. There were little if any jobs created by this massive pork bill although Obama seems to tell you differently. He also wants you to rat on your neighbor if you see or hear anything in the form of dissent to his health care bill. Isn't it funny that people got unsolicited emails from the Whitehouse on Obamas pro abortion healthcare plan with David Alexrod's name on them. Is this legal? I can imagine if Bush would have allowed this to happen. There would be a revolt. The liberals would go crazy. This is the lefts plan to socialize the country and healthcare. You don't see Obama asking for tort reform as he is in the back pocket of the trial lawyers. People are fed with this teleprompter reading moron that can't articulate a sentence unless he is reading it off of a screen. We don't want his socialistic health care program ,his cap and scam or card check program either. Bend over america ,you are now getting the shaft and the change you voted for.

Big Love's picture

If it were just a few of the

If it were just a few of the fringe righties that caused this retreat on reform, what does that say about the backbone of the liberal leadership that led this fight? Did it really only take a few crazy right-wing teabagging, racist, facist, and a conservative news network to beat back a liberal senate, liberal house, liberal White House, the unions, well funded liberal special interest groups and all of the liberal media? Why are you all so quick to blame FOX news and and conservative talk show hosts when none of them has a vote? All of your whining and name calling is getting the left nowhere. Leaders in your own party are calling for the administration to "hit the reset button", and you're blaming this failure on Sean Hannity?

Frostproof's picture
verified

You can always trust Lil's

You can always trust Lil's uncanny ability to find the psychos in any group. Birds of a feather.

Hysteria? Rational thought. Perhaps tron refers to the whackos who shriek RACIST whenever a riled up granny mentions health care for illegal immigrants? No, that's civilized discourse.

Obama is not the country. Wanting Obama's policies to fail is not calling for the destruction of the republic. For 8 years knee-jerk liberals advocated total failure for GWB, up to and including painful lingering death. If the president is the country, they were calling for the country's failure. You can't have it both ways, but that won't stop liberals from trying.

At least with a fascist you know where he stands; a liberal changes his principles more often than his underwear. As proof, stay tuned for more 'reform' changes caused by those phony town-hallers.

Lil's picture
verified

Nobody had to advocate for

Nobody had to advocate for Dubya's failure, he had that one covered, and was amazingly good at it.
______________________

"We make a living by what we get, we make a life by what we give."
Winston Churchill

Lil's picture
verified

A few noisy brain dead right

A few noisy brain dead right wing automatons represent a populist uprising? Do you mean the ones carrying signs with swastikas? Or the occasional Obama with a Hitler moustache?
______________________

"We make a living by what we get, we make a life by what we give."
Winston Churchill

tron's picture

The raucous at the town

The raucous at the town meetings are phony. Not to say the people are not riled up, but they got this way because of the very people that want this country to fail. Remember Rush Limbaugh, "I want him to fail." And to that end, conservative talk radio, right wing FOX News and bombarded the airwaves with lies and fear in order to drum up the hysteria you now see. Any hysteria feeds on itself until it finally collapses on itself. Will it derail the health care bill? Maybe, but just maybe if people return to rational thinking we might get a debate to really improve the current situation. In order for that, we must fight the lies and fear, in the town meetings, on the streets and on the airwaves. We cannot allow the narrow minded fascists win.

Advertisement