Put little faith in egg baron's public apology

Back in June, months before Austin “Jack” DeCoster became the national face of industrial chicken farming, we argued that a $34,000 fine leveled against his Turner mega-farm was too small.

At the time, DeCoster’s Maine Contract Farming was on the hot seat for animal cruelty violations secretly recorded during an investigation by an outside group.

The editorial pointed out DeCoster’s long history of labor and sanitation problems at his operations in Turner and in the Midwest.

The editorial was quickly followed by a rebuttal from Jay DeCoster, operations manager at the Turner farm, outlining the steps the farm has taken to correct various deficiencies.

Last week, Jack DeCoster appeared with another of his sons, Peter, the company’s chief executive officer, at a Congressional hearing into the salmonella outbreak.

Jack DeCoster said he was “horrified” to learn that his eggs had sickened about 1,300 customers, mumbling something about becoming “big” while still operating like they were “small.”

The explanation didn’t wash with congressional questioners, and the public shouldn’t buy it.

DeCoster has been big enough long enough to figure things out.

Instead, his hog and chicken farms have a long history of problems in every state in which they operate.

The Associated Press reported last week that Wright County Egg received 426 positive results for salmonella between 2008 and 2010, 73 of which were for salmonella enteritidis, the strain responsible for this summer’s outbreak.

The company had a positive test result for enteritidis on July 26, just three weeks before it finally recalled more than a half-billion eggs.

It’s a shame that neither DeCoster nor his employees were horrified enough to correct the problems before hundreds were sickened.

Equally disturbing was evidence that the positive reports were forwarded to the Agriculture Department’s National Veterinary Services Laboratories, showing that government regulators should have known of the threat long before hundreds of people were sickened.

If it’s not clear by now, it should be: Our fragmented regulatory system is broken and threatens our health and safety.

An Associated Press profile of DeCoster last week described him as a complex person, a born-again Christian who ministers to jail inmates and donates money to church and community projects.

That’s great, but it’s certainly hard to square that public-mindedness with DeCoster’s continuous record of skirting health, safety, immigration, labor and environmental laws.

“We were horrified to learn that our eggs may have made people sick,” DeCoster told the committee in a prepared statement. “We apologize to every one who may have been sickened by eating our eggs. I pray several times each day for all of them for their improved health.”

Again, that’s good, but it’s going to take much more to turn around the image of a lawless company that’s willing to cut corners to produce a profit.

editorialboard@sunjournal.com

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Displaying comments, from newest to oldest

John Miller's picture

It's deplorable that he

It's deplorable that he believes he can buy his way to heaven. How can any "God fearing born again Christian" like Jack believe that they can treat people and animals that way. Treat others the way you would want them to treat you.

Maineiac in VT's picture

In the next life

We can only hope that there is reincarnation and that Jack comes back in the next life as a chicken on one of his farms!!!!

Maineiac in VT's picture

How convenient

How convenient that Jack DeCoster ministers to jail inmates!!! Maybe he can pick out his cell the next time he's at the big house!!!

WideStanceRepublican's picture

Wait what?

The Sun Journal is calling for a more unified government oversight role in regards to food safety? I though the SJ and the Costellos were all in favor of industry regulating itself. You know private industries being so much more efficient than government agencies.....
/snark

cmetwo's picture

Austin “Jack” DeCoster

He's full of the crap that comes from his chickens.Doesn't know what the truth is.To long telling his lies to know about the truth.Time the government put this man and his company out of business for good.His record stands for it self.Don't know how some people can live with their conscience and sleep good at night.

Livermore Resident's picture

Decoster

Have you ever worked for Jack Decoster? Well I have and it provided my family and I an income and I believe that every company has its faults. I believe that half the people that make the comments against Jack Decoster don't know him or have never been at the plant or barns. Why is he to blame on how people choose to live in the mobile homes??? He is one man that built a very large business from a barn out back. I think that every business has its problems as his does, but lets all remember how many people he has employed and families that he has helped by him owning this business. We are all very quick to judge. Now lets say he closes the business how would all these workers feel as well as the town of Turner and then we could pay even more for our eggs that have to be shipped even further. I think people are so quick to judge others. Maybe some of these folks should get a job and be productive.

Chrisbee's picture
verified

So that makes it ok?

We wouldn't tolerate it if someone employed children to do those jobs, or if they were paid pennies per hour. Why does the fact that he gives people jobs make it ok? Why is the fact that people had to work in deplorable conditions ok? Why is the fact that the product of that got sold and people got sick ok?

Yes, it's fantastic that he employs people. It's fantastic that he does charity. None of that excuses the things wrong that were done. None of that means we should let him slide (yet again).

I've never worked for him, but I do know people that have. People that got sick doing so. People that couldn't eat eggs for years afterward because of what they saw there. Their experiences aren't any less valid than your's. I'd be willing to bet money that there are a lot more people UNhappy to work or have worked for DeCoster than are happy.

As for being quick to judge, how long should we wait? The point of these stories is, DeCoster's shenanigans have been going on for decades. He's had many many years to clean up his act and get better. Instead, he chose to shuffle the paperwork on his Maine farms and concentrate on states where he hadn't gotten in as much trouble yet.

If I caught my nephew doing something wrong, I wouldn't trust the excuse to pop out of his mouth unless it sounded like the truth. What DeCoster said doesn't even sound a little like the truth. Either he's a smart and savvy businessman who extended his farming business across multiple states, or he's a lucky idiot who wasn't aware of what was going on under his nose. Either way, his explanation doesn't wash, because he SHOULD have known, and he SHOULD have taken steps to do something about it.

tron's picture

While the government hasn't seemed to stop Jack, let's

hope the results of the impending lawsuits might change his mind. That will take a while, because I'm certain he'll fight to the bitter end, then declare bankruptcy and fail to pay any judgement.

Maineiac in VT's picture

You can bet that's how it

You can bet that's how it will play out.

Advertisement