Study says casinos in rural counties lead to more drunk-driving deaths

OXFORD — Anti-casino groups unveiled a fresh argument against the proposed Oxford County casino Thursday.

According to a recent study published in the Journal of Health Economics, casinos in rural counties bring a 9.2 percent increase in drunken-driving fatalities. It's the first study to examine the relationship between drunken-driving fatalities and casinos.

“It's entirely appropriate for Oxford,” said Dennis Bailey, executive director of CasinosNo!. He said the county's highways could become more dangerous with a large facility serving alcohol.

Robert Lally, an investment partner in casino sponsor Black Bear Entertainment, accused CasinosNo! of using scare tactics as the election draws near.

“We were kind of expecting the opposition to come at us with some of these scare tactics,” he said Thursday.

"They don't want to talk about jobs and they don't want to talk about school funding and an additional $50 million in tax revenue," Lally said. "We expect to see more of their scare tactics in the next couple of days."

The study was conducted by economics professors Chad D. Cotti and Douglas M. Walker of the University of Wisconsin Oshkosh and the College of Charleston, respectively. It concluded that in urban areas, casinos can decrease drunken-driving fatalities.

In urban counties, Cotti and Walker conclude, casinos can decrease the distance people drive after drinking. Where the population is more sparse, they write, impaired drivers will travel more. The study accounts for increases in population and changes in alcohol laws in its conclusion.

According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, three people died in Oxford County last year as a result of impaired driving, defined as driving over the legal blood alcohol content limit of 0.08 percent. The NHTSA data shows one drunken-driving death in 2008 and one in 2007.

“We've never seen that at Hollywood Slots,” Randy Seaver, spokesman for the pro-casino group Take Charge Maine, said Thursday. “You don't see a whole lot of people using public transportation in Bangor.”

The study said the presence of casinos could also increase drunken-driving deaths in neighboring counties.

treaves@sunjournal.com

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Displaying comments, from newest to oldest

Angel's picture

Dennis Bailey needs to find a

Dennis Bailey needs to find a 'real job'! What does he do besides try to get rid of any business thats will create jobs in Maine? MAybe he needs to go back to being a car salesman in the family business...let him see what it is like to really work...

crankbait's picture

casino

casino casino casino........it not a casino with a resort.............Its a resort with a casino. Think of it as a Cabelas type attraction.....The only people who dont want the casino are old or trust fund babies from out of state. Get over it you moved to Oxford not Oxbow!

Philblampied's picture
verified

More people, more incidents of all kinds

Put a casino in a place where there were about 500 people a day and suddenly you have 5000 people a day.

That means that every form of human experience will be multiplied by something like a factor of 10. There will be 10 times as many muggings. There will be 10 times as many cases of acne. There will be 10 times as many random acts of kindness by strangers.

Of course there will be more traffic incidents because the traffic will be that much greater.

The solution: go for the ghost town solution. Do nothing to create jobs and bring in revenue to the area. Eventually there will be no drunken driving or accidents. No driving at all, in fact. No, or precious few, people. Then call the place Baileytown.

K0NPHL1C7's picture

How about creating jobs in

How about creating jobs in other ways? Do more things to bring ethical businesses to your area. Don't make a deal with the devil for a "quick fix" at the expense of those who came to Maine because of the quality of life.

candiceanne's picture

KONPHL1C7 we are all waiting

KONPHL1C7 we are all waiting for you to bring on these other ways and ethical businesses with all the jobs.

Rock Lobster's picture

Explain the "expense" ...

-what is "at the expense" of "those who came to Maine"?
What about the quality of life for those that have always been here? A lot of "quality life" perks come to areas supporting Casinos.
Are tax-exempt church Bingos "ethical"?
How about those of you, who bitch at others for the ideas they come up with, come up with some solutions yourself (instead of just jock-blocking opportunity for others).
-that would be refreshing.

eddie's picture

the study is not valid in Maine.....here is why

The authors by thier admission do not seperate jurisdictions where casino give away free liqour and those that do not like Maine....they even say in footnote #3 it is a limitation in the report. they also suggest in casinos that charge for liqour the tendency could work in the opposit as customers would want to gamble rather then but a drink...another scare tactic by the master boogie man Dennis bailey..vote yes on 1

angelsx34eva's picture

Geo...

Does it really matter that someone may not know how to write properly?....Some misspelled words and left out periods and commas...is this really a big deal?...You basically are making fun of someone here...why don't you search the archives of the SJ over the past week and read the article on bullying....

Geo's picture

Bit of advice

roadwolfwalker your views may be better heard if you could write with some form of sentence structure!!! I realize the freedom of this forum, but some folks should stop and read their dialogue before committing to post.

candiceanne's picture

Left out a lot of relevent considerations

Notice they did not take into consideration the effect of unemployment on alcohol consumption. Nor did they take into consideration the effect of depression which is frequently a consequence of unemployment with the likelihood increasing the longer the unemployment and that alcohol is frequently, though mistakenly since it is a depressant, used to self medicate. Please feel free to jump in KSaisi since you know more about these things as a drug counselor than I do.

angelsx34eva's picture

So I Read This Article...

and basically what I got from it was its ok to have a casino in a "urban area" because the "drunk driver" has less travel time...but it's not okay to build it in a "rural area" because the drunk driver has more travel time....Did the State of Maine legalize "Drunk Driving" sometime and I missed it?

K0NPHL1C7's picture

Not to mention a double-digit

Not to mention a double-digit increase in other crimes.

Gary52's picture
verified

State government promised us

State government promised us money for education when they brought in the lottery, then, like every other dollar raised, they stole it for their own entitlement programs. The casino will not cost taxpayers one lousy cent, and it will create jobs, both directly and indirectly. People are already spending at casinos, but out of state. I think we are overdue to get in on this, before it's too late.

what if's picture

What

will they come up with next? Read the court news! There's no casino and yet there are plenty of OUI arrests. Socioeconomics, i.e., abject poverty, joblessness, debt, and a myriad of other reasons for drunk driving. If people were working, earning a living, some of those problems might not be as pressing.

roadwolfwalker's picture

drunk drivers are here now

Maine police get at least 100 drunk driver every day in maine seven days a week more on weekends the casino has nothing to do with this a person can any where and drive drunk anytime of the day casino not the blame the drunk drivers they are people that will drive drunk until they get caught or run someone over that why no one ever should drive drunk its a total disrepect of human life drunk driveing kills unless you shut down all the places that serve beer and wine and still have drunk drivers that get smash at home and than drive to the store to buy more beer the casino not the blame the person driveing drunk is

lawntobemowed's picture

Money for education?

That was the argument for the Maine Lottery. I'm voting NO. Casino's are in the business of making money. They are not happy giving money away. Don't believe me? Look at the sucker bets the Maine Lottery has going. Buy a $1 scratch ticket or lottery ticket and my point will be proven. Give a Maine worker a dollar and he'll give you two dollars worth of work. That's what we want Maine to be known for.

Rock Lobster's picture

BFD ...

-increased serving of alcohol & consumption in any area will lead to increased drinking and driving episodes.
Why not a paper-cup waste study? How about increased carcinogens from increased cigarette consumption? I know, let's study how much tire-tread will be lost driving to and fro a rural casino ... and think of the increased gas consumption -oh no!
"Unveiled a fresh argument" -that's so pathetic it's funny.
Might as well have revealed a fresh box of tiny rubberbands, that was such a ridiculous and useless "argument". And a study for it? -I hope no one paid for that *gem" that even a twelve year old kid would even find obvious.
Give it up, grandmas, and get your slot-pulling arms in shape ... -the casino, it's coming.

Advertisement