LEWISTON — Before exploring Asian countries online, 6th-grade teacher Sara Hogate asked her class: How many good cards did they get that Wednesday?
Sixteen, her Longley Elementary School students answered.
“Who remembers how many we got the day before?” The answer was 19. “So we went down a bit. I want to get it back up. Yusuf, it's your turn to write the chart.”
The boy went to the board and updated the chart. Hogate passed out good cards.
Ali got one for working quietly, Mohamed for helping to clean. “Ben and Yusuf also got good cards for helping clean,” Hogate said. Mohamed, Kyle, Hussein and Joey got cards for helping or being quiet after lunch.
As the teacher talked, noise from students talking got louder. “Why do I hear people talking when I'm talking?” she asked. “That's not respectful.” The noise subsided.
As part of the first year of a major school improvement plan at Longley, “good cards” and a Positive Behavior Intervention and Support program are new ways students are taught and encouraged to behave, allowing more time for learning.
All Lewiston schools this year have adopted the program and three student rules: “safe, respectable and responsible,” said Longley Principal Linda St. Andre. How the rules play out differ from school to school.
At Longley, rules are posted in classes, the cafeteria, the playground, even the water fountain.
When students follow the rules, “they get a good card,” said Hogate, 26, a recent University of Maine graduate. Students get prizes, a cupcake, gum, pencils or erasers for getting good cards. The behavior is discussed in class. When the daily count goes down, “we talk about what we can work on as a class,” Hogate said.
Each week every homeroom teacher holds a raffle drawing one good card. The winning student is sent to the principal's office for a treat and praise. “I talk to them about what they did to get a good card,” St. Andre said. “I thank them for being good Longley lions and encourage them to continue to make good choices.”
There are no cards for bad behavior but there are consequences, like losing recess, Hogate said. When that happens students meet with the teacher to talk about it. The goal is to respectfully correct and empower the student.
Longley has lists that spell out safe, responsible and respectable actions for different settings. At the water fountain, posted rules say: “Form a line. One at a time. Take a drink. Count to three.”
In the cafeteria lunch line, rules include: take turns, wait patiently, say please and thank you, follow cleanup directions, keep voices quiet. “It's all worded in the positive,” St. Andre said.
A group of third-graders eating lunch was asked to give examples of cafeteria rules. A half dozen eager hands shot up. “To use your manners,” Abdikani said. “To follow cleanup,” Miski said. “If you see a paper on the floor you pick it up.”
The federal improvement school program provides Longley with a behavioral specialist for 10 hours a week. That specialist gives group presentations to teachers and follows up with individual teachers in classrooms.
Overall, the program recommends five good cards be given for every one discipline referral. “When you reward kids for doing what you taught them, they'll continue to do it. Others will see it,” St. Andre said.
So far, students are responding, she said. About 80 percent of students are doing well, 20 percent need some intervention. “In that 20 percent some kids are written up once. A very small percentage are repeatedly written up.” Those students receive extra attention, she said.
Teaching students what behavior is expected, then praising them for doing it, means classrooms run smoothly and less instruction is interrupted, St. Andre said. “We can get on with the business of academics.”





Thank you "Think" Great post
Thank you "Think" Great post insight only a teacher would have!! Now If this Teacher had to post her Real name on this post do you think she would post it!! And face the lynch mod of parents in the morning!!! HUMM REX Think about it!!!!!!
- Permalink
- Is this comment inappropriate?
Would you like to respond? Login or create a new account. You'll need to verify your account before you can respond.Now I don't want to rain on
Now I don't want to rain on the parade but rewarding good behavior rather then punishing bad behavior might be easier for teachers but does nothing for molding children in to productive members of society. Why does everything have to be a bribe these days to get children to act correctly.I see it all the time most recently while out Christmas shopping kids crying and throwing fits and Parents bargaining you want a treat a toy ect to get the kids to behave. Our sensitive society is failing, Creating what I call "The tee-ball" culture (every one swings til they hit every hit is a home run and everyone wins) is destroying this generation. They will be helpless as adults expecting a FAIR life, where failure is rewarded and just showing up should be cause for promotion. I know my parents never spanked us growing up, but that's only because we never called their bluff, I think the closest I ever came was my Dad getting his belt half way off and I fell in line!! In life, in sports, in business It pays to be a winner. Or used to!! I guess if all we expect out of our children is mediocrity that's all we will get. A society where excellence and failure both get first Prize does us all a disservice.
- Permalink
- Is this comment inappropriate?
Kudos AwardedAgree (2)
Would you like to respond? Login or create a new account. You'll need to verify your account before you can respond.Please Rain on the Parade of Foolishness
I am a teacher. I know first hand what it is like in a classroom. The behavior program is not "new" at all. These tricks have all been tried before, and they do not work, at least not in the long run. In the meantime, it does nothing but give the overworked teachers more work to do. Think about it. The expectation is to give five good cards for every one bad card. So, when the naughties act up - and they will no matter what- and you give a bad card, well then forget about teaching and learning because now the focus is getting out five good cards to the one bad one. This becomes an unreasonable, and utterly ridiculous task. These behavior programs and plans never work. What works is accountability and parental involvement. But, teachers' hands are tied when it comes to accountability. Many of us believe that if you don't do the work you shouldn't pass...period. After all, we are supposed to be preparing kids to become successful members of society. In the real world, if someone doesn't do their work the consequence is termination. That's it. That's real. When a worker acts inappropriately it does not become the employer's job to find out why and come up with a plan to fix it. The employer doesn't now have to work harder becasue the employee chose to blow off the work, act inappropriately or just plain old act like a clown and break the rules. We all do the best we can with every child, but we should not be expected, as one poster suggested, to get to the core of the behavior. The problems with kids go very, very deep and we cannot possibly fix them. My god, use your heads here and think. Where on god's green earth do you think we can possibly find the time to do that? Do you realize just how much difficulty we face every day? Apparently not. The problem is primarily parental in nature, period - fed by our developing "look at me" culture in general. Such a sad state of affairs really. Please stop putting all the ills of children on the backs of schools and teachers to fix. I think you will see many, many good teachers leaving the profession in the not so distant future because of these kinds of absurd expectations. Bravo to them and bravo to me when I do it, because as it stands now, the toll it is taking on our health and well-being isn't worth it- no matter how much we love teaching itself.
- Permalink
- Is this comment inappropriate?
Kudos AwardedAgree (2)
Would you like to respond? Login or create a new account. You'll need to verify your account before you can respond.Thank you "Think" Great post
Thank you "Think" Great post insight only a teacher would have!! Now If this Teacher had to post her Real name on this post do you think she would post it!! And face the lynch mod of parents in the morning!!! HUMM REX Think about it!!!!!!
- Permalink
- Is this comment inappropriate?
Would you like to respond? Login or create a new account. You'll need to verify your account before you can respond.It is good to hear that the positive
is working at Longley. I do hope that all children get praised for making good choices. I agree that sometimes the kids who have good behavior all the time get overlooked on the praise and that stinks for them. I have personally witnessed the "naughty" kids getting more kudos and rewards than the well-behaved kids due to behavior plans, etc. It would be great to see the typical/average kids get more of that positive stroking and it sounds like Longley is doing just that. I think the children at Longley with thrive with this kind of program in place.
- Permalink
- Is this comment inappropriate?
Would you like to respond? Login or create a new account. You'll need to verify your account before you can respond.It is good to hear that the positive
is working at Longley. I do hope that all children get praised for making good choices. I agree that sometimes the kids who have good behavior all the time get overlooked on the praise and that stinks for them. I have personally witnessed the "naughty" kids getting more kudos and rewards than the well-behaved kids due to behavior plans, etc. It would be great to see the typical/average kids get more of that positive stroking and it sounds like Longley is doing just that. I think the children at Longley with thrive with this kind of program in place.
- Permalink
- Is this comment inappropriate?
Kudos AwardedAgree (1)
Would you like to respond? Login or create a new account. You'll need to verify your account before you can respond.BUT I LOVE HIM!
a boyfriend that doesn't work, plays video games all day, and most days when this child comes home, the boyfriend is drunk...he's not physically abusive to this child...but it is abuse...only in a different form...I've told my friend several times "You want change?..Your tired of hearing from the school?..Get rid of HIM and your problems will go away"
There's your problem!!!!!!
- Permalink
- Is this comment inappropriate?
Would you like to respond? Login or create a new account. You'll need to verify your account before you can respond.If Only...
This type of program was implemented in all our elementary schools across the board...too many times kids are only singled out for what they do that is "bad"....if a child knows there is going to be an "award" of some kind being given out for the "good" things they do, maybe the "bad" would disappear....Yes, there are those kids that no matter what you do for them are going to continue there "bad" behavior...I believe this starts at home...It's not taught in our schools, so it's learned somewhere...one can only assume it starts at home and I'm not one to "assume" things too easily...but come on...The "culture clash" in our schools is growing at an alarming rate..and as parents it is our responsibility to teach our children about "diversity"....then I think it's up to the schools to do there part also...When I hear a 5th grader talking "smack" about a somalian kid I just shake my head...where is that learned?...At HOME..We all need to get along; parents, students and teachers alike...All of our children should be praised at school and at home...This is a whole new era...a whole new generation...if teachers want respect they need to give it...And if there's a child in a class that's constantly getting into trouble...there's something wrong...and as teachers; whom spend the most time with our children; they need to step up to the plate and find out why...I have a friend whose son is constantly in trouble in school...this friend has a boyfriend that doesn't work, plays video games all day, and most days when this child comes home, the boyfriend is drunk...he's not physically abusive to this child...but it is abuse...only in a different form...I've told my friend several times "You want change?..Your tired of hearing from the school?..Get rid of HIM and your problems will go away"...It does take a village to raise a child...and I praise Longley School and Miss Hogate for there work here...It seems to be working....Now we need to get this program in all our elementary schools....
- Permalink
- Is this comment inappropriate?
Would you like to respond? Login or create a new account. You'll need to verify your account before you can respond.It will only work
if all staff members are consistent and have the same expectations. Your one weak link will wreck the program. When I was a student in an area school they had PRIDE cards. All the teachers would give these cards to the worst acting kids and they would be the winners every week. The good kids would seldom win. Eventually it was only the special ed. (behavior impaired) kids that would be recognized. Non special ed teachers seldom or completely stopped passing out PRIDE cards. I used to see kids going to the drawing box stuffing handfuls of PRIDE cards. Teachers, don't get lax with this program and it should work fine. Good luck. Hope it works. Hope it doesn't make kids grow in to adults that expect something for doing what they should do automatically.
- Permalink
- Is this comment inappropriate?
Kudos AwardedAgree (2)
Would you like to respond? Login or create a new account. You'll need to verify your account before you can respond.Thumbs up
Great program.. schools need to do more to award good behavior. It creates a new incentive and lets exemplar students know how appreciated they really are by their teachers, something that can sometimes be overshadowed when a teacher spends so much time dealing with the troublemakers.
The two stories in this series are spectacular so far, but when it comes to Lewiston's schools, especially Longley, it'd be especially interesting if the Sun Journal took a close look at the roots of the challenges that exist. It's frustrating, because I know there is a lot of praise deserved in our schools, but the SJ has never taken a critical look into the Somali population and the societal clashes of how they raise their children vs. the typical way an American child is raised and how THAT presents challenges in our schools. In our press we see nothing but positive stories about the Somali community, while among our citizens the response is mostly negative, and there is resent or dismissal whenever the SJ gives us those positive stories because that's all we see. Why not dig deep and do something more than just a puff piece (even if it IS well deserved)?
I realize I got a bit off topic, but I feel so strongly about this.
- Permalink
- Is this comment inappropriate?
Kudos AwardedAgree (2)
Would you like to respond? Login or create a new account. You'll need to verify your account before you can respond.