Military recruiting ads present false image

The science fiction of military marketing

I'm a video game geek, so as I sat through movie previews a few weeks ago, I was sure I was watching Nintendo ads.

There on the cinema's screen was a super-sleek plane flying over a moonscape while communicating with an orbiting satellite. In the next moment, a multi-colored topographical map, orders being barked — and in my own mind, memories of "Call of Duty" graphics. And then, finally, two guys in front of a computer console, and the jarring punch line: "It's not science fiction; it's what we do every day," said the bold type, followed by a U.S. Air Force symbol.

Before giving the audience a chance to digest the slogan, it was onto another montage, this one of helicopters and explosions with 1970s music playing in the background. A preview for a Steve McQueen-themed game, I thought. Then, though, the familiar kicker: "The drones fight terrorism and protect America, and in the process, they keep the frontlines unmanned," said the voiceover, adding, "This isn't science fiction; this is life in the United States Navy."

The ads preceded "The Hurt Locker" — a dramatized movie about soldiers who defuse roadside bombs in the midst of Iraq's horrifying carnage. And even with its fictionalized dialogue, the film was far more honest than the U.S. military's fantastical sales pitch. Join the armed forces, the ads suggest, and you don't have to experience the blood-and-guts consequences of combat. Instead, thanks to drone technology, you get to hang out stateside and entertain yourself with a glorified PlayStation.

During this, one of the bloodiest months in the Afghanistan War, the spots promote a somewhat comforting, if disturbingly misleading, message — and it is aimed not just at potential soldiers, but also at the public at large.

For the former, the goal is reassurance. As Bush-era attempts to conflate bellicosity and patriotism were undermined by persistent body bags, military recruitment has become more challenging. In response, the Pentagon hopes to make prospective volunteers believe their tours of duty will be as safe as a night on the couch.

For the general public, the objective is sedation. New polls show the country strongly opposes the Afghanistan and Iraq wars — but military officials want to preserve the possibility of an escalation in Afghanistan and a permanent deployment in Iraq. So along with persuading President Obama to withhold photos documenting fog-of-war brutalities at Afghanistan and Iraq prisons, the Pentagon is seeking an opiate to placate the war-averse populace. What better anodyne than a marketing campaign implying wars are fun video games?

Certainly, the ads aren't pure "science fiction." As the armed forces build more unmanned drones, Popular Science magazine reports that recruiters are indeed looking to add new remote pilots. The "science fiction" is the specific assertion that "the frontlines are unmanned." Claims like that are deeply destructive, beyond their obvious insult to the thousands killed, wounded and/or currently stationed on those very frontlines.

For instance, it's a good bet more than a few enlistees will expect their service to be happy video game tournaments, only to find themselves dodging real bullets in a Baghdad shooting gallery.

More broadly, the American psyche's slow progress toward an increasingly peaceful disposition could be stunted by the propaganda's powerful paradox: While sanitizing ads play to the country's growing disgust with militarism, they could ultimately lead us to be more supportive of militarism. How? By convincing us that violence can be just another innocuous expression of adolescent technophilia.

If we end up thinking that, we will have once again forgotten what all wars, even the justifiable ones, always are: lamentable human tragedies.

David Sirota is a syndicated columnnist and author. His e-mail address is: ds@davidsirota.com.

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Displaying comments, from newest to oldest

Pirate's picture
verified

Hey, Sirota....don't like

Hey, Sirota....don't like it? Don't join.
If you're concerned about deceptive advertising, why don't you write a column on the slick shell game the congress and obama administration are trying to pull over on us regarding national healthcoverage. Notice I said healthcoverage and not healthcare. Everybody is getting the healthcare they need; rich or poor. Everyone does not have healthcoverage, however. It's all part of the same scam.

nmcssc's picture
verified

This now a country of people

This now a country of people who are not willing to do what is necessary to defend it against it's enemies. It starts with the present administration and congress. All the administration's doing is to take away the necessary tools that today's military needs to do it's job. Pretty sad when troops do not have bullets for their guns, or have to wait for a lawyer to tell them if it's ok to defend themselves. Most of todays military are people out there doing a job that needs to be done and doing a very good job of it with the resources available to them. I wish I could say the same about congress.

verified

The former congress of

The former congress of Republicans also cut back funding for bullet proof vests, rifles, scopes, Humvee armor, and sent them out nearly unprepared. How about you speak what the prior administration said and back it up with correct knowledge and not your own prior knowledge of events. Also now after denying the CIA and Armed Services from burning the opium crop that sprung up; Obama signed official papers for it to be burned and putting Afghanistan back on the correct path for business. Bush and the conservative congress allowed it to grow nearly unwatched while who knows were it was sent. You say we are not willing to defend against our enemies and we are since that time opium war lords have paid a heavy price since that signing and the crops have literally gone up in smoke.

Joseph Ziehm
Lewiston, ME
"Masters, give unto your servants that which is just and equal; knowing that ye also have a master in heaven. Continue in prayer, and watch in the same with thanksgiving;" Colossians 4: 1-2

Mac antSaior's picture
verified

Top Gun didn't make me think

Top Gun didn't make me think I was going to be a fighter pilot... On the other hand, recruitment ads showing some kid on a midnight to four am afterbrow watch on a lonely warf just don't grab our attention. I didn't know of anybody who went in thinking it would be glamorous ... or like a game of any sort. It's just people like Sirota who think that the only reason someone would choose a life of service to the country is because they were somehow duped.

It is the undauntable thought, my friend. The one that says, "I'm right!" ~Bobby Sands

veritas's picture
verified

I think I've got a few old

I think I've got a few old photos of the bar hogs in Subic Bay that might work as an inducement!!!

------------------------------------------
When I was a young Sailor - I drank like a Sailor, fought like a Sailor, and screwed like a Sailor. Now that I am old and wise - I have a few scars, but many fond memories.

Mac antSaior's picture
verified

Ahhh...memories of the

Ahhh...memories of the P.I.

It is the undauntable thought, my friend. The one that says, "I'm right!" ~Bobby Sands

Old Bill's picture

We don't need a draft. What

We don't need a draft. What we need is either an all-volunteer force (which we have now) or universal service. The latter works well for Israel. This, of course, would mean that Mr.Sirota (and most other libs) would be against universal service. So, Mr. Sirota, what would you have the Armed Forces do? Just pack it in, go away, and hope our nation's enemies leave us alone out of the goodness of their hearts?
"The democracy will cease to exist when the government takes from those who would work and gives to those who would not." - Thomas Jefferson.

tron's picture

Actually, I agree with

Actually, I agree with universal service. Everyone works two years in the military, if able, or some other public service IF, and ONLY IF, they are not qualified for military service. Definitely not an either or scenario. Republicans would puke at such a suggestion, considering our republican leaders haven't done anything for the country, IE, rush, sean, bill, dick, anne etc. Even on the local level, such as Councilor Reed or even his children, although only one is old enough. Republicans are generally, I know you'll find exceptions but generally, abhor any kind of community service.

jchick's picture
verified

David said: "...the American

David said: "...the American psyche's slow progress toward an increasingly peaceful disposition could be stunted by the propaganda's powerful paradox: While sanitizing ads play to the country's growing disgust with militarism, they could ultimately lead us to be more supportive of militarism."

Peacefull disposition? Pray tell, where have you been keeping your head burried for the last two years? I've never seen a time when the American people have been so divided over every issue imaginable. And the hateful things people say to each other, it's the furthest thing from a peaceful dispostition.

Disgust of militarism? How so? I think the nation has a disgust for war, but most of us know that a strong military is essential for maintaining the freedom and liberty we enjoy as American citizens. Personally, I'm disgusted with so-called journalists who find fault with anyone and everything that doesn't fit their world view fantasy. The MSM are the bigest purveyors of propaganda, not the armed forces.

John A. Chick

"If a nation expects to be ignorant and free, in a state of civilization, it expects what never was and never will be." -- Thomas Jefferson in a letter to Colonel Charles Yancey (January 6, 1816)

veritas's picture
verified

So what are you gonna do??

So what are you gonna do?? Patriotism isn't playing that well, and Congress doesn't have the gonads for the draft.

------------------------------------------
When I was a young Sailor - I drank like a Sailor, fought like a Sailor, and screwed like a Sailor. Now that I am old and wise - I have a few scars, but many fond memories.

Advertisement