Speculation gets us no closer to truth in shooting

Who's to blame for a 22-year-old opening fire on a crowd of people, killing six and severely injuring others, including a member of Congress?

We have no opinion on that, mainly because we have so few facts upon which to base an opinion.

That hasn’t stopped a host of people, particularly TV commentators and fellow politicians, from loudly reaching for what’s not there — an easy answer based upon tenuous connections that suit their political ends.

U.S. Rep. Gabrielle Giffords’ office was vandalized after she voted in favor of the Health Care Reform Act, so that may have been what touched off the violence.

She had voted in favor of comprehensive immigration reform, so maybe it was that.

Giffords was “targeted” by former Gov. Sarah Palin’s campaign to unseat Democratic members of Congress, so maybe it was the tea party's fault.

Perhaps the gunman was set off by the hostility of right-wing politics in America or, conversely, by similar vitriol from the left.

And, of course, there is the inevitable anti-firearm question: How does a young man recently thrown out of college for mental instability walk into a gun store and obtain a 9 mm handgun with an extended clip for holding extra rounds?

Which is quickly followed by the opposite argument: If more people in the crowd had guns, they could have shot the killer in the few seconds it took to unleash his deadly attack.

At this point, it could have been all of those things and, of course, none of them.

People who do things like this are most often simply suffering from some delusional mental illness such as schizophrenia, which is often “characterized by a disintegration of the process of thinking and of emotional responsiveness.”

Schizophrenics, while rarely violent, suffer from hallucinations, paranoia, delusions and disorganized speech and thinking.

What’s more, these conditions are often worsened by recreational drugs, including marijuana.

Jared Loughner, the gunman in Tucson, has been described as a “pot-smoking loner” who disrupted his college classes and frightened his fellow students with his hostility and incoherent ideas.

Which, if true, would mean he could just have easily focused his hatred on any number of targets: police, blacks, Hispanics, Christians, Muslims, his own family or his last girlfriend.

A paranoid schizophrenic needs enemies, and they can range from his co-workers to aliens from outer space.

At some point it seems likely we will know what was wrong with Jared Loughner. He was captured alive and will no doubt be analyzed by experts.

But it will clearly take weeks and months to unravel the delusions he held in his head or what finally prompted him to act.

In the meantime, the real-time nature of 24/7 news and commentary should allow us time to do the obvious — admit our confusion and sadness, and show compassion for those killed and injured.

editorialboard@sunjournal.com

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Displaying comments, from newest to oldest

summerzonly's picture
verified

It's Sarah Palin's "fault". Please!! Grow up!

Read the facts! This nutcase had Rep. Gifford in his sights for a long time before Gov. Palin's 'cross-hairs' campaign business. If you use your head for a minute, it might come to you that it was a figure of speech and a bit of campaign foolishness that, while not wise in hindsight, wasn't much different than what was going on across the aisle. To suggest that nothing of similar imflammatory political rhetoric came from the left side during the last campaign and/or the last ugly, nasty years of Bush's presidency is silly and disingenuous. You can twist most situations any which way to get the answer you want, particularly if you don't want to be distracted by the facts. I find it sad that this tragedy, which lays at the feet of a tortured, mentally-ill young man, has become political fodder. Sometimes if it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck........VOILA!! It's REALLY just a DUCK!

Read it right's picture

Here's a thought!

"Who's to blame for a 22-year-old opening fire on a crowd of people, killing six and severely injuring others, including a member of Congress?"

How about the 22-year-old? Has anyone thought that HE might be to blame?

Rev Jim's picture
verified

speculation

Mr. Loughner is the one to blame. And wasting time on speculation only throws a curve ball at the real issue. Why is there a blame game? Let him get his fair and quick trial and the ultimate consequences for his actions. Murder is murder, no ifs,ands, or buts!

ClasslessRepublican_isthereanyotherkind's picture

False equivalence as usual

The SJ is such a joke of a newspaper so I guess this is to be expected:

"Perhaps the gunman was set off by the hostility of right-wing politics in America or, conversely, by similar vitriol from the left."

Where are liberal and/or progressive pundits out calling for "2nd amendment solutions"? Has any liberal and/or progressive pundit told their audience 10% of the population may die because of the president's policies? The answer is no, but since the Sun Journal is the wasteland for Costello teahadism, I guess we should expect no better.

There is no similar vitriol from the left. There are no politicians on the left placing targets on the districts of Republicans they do not like. There are no politicians on the left calling for armed rebellion.

The Sun Journal's owners, Rupert Murdoch, Roger Ailes, Rush Limpbaugh, Sarah Palin, Glenn Beck and the rest of the right nutjobs should be shut down until they can all show they are able to lead reasonable, non inflammatory discussions and reporting.

rumforddude's picture

Do your research..

"I attended the convention and remember the terrorist acts that were carried out by anti-Republican protesters very well. They threw bricks through the windows of buses, sending elderly convention delegates to the hospital. They dropped bags of sand off highway overpasses onto vehicles below. Fortunately, no one was killed.

These were anti-Bush and anti-Republican protesters. Is it a stretch to think that some of them, at least, may have been inspired by over-the-top, hateful attacks on the Bush administration by Democratic Congressmen, DNC Chairman Howard Dean, Michael Moore, who was a guest of honor at the Democrats' own convention, various show business personalities, and many other leading liberal figures? I don't think so. We haven't seen that sort of hate campaign since the Democrats went after Abraham Lincoln. It seems unlikely that none of the "protesters" who tried to commit murder were inspired by those liberal voices.

Yet, hardly anyone seems to be aware of the violence that took place in 2008. At most, the story was treated with a ho-hum attitude in the press. For some reason, political violence was not a concern less than two years ago. Yet today, we can hardly imagine what would happen if a group of tea partiers were to drop sandbags off a highway overpass, trying to kill motorists below. Liberal reporters' heads would explode. But this is exactly what anti-Republican Party protesters did in 2008, and no one cared. To my knowledge, not a single Democratic politician condemned this anti-Republican violence or attempted in any way to distance the Democratic Party from it."

Read more: http://newsbusters.org/blogs/noel-sheppard/2010/03/28/media-forget-leftw...

http://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2010/04/what_about_left_wing_violenc...

Lil's picture
verified

WND

What's next, World Nut Daily?

Pirate's picture
verified

..."so maybe it was the tea

..."so maybe it was the tea party's fault"...
Right, and if she were republican instead of democrat, she'd be tagged by the left as having provoked the shooter into action. Face it, the guy's a wack job. An insane person did it. Everything else being bandied about is bs.

tron's picture

and YOU'RE the bs expert

and YOU'RE the bs expert

Pirate's picture
verified

Ahhh, another name calling

Ahhh, another name calling session from the lower echelon mammal.

Jason's picture
verified

Fact of the matter is this

Bad things happen to good people for no reason.

Now, hopefully some good will come from this. Maybe both sides will take pause, and look at their rhetoric. Do I think Sarah Palin set this nutjob on this congresswomen? No. However, everyone needs to remember that you never know for sure. Maybe it did, maybe he took SarahPac's ad to heart in his crazy mind, and decided to kill the congresswomen. Maybe Count Chocola told him to do it. We'll never know.

But remember, it could have. So everyone remember to weigh your words carefully.

tron's picture

Finally someone is getting

Finally someone is getting it, now if only you could convince the right wing wackos. Good Luck!

koalalover's picture

Count Chocola! LOL That's

Count Chocola! LOL That's cute. But, what you said is true....we'll never know.

blame

blame the complicated human brain...

tron's picture

"he could just have easily

"he could just have easily focused his hatred on any number of targets", but, of course the one person he targeted was the one of the people Sarah Palin targeted, in cross hairs no less, on her facebook page with the caption, don't retreat, reload. But, of course, it is ridiculous to suggest that it had any affect on this poor deranged man. Until people accept that what they do have consequences, nothing will change. I guess that's what you want.

Pirate's picture
verified

"poor deranged man"....birds

"poor deranged man"....birds of a feather flocking together?

heijoeray's picture

shooting

We have become a country divided by extremes, and need to get back to the center and focus on civil discussion instead of attacking each other.

Pirate's picture
verified

Many of us can remember when

Many of us can remember when America wasn't like this. Few of us have any hope that it end any time soon. Certainly not before we've had another civil war, or something similar. The polarizing factors are too extreme for anyone to imagine peaceful resolution, except for maybe the lofitest of dreamers.

Erin's picture
verified

Exactly when are we talking about?

Have you ever picked up a history book, or are you just going off what you've read on the internet since its invention in the 90's? American politics has always been a place of controversy, hate speech, nut jobs, militia groups, etc. We've had attempted assassination and assassinations of political figures since the birth of the country. Please give me more specific dates of the utopia time of America

ConservaMom's picture

I wish you weren't right

I wish you weren't right Pirate, but I have to agree with you. This will only continually get worse until we self-destruct. I just don't understand why anyone with any common sense can't see this terrible, terrible tragedy for what it is - a sick, deranged, psychopath who committed the most despicable of acts. Trying to spin this politically is just causing more divisiveness. Why is that so hard to see? I pray for the the victims of this horrible, horrible crime, including the alleged gunman's parents, and I pray for peace to someday be restored in our wonderful Country. God Bless.

Pirate's picture
verified

As the pirates like to say,

As the pirates like to say, "Without war there can be no peace".

tron's picture

The tragic part is people

The tragic part is people like you and pirate seem to want society to self destruct, so you can mold it in your own image. That's why the rabid right REFUSES to accept their culpability in this matter.

Pirate's picture
verified

And, Tron, to people like you

And, Tron, to people like you truth is but a lie undiscovered.But, if you're so concerned about the "rabid right", why don't you go out and get yourself a rabies shot.

freyt's picture

poor deranged man?

LOL.

Advertisement