Republicans show split with LePage on BPA

AUGUSTA — Dana Dow thought the Kid-Safe Products Act was a good idea in 2008. Three years later, he still does.

That's why Dow, a Republican state representative from Waldoboro, hopes to convince his GOP colleagues to resist Gov. Paul LePage's proposal to overturn the law that Dow helped lead to overwhelming bipartisan passage in the Legislature.

Dow said he planned to meet with GOP leadership to make sure that the law designed to keep harmful chemicals out of children's products remains.

That meeting may not be necessary.

Several members of the House and Senate GOP leadership indicated Monday that there isn't much support to repeal legislation that most recently facilitated a ban on bisphenol-A, or BPA.

The governor's plan to repeal the Kid-Safe Products Act has generated a firestorm. Several studies have linked infant exposure to the chemical with health and development problems, including cancer. And several major retailers, including Wal-Mart, have stopped selling products containing BPA.

LePage's aides say the science on BPA is divided and that absent "consensus science," the ban, and Kid-Safe, should be repealed.

Some Republicans aren't so sure.

"There might be ways to improve the law," Senate President Kevin Raye, R-Perry, said. "But the basic principle that the law was based upon had very strong support and I don't see that changing."

Kid-Safe, which was co-sponsored by Dow, passed 35-0 in the Senate and 129-9 in the House. Seventy-four lawmakers that supported the bill are still in the Legislature, including 32 Republicans.

Raye supported the bill in 2008 and helped negotiate language that mandated state toxicologists to participate in the review of 200 priority chemicals such BPA.

LePage's plan to overturn the ban has mobilized environmentalists and activists who claim the governor's proposal was the result of out-of-state influences and the national chemical lobby.

The controversy reached a crescendo last week following publication of LePage's comment that the only harmful effect of BPA was that women could develop "little beards."

Some members of Republican leadership said Monday that the BPA debate had armed opponents and diverted attention from the party's job-creation agenda.

"This discussion about BPA has overshadowed true regulatory reform," said Sen. Jonathan Courtney, R-York, the Senate majority leader. "I’m here to create opportunities to create jobs and that’s the number one priority. I don’t see where that (reversing the BPA ban) does that at this point."

Courtney, who also supported the bill in 2008, said the uproar had also "ginned up" the environmental lobby.

"They’ve been handed the tools to raise money and cultivate their base," he said.

Rep. Andre Cushing, R-Hampden, the assistant majority leader in the House said LePage's "off-the-cuff" comment about BPA and the ensuing media attention had become a distraction.

Cushing also voted for Kid-Safe in 2008.

Leadership's apparent unwillingness to support the governor's stand marks the party's first public split with LePage. It could test the governor's ability to broker deals with the legislative branch.

Cushing and Courtney said Monday that they hadn't heard from the governor or his staff about repealing the ban.

The split could also test GOP lawmakers' willingness to support some of the governor's more controversial proposals. LePage has said that he doesn't care if he's a one-term governor, but lawmakers are elected to two-year terms and are more closely connected to their communities.

Dow said Monday that he'd received numerous phone calls from constituents opposing repeal of the Kid-Safe law and the BPA ban.

Dow said he wasn't sure where the idea of overturning Kid-Safe originated.

"For me it’s one of those issues that may have been from an out-of-state concern," he said. "We have all kinds of lobbyists running around here representing all kinds of companies and things."

What do you think of this story?

Login to post comments

In order to make comments, you must create a subscription.

In order to comment on, you must hold a valid subscription allowing access to this website. You must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. To subscribe or link your existing subscription click here.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned from posting comments.



Sadie Roberts's picture



Bob Deschenes's picture

Kid Safe Act

We should be able to repeal the last election. The KMA gov has to go.

Bob Deschenes's picture

Kid Safe Act

We should be able to repeal the last election. The KMA gov has to go.

Greg Rose's picture

Lepage doesn't care if he is a one term governor? I DO!

Lepage embarrasses all Maine citizens virtually every time he speaks. (Well, almost all Maine citizens - I am sure there are some AMiners in perfect lock step behind his each and every faux pas.) I care that he even got elected to one term... that NEVER should have happened. And to those who will respond to this and say "the people have spoken" and elected him. 38% of Mainers "spoke" for Lepage with their votes. Courtesy of party politics, 38% was enough for him to get elected. Libby Mitchell was able to distract enough party loyalists to her side to destroy Eliot Cutler's chance to be Governor and actually LEAD Maine instead of embarrassing Maine.

It is incredibly unfortunate that party politics, regardless of party, has corrupted the American system of government at every level.

 's picture

LePage out-of-touch with reality

LePage's plan to repeal Kid-Safe Law, i.e. poison infants, and his ignorant comments about "little beards" on women only continue to prove that he is unqualified to be governor and even the Republican Party knows this. His proposal to open 3 million acres of wildreness land to rapid unregulated development must make outdoor recreationists happy. His plan to cut wages by about 25% by prohibiting our Constitutional rights to organize into unions must make workers happy. His budget plans to cut jobs throughout the state must make teachers and first-responders happy. LePage must aspire to be a standup comic.


Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...