Maine GOP chair questions 19 voter registrations in 2004; probe reveals displaced medical students voted legally

AUGUSTA — In the latest twist in the debate over same-day voter registration, the chairman of the Maine Republican Party on Friday questioned why 19 individuals staying in a South Portland hotel were allowed to register to vote on Election Day in 2004.

Associated Press file photo

Maine GOP Chairman Charlie Webster

As it turns it out, the individuals were American college students, who appear to have registered and voted legally.

Questioned by the Sun Journal, Jason Bartlett, general manager of the Holiday Inn Express on Sable Oaks Drive, said the students had been "permanent guests" at the hotel because their medical school on Grand Cayman Island in the Caribbean had been destroyed by Hurricane Ivan.

The 19 students, who came from states across the country, were among 383 students enrolled at St. Matthew’s University School of Medicine. All were displaced by the storm. According to Bartlett, the students were sent to Maine to continue their studies while their school was repaired.

St. Joseph's College in Standish assisted in the relocation program, according to a college spokesperson.

The relocation was the subject of a Press Herald story published in September 2004.

Maine Republican Party Charlie Webster did not identify the individuals as students in his news release. He made no reference to the circumstances that led to their relocation to Maine.

"Mainers should be very concerned that 19 individuals, who all listed the same hotel address, were able to register to vote and cast a ballot, all on a busy Election Day," Webster said in the release issued Friday morning.

Asked Friday if he called the hotel to inquire about the individuals, Webster said he didn't. He added that their circumstances were irrelevant to his argument that town clerks need more time to verify whether the individuals were actual residents or had cast ballots elsewhere during the same election.

"We don’t know that unless somebody has a chance to inspect their name," Webster said. "That’s the whole issue here."

He said it was possible that the students registered as part of a partisan voting drive.

Of the 19 students who registered, seven enrolled as Democrats, seven declined to choose a party, four registered as Republicans and one was a Green Independent. Their ages ranged from 21 to 46.

Webster said the problem was that the students hadn't planned to stay in Maine.

He added, "It's obvious to me that these people never intended to stay here because they never voted again in Maine."

According to news reports from 2004, the students returned to St. Matthew's in 2005. However, there is no law that requires individuals who establish residency and vote in Maine to remain here for a specific period.

Voters must meet three requirements to establish residency. An individual must be a U.S. citizen, must establish and maintain a residence in the municipality where the person intends to register to vote and must be at least 18 years old.

The law also allows an individual to use a "nontraditional" address, such as a dormitory, to establish residency when registering to vote. According to Bartlett, the hotel doubled as a dormitory for the displaced students because there wasn't sufficient housing at St. Joseph's College.

The U.S. Supreme Court in 1979 ruled that college students can list their dormitories as their residences to establish residency and to vote. That decision has irked Webster and others who believe students can affect local or legislative elections, even though they might leave.

In 2008, the Legislature killed a Republican-backed bill designed to prohibit out-of-state college students from voting in the communities in which their schools were located. Attorney General Steven Rowe said the proposal was unconstitutional under the 1979 ruling.

Webster did not accuse the 19 students of committing fraud. However, his release follows a series of statements in which the GOP chairman has attempted to raise questions about potential gaming of Maine's election system.

Only two prosecutions for voter fraud have taken place in Maine in recent years.

Webster has ramped up the fraud rhetoric since the Republican-controlled Legislature last session repealed Maine's 38-year-old, same-day-registration law and required registration no closer than three business days before an election.

On Thursday, the Maine Secretary of State's Office certified a people's veto effort to restore same-day voter registration in Maine. The issue will be on the November ballot.

Members of the coalition hoping to restore same-day voter registration say Webster is making outrageous claims about out-of-staters and outsiders in an attempt to confuse voters.

Webster said he's simply representing the views of his party and regular people.

"I'm an oil-burner repairman and I bring to this party regular views from regular people," he said. "And regular people won’t be happy to think that someone is voting who has no intention of living here."

Ben Grant, chairman of the Maine Democratic Party, had a different view.

"Charlie Webster's campaign to intimidate voters and mislead the general public has gone too far," Grant said in release. "First he was attacking college students, now he's attacking victims of a natural disaster who had moved to Maine."

He added, "He's ruined his integrity. He's ruining the Republicans' integrity. And, he's damaging our entire political system through his fear-mongering and lies. It's embarrassing us as a state and as Mainers. Quite frankly, it's time for his colleagues within the Republican Party to join us in standing up against it."

Webster said he has the full support of the GOP. He said he was undeterred by criticism from Democrats.

"The left can make me their bogeyman if they want," he said. "I don't care."

What do you think of this story?

Login to post comments

In order to make comments, you must create a subscription.

In order to comment on, you must hold a valid subscription allowing access to this website. You must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. To subscribe or link your existing subscription click here.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned from posting comments.



Jane Ryerson's picture

gop questions 19 voters

Mr. Webster is correct. Whether these 19 ended up being here and using the holiday inn as their address is beside the point. I believe people should be pre-registered at least 24 hours prior to voting and should be a resident of the state of Maine. I don't believe students going to school here from other states have any right to vote. If they want to vote, they should be voting in their own state either by being their or by absentee. These out of state students should be voting for their own politicians that affect the decisions of the states they make. I am 100% behind pre-registration for voting. With all the fraud and illegals, same day voting should not be allowed.

 's picture

Voting in Maine made simple...

Simple answer to a simple question , not surprising Maine as a problem figuring out what is up or down.

As far as the students right to vote, it is simple. Unless they are paying instate tuition then they should be voting in their home states. Students pay out of state tuition for a reason.

It's a very simple process to sign up for absentee ballot. Now make that the law. Thats doing something worth while, writing laws that make sense.

I agree with Charlie, we must question voter integrity in some cases. Much like the Secretary of State validates voter in referendums.

Now keep it simple Maine, doing the right thing for the rights of the voter...And protect our system from voter fraud.


Wrong again Charlie

You are wrong now, you were wrong before, and, no doubt you will be wrong tomorrow unless there is a miracle, you see the light and become a Democrat or at least an honest Abe type Republican.
Don't you have something useful to do, like calling the Koch boys for a contribution or cleaning a furnace.

 's picture

paid for by

The S-J should use a different photo every now and then. Or start charging the Maine GOP for advertising space, or ad the script saying "this ad paid for by the S-J."

 's picture

New law seems fair

The law seems fair, but I keep wondering how much of my tax money funds this recall effort. With all these semi government organization gathering sig ayers an the such

 's picture

New law seems fair

The law seems fair, but I keep wondering how much of my tax money funds this recall effort. With all these semi government organization gathering sig ayers an the such

 's picture


Mr Webster's standing as the biggest tool in the state of Maine is intact! When is someone in the state GOP going to put a leash on this idiot?

 's picture

medical students?

I wasn't aware that St. Joe's has a medical program. According to their website, they only offer bachelor (sp), masters and post master certificates. So, what's the rest of the story?

 's picture

i think that they do have a

i think that they do have a nursing program. they were prob. continuing with classroom educational needs that could be met there as well as the hands on at maine med.

i do think though that the whole mantality of "i'm going to vote to affect change in this area today then go home tomorrow and leave the people here to deal with it" is fishy.


Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...