"We spoke with one voice:" Mainers vote to keep Election Day registration

LEWISTON — After several months of bizarre twists and turns, the battle over Election Day registration is over.

The coalition that sought to restore Maine's 38-year-old election law on Tuesday successfully beat back the Republican Legislature's efforts to repeal it.

And it wasn't close.

The Associated Press called the race for the Yes on 1 campaign at 9:40 Tuesday night.

According to unofficial results, the coalition that worked to restore EDR held a large lead over the groups that sought to repeal the law. With more than half of the state's 594 precincts reporting, voters favored retaining EDR, 60 percent to 40 percent.

The Yes on 1 campaign, which this summer gathered enough signatures in just seven weeks to get on the November ballot, won a wide cross-section of rural and urban precincts.

Mike Carey, D-Lewiston, called the campaign "a resounding victory for Maine," adding that support for voting rights was supported by voters regardless of party affiliation.

"We spoke with one voice," Carey said. "Now it's time to get back to Augusta and get back to work on the economy."

The defeat was a tough one for the Legislature's new Republican majority. The repeal of EDR was sponsored by GOP leaders, including House Speaker Robert Nutting, R-Oakland, and Senate President Kevin Raye, R-Perry.

But the GOP leadership was not the face of the No on 1 campaign. That role belonged to Maine Republican Party Chairman Charlie Webster. Webster's tactics during the campaign included alleging that college students were potentially committing voter fraud and that Democrats were guilty of poll flooding.

But Webster's accusations of fraud were never backed with hard evidence, leading EDR advocates to claim Webster was peddling fear to restrict typical Democratic constituencies from voting.

"The advantage we had was the truth," said David Farmer, spokesman for Protect Maine Votes. "The facts carried the day. Same-day voter registration works and it has for nearly 40 years. Unlike other states, Mainers wouldn't stand for the erosion of their voting rights. They should be very proud of that."

On Tuesday, Webster was unapologetic, despite taking heat during the final days of the campaign for a print ad that singled out a gay rights group's support for EDR.

"In politics you have those who want to get along and those who want to fight," he said. "I'm a fighter."

It remains to be seen whether Webster will pay a price among the Republican rank and file. Several GOP lawmakers were unenthusiastic about supporting repeal of EDR during the legislative session. Initial votes to pass LD 1376 failed in the Legislature as several Republicans sided with Democrats.

Asked if he thought his support for the repeal would cost him support in the party, Webster said he didn't think he had that much influence in legislative affairs.

"I wish I could take that much credit for anything," he said.

Asked if the loss would cost him the GOP chairmanship, Webster said, "If they want a street fighter, that's what they have. I would be shocked if more than a handful of people didn't support what I'm trying to do."

He added, "If they want to throw me under the bus, that's OK."

Democrats were quick to blast Webster on Tuesday.

"For months, Charlie Webster has been attacking and intimidating voters," Maine Democratic Party Chairman Ben Grant said. "He started this campaign with a baseless accusation of voter fraud and ended it with homophobic advertisements and mailers. All the while, Republican leaders stood on the sidelines silently condoning this behavior. And today, Mainers told them they would not stand for it."

Not quick to abandon campaign form, Webster attributed the coalition's victory to its deep pockets, in particular Donald Sussman, the hedge fund manager and husband of U.S. Rep. Chellie Pingree, D-Maine. Sussman, who gave heavily to the Yes on 1 campaign, has frequently contributed to progressive candidates and causes.

Webster said Mainers should be concerned that someone like Sussman can influence elections. However, he also acknowledged that the No on 1 campaign was at a disadvantage because the content of some of its advertisements was determined by outside groups.

"We couldn't control the message," he said.

Webster also said the issue didn't resonate with conservatives. The coalition argued that that was because Republicans and Democrats both supported voting rights.

"What this shows is that all Mainers — Republicans, Democrats and independents — take their voting rights very seriously," Farmer said.

Democrat and Republican voters have made heavy use of Election Day registration during the past two elections.

Toby McGrath, a political consultant who has run several referendum campaigns, including this year's Yes on 2 effort to authorize racinos in Biddeford and Calais, said the coalition supporting EDR ran a disciplined campaign designed to take advantage of the low turnout.

"They built a broad coalition, a coalition that you can turn into votes," McGrath said. "You can really affect an election when you have membership. Their ads were good. They were clear about what this was about. They used Mainers to explain this."

McGrath said opponents of EDR never found a consistent message.

"The No on 1 people were completely all over the place," McGrath said. "They were running 15-second ads; they were all over the place. They weren’t that clear and they weren’t authentic."

Webster's tactics in the campaign were a source of controversy, even among some Republicans. 

On Monday, Webster defended print ads paid for by the Maine GOP political action committee that targeted a gay rights advocacy group's support for EDR. Webster acknowledged that the ads prompted concerns from some Republican lawmakers that they cast the party in a negative light.

Republican tea party candidate for U.S. Senate Andrew Ian Dodge, who is taking on U.S. Sen. Olympia Snowe, R-Maine, said the ads were uncalled for. He said Webster should resign.

“The gay-bashing and xenophobic advertisements run recently by those against ballot Question 1 should be condemned by all Maine residents," Dodge wrote in a statement.

Nutting, who was the lead sponsor of the law repealing EDR, was unavailable for comment Tuesday night. His spokesman, Jim Cyr, said the speaker wouldn't release a statement until Wednesday.

Cyr, speaking on Nutting's behalf, said it was too soon to tell how the restoration of EDR would affect an upcoming effort to require voters to show photo identification at the polls. The Legislature held over that bill last session.

"The speaker believes that same-day voter registration and photo ID are separate issues," Cyr said.

Asked Tuesday if he was surprised by the margin of victory, Farmer said, "We're gratified by the margin."


What do you think of this story?

Login to post comments

In order to make comments, you must create a subscription.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must hold a valid subscription allowing access to this website. You must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your SunJournal.com profile. To subscribe or link your existing subscription click here.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned from posting comments.



 's picture

Content, emphasis, tone,

Content, emphasis, tone, intent. Mr. Mistler is consistent. EDR Was and is a non issue. Mr Summers characterized the issue as all of us rushing in on election day and legions of us overwhelming the clerks. And the opposite side depicting this as a dreadfull inconvenience, infantilizing our seniors and making it almost impossible for hard working people with two three jobs to register. Most hard working people, who do vote, somehow always find time to register anyway, most seniors are far more responsible than any of us. Whether this was thrown out or not, I doubt anyone would have noticed the difference. What a waste of time.

Laurel Frost's picture

I love this state!

Fellow Mainers, I want to thank 60% (give or take) of Maine for being able to think critically and see through the BS that was coming out of Augusta and from THEIR SUPPORTERS. Now we can find out who the out-of-staters REALLY are, and DON'T FORGET WHAT HAPPENED HERE, because this was only the FIRST YEAR of the LePage administration.

Mark Elliott's picture

Irregardless of what side of

Irregardless of what side of the issue you are on or even what the issue is. If we don't want to lose something we have then it is up to ALL of us to make sure it isn't abused. All it takes is a few to ruin it for all. I am willing to bet, in the future (well, the immediate future anyways because complacency will set in) both parties will scrutinize the process better and report anything "fishy". It is up to all of us, on both sides, to protect the integrity of our elections by reporting any abuse, even if it is by our own party.

 's picture

Who writes the ads?

I was struck by the statement, "[Charlie Webster] acknowledged that the No on 1 campaign was at a disadvantage because the content of some of its advertisements was determined by outside groups. 'We couldn't control the message,' he said."

What business did they have publishing ads that they couldn't control the message of?

Mark Elliott's picture

third party groups that

third party groups that believe they are "helping the cause" sometimes take out their own adds. This can send mixed messages. That is what he is referring to.

 's picture

See ya Charlies

Webster's comment about people getting along, vs people that fight, shows how out of touch he is.
There is no longer a place for the lies myth and simple bull that was slung from his side of the Issue 1 campaign. That's for 12 year olds planning a run for school council, not for thinking adults.
Charlies,,,,, I hope you think long and hard about the message that the vote on Issue 1 is sending your way, the time for you and your tired old politics has come to and end. See ya!

Scott Foster's picture

Both sides

I think both sides ran ads that were BS. The busy working person wasn't going to be able to vote? Really? They found time to register their car during the year. I would prefer to see something where if an election is close, same day registrations could be verified before the vote is finalized. That I think would be fair to all parties.

RONALD RIML's picture

So to the two Charlies

Both Webster & Summers We didn't buy your Crap.

The only fraud was that which 'You'se Guys' brought to the table.


Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...