Gingrich might be worth a second look

A successful presidential candidate taps into the public mood. Newt Gingrich must be hoping the public is bristling with irritation and high dudgeon.

The old saw is that the most dangerous place to be is between Chuck Schumer and a camera. The second most dangerous place to be is sitting across from Newt Gingrich on a stage asking him a question during a Republican debate. There is no surer way to get shot down as superficial, ill-informed and divisive than to pose a query to the former speaker of the House.

At the CNBC debate on the economy, Gingrich eyed Maria Bartiromo the way Franklin Roosevelt might have looked at Adm. Yamamoto had the Japanese commander been selected to moderate a foreign-policy debate shortly after Pearl Harbor. A lawyer argues the law when he doesn't have the facts on his side, and vice versa; Gingrich litigates the debate question even when he has a perfectly suitable answer.

His exchange with Bartiromo on health care was utterly characteristic. She asked all the candidates for a 30-second summary of how they would replace ObamaCare. A couple of them did, and when she got to Gingrich he objected to the "absurd question," complaining that no one could meaningfully discuss health care in 30 seconds. The two of them bickered unpleasantly about the appropriateness of the question for more than a minute — before Newt gave in and delivered a crisp response hitting on the highlights of his thoughts on health care.

The chattering class that left Gingrich for dead months ago is now talking of a revival. Although his poll numbers have ticked up, it's unclear whether Republican voters will cooperate with the new pundit narrative. But Gingrich deserves the proverbial second look. For all his vast and well-established flaws, he's a figure whose strengths match the moment.

The Republican Party has worked its way through about half a dozen outsider-populists in the past year, all of whom have proven either not particularly knowledgeable or careful about the issues, or uninterested in undergoing the rigors of running for president, or both. Sarah Palin, Donald Trump, Michele Bachmann and Rick Perry all rose and fell. Herman Cain is still ascendant, but even if he remains unharmed by sexual-harassment allegations, he will probably be worn down over time by his touch-and-go command of substance and his lack of experience.

It's counterintuitive to categorize a former speaker of the House and the builder of a sprawling archipelago of Beltway organizations as an outsider-populist. But Gingrich never lost his genius for the outre. In his bristling hostility to representatives of the media at the debates, he's trained his fire on the institution that unites all Republicans in their disdain. He can be as inflammatory as Donald Trump and as populist as Sarah Palin. Yet he brings to the table the wellsprings of knowledge of a history Ph.D. and an incorrigible — insufferable, perhaps — policy wonk.

No politician has spent so long saying we need such fundamental change. It is typical of Gingrich that his 21st-century Contract With America is conceived as "a larger and more complex developmental challenge than any presidential campaign has undertaken in modern times." Cue the eye-rolling. But the country now has such grave challenges even beyond the headline problems of joblessness and spiraling debt that there's a place for a candidate devoted to upending 20th-century structures in health care, education and more. Never have Gingrich's extravagant overstatements seemed so apt.

In many ways, Gingrich would be better-suited as an intellectual ombudsman of the GOP race than as a candidate himself; he has more baggage than Queen Elizabeth II on a road trip. But the hour is late and the pickings are slim. He ran when others didn't, and his outsider-populism is tinged with brilliance. Republican voters not sold on Mitt Romney might have to decide that you go to political war with the alternative you have.

Rich Lowry is a syndicated columnist. He can be reached via email at:

What do you think of this story?

Login to post comments

In order to make comments, you must create a subscription.

In order to comment on, you must hold a valid subscription allowing access to this website. You must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. To subscribe or link your existing subscription click here.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned from posting comments.



Garry Robitaille's picture


The only think that makes Newt Gingrich look intresting is the lack of a leader in that current pack dogs, I'm a card carrying republican and I'd vote Obamma again before any of them. Certianlly not becasue Obamma has done a good job or that I like him, becasue I don't. It just a sad state if the current feild is the best the GOP has to offer.

Anybody got a Good write in canidate?

Steve  Dosh's picture


Garry , 11.16.11 6 pm
Newt's in New Hamster [ sic. ] right now setting up shop
Q: N e one got a good write in candidate ?
A: Yes . Colin Powell ?
ßack in 1995 i met Colin in Africa whilst he was on his way to Nelson Mandela's inaguration . He was on Hillery's 7 0 7 . Someone asked him . " Hey Colin ? How come you don't run for President ? " At the time people did not even know if the former general was Republican or Democrat . [ SECCOMMERCE Ron Brown was still alive , too , and in the crowd ]
Colin's response , " I was going to run but my wife Alma told if i did run i'd probably be shot ."
Thankfully , our President has proved even that type of analysis wrong . h t h ? Dr. Dosh , Hawai'i •

PAUL ST JEAN's picture

It's hard for me to

It's hard for me to understand how you can claim to be a republican, but state that you would vote to re-elect oBAMa. Any republican, or democrat for that matter, with a pulse would make a better president than what we have right now.
If Gingrich were fortunate enough to be nominated as the republican candidate in 2K12,he would be the most qualified person to run for the presidency that we will have had in the last 20 years. Before all the linkbirds get all cranked up with requests for proof and documentation, let me state right now...It's an opinion.
I agree with you on the "sad state of affairs". Why make it worse by re-electing the Incompetent-In-Chief for another term?

Steve  Dosh's picture

Gingrich might be worth a second look

Rich ,
. .That two - timer ? Mr. Family Values ? Right ?  Go and divorce your perfectly good wifey and marry your secretary everyone . It reminds us of V P Nelson Rockfeller ref : and we all know how he died [ he suffered a heart attack whilst in bed with his personal secretary ] We'd probably be better off with that convicted felon Col. Ollie North , the greatest threat to the U S Consitution last century whilst running private armies out of the White House basement under Presidnet Reagan and Chief of Staff Regan's noses . Anyone still remember Contragate , the exchanging of arms for prisoners with Iran , of all places ?
Sarah Palin ? Michelle Bachman , anyone ?
True blue blooded , sentinent Republicans must be asking themselves how come q u a l i f i e d Republicans are not running for President . We speak to your Honorable Senator they'ya in Maine , Ms. Susan Collins , or , alternatively , the former Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff , four star general , and SECSTATE Colin Powell . Either individual would be a darn sight better than the current G O P field and they run the added advantage of being black or female
Now that would be a ticket
The thought of an other dumb former TX Governor or a wooden MA politician ( a lá Kerry , Dukakis , or Al Gore , D-TN ) as President simply turns our stomachs
Just my opinion , Rich . .. .:) /s, Steve Dosh , HI 11.13.11

PAUL ST JEAN's picture

And, Ted Kennedy, Bill

And, Ted Kennedy, Bill Clinton, Anthony Weiner....they're all clean, right?
Sure, Powell and Collins would be better than the current field; they're both RINOs.


Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...