Bigotry takes the form of a chunk of concrete

 

"Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere." — Martin Luther King, Jr.

Your blues, author BeBe Moore Campbell famously wrote, ain't like mine.

I've occasionally borrowed that phrase to explain how bigotry as experienced by majority and minority is not the same: the one has access to levers of power enabling it to express its hatred in public policy, the other has access only to fists and words. But there are times that observation is simultaneously true, and irrelevant. This is one of them.

There is, after all, a certain egalitarian outrageousness in what happened to 18-year-old Brian Milligan. Getting hit in the back of the head with a chunk of concrete is getting hit in the back of the head with a chunk of concrete, whether you are Jew or Muslim, gay or straight, black or white.

That's reportedly what happened to Milligan the night of Aug. 18, after he walked his girlfriend to her home in their gritty Buffalo, N.Y., neighborhood. Milligan had headphones on, so he didn't even hear it coming. A mob of 10 to 12 black males then stomped and kicked him and hit him with more concrete — all in the head and face, says his father, Brian Sr., 41.

As they struck him, they taunted him. "You white motherf---, we told you stay away from here. These are 'our' streets. We told you stay away from our women."

Brian, you see, is white. His girlfriend Nicola Fletcher, 18, is African-American. That difference in melanin has, they say, been a source of daily friction with a gang of black men in their neighborhood for months. She's been shot with paintballs, they've both been repeatedly cursed and taunted. "They would hit on her right in front of me," says Milligan. "They would call her baby and all that."

Now there's this. Brian Sr. says when he got to the hospital, he didn't even recognize his son. "I seen a mess. I seen somebody laying there dead."

Not quite, but close. Brian Jr. had a gash on his head that required seven staples to close. He had bleeding and swelling in his brain. His jaw and one tooth were broken. His sense of smell is gone. He has no memory of the beating.

According to media reports, blacks in the neighborhood have been conspicuous in their refusal to cooperate with investigators. While a black anti-crime group has been trying to help bring the criminals to justice, Brian Sr. says other blacks have chosen silence. "I don't know if it's that they're scared or they don't care. That's a coin I just don't want to toss up in the air."

Nor do I. So let me just say this: Assuming the facts are as we have been told, this demands prosecution as a hate crime. What happened to Brian Milligan is an offense against civil society. We should "all" be outraged.

I loathe bigotry in all its forms, but I have a special problem with bigotry as practiced by those who, by dint of their own history, should know better. When Jews hate Muslims for their religion, when gays scorn straights for their sexual orientation, when blacks beat a white teenager for the color of his skin, it suggests people too dense to understand the moral of their own story, the meaning of their own passages. The minority is no more righteous in its hate than the majority is.

Brian, Sr., an unemployed construction worker facing a mountain of medical bills, is asking for help. A special savings account has been set up for Brian at Bank of America.

And yes, Brian and Nicola are still together. He credits her with nudging him to get his GED. "She loves me. And I love her. That's more than anything. That sums it all up."

Somebody thought they had a right to tell this kid where he could go and who he could see. They kicked his head in because he is.

And that's a sadly familiar song. It is a blues we've heard too many times before.

Leonard Pitts Jr. is a columnist for The Miami Herald. His e-mail address is: lpitts@miamiherald.com. Leonard Pitts will be chatting with readers every Wednesday from 1 p.m. to 2 p.m. EDT on www.MiamiHerald.com.

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Displaying comments, from newest to oldest

tron's picture

Nope, I think pretty much

Nope, I think pretty much everyone recognizes this as racism, no need to expound on it. We only speak up when you and your friends do thing that you don't recognize as racism, so we point it out. We notice that you are ALWAYS able to point out black on white racism, yet NEVER seem able to point out the reverse. Any explanation as to why?

David Hughes's picture

If there is no need to

If there is no need to expand on this case, why is it that you, and many others, feel free to expand on cases just as obvious but with white racists and black victims? When was the last time you passed up a chance to speak, or type, on a case of obvious racism by a white person against a black person? When have I done anything that was racist Tron? That's what you accuse me of. When have I done that? Find an example, show it to me. Maybe there's a misunderstanding. Maybe it is an example of racism and I just don't see it. But Tron, if you can't provide a concrete example of me being racist, whether I recognized it at the time or not, you had better be issuing an apology.

Pointing out black on white racism isn't speaking to racism, it's speaking to the hypocrisy of those who would ignore it while those same people jump at the chance to call white's racist at any opportunity no matter how nuanced or obvious the racism is. Perhaps they ignore it out of fear for of damaging the cause of ending white on black racism. We cannot have equality unless all instances of racism are decried equally regardless of which direction the racism flows. That is the point of my original comment Tron.

You want to end racism in America for the benefit of all races then you have to treat every instance of racism the same way without regard to race of the perpetrator or the victim.

Seriously Tron, when was the last time you pointed out black on white racism that was as obvious as what occurred in the Prof. Gates situation? Or heck, Asian on Latino?

tron's picture

This is my very point, you

This is my very point, you actually believe the Gates issue was a black on white form of racism, when, in reality, it was the other way. This white cop wasn't gonna like this uppity (n*****) Havard professor talk to HIM like that. We're gonna show HIM!! But when people use white sheets, they rarely see reality.

Or this week when a bunch of WHITE parents, don't remember any black or Asian or Latino parents, not gonna let this BLACK President talk to their kid. What kinda nerve does this guy have?

So, you should now realize, while black on white racism is usually direct and inescapable, the other kind is very subtle and difficult for people like you to see. So we try to help. Your welcome.

David Hughes's picture

Tron, in every one of my

Tron, in every one of my responses I've been pretty clear that I'm wondering why it is people like you, who feel free to point out white on ( insert racial category that isn't white here ) racism don't point out racism that is ( insert racial category here ) on white racism. Can we at least agree on that? Because if we can agree on that your response makes no sense other than a display of your own prejudice.

Here's what I asked tron:
Seriously Tron, when was the last time you pointed out black on white racism that was as obvious as what occurred in the Prof. Gates situation? Or heck, Asian on Latino?

The question, alone and out of context, doesn't even offer a declaration of which way racism went in the Gates case. I'm asking you to point to any time where you pointed out black on white racism where the other kind of racism, the kind that's "subtle and difficult for people...to see", as you did in pointing out white on black racism in the Gates case. Is that clear enough for you?

I fail to see how you could have come to any other understanding of the question.

David Hughes's picture

I wonder where our resident

I wonder where our resident crowd of racist watchdogs are this morning on this story. I wonder which it is that they can't get their heads around...That blacks can be and are racists or, as our resident watchdogs continuously suggest, that only right wing whack jobs are racists and to cling to that belief that have to believe that these blacks are right wing whack jobs which just doens't make sense since, as our watch dogs continually tell us, only whites are right wing whack jobs with the rare token that proves that rule.

So watch dogs, just where are you to decry this blatant act of overt racism? Perhaps you are all too busy trying to read racism into some conservatives objection to whatever issue it is they object to?

Advertisement