Maine must expand access to dental care

The leading reason for uninsured or under insured young people to visit an emergency department is dental pain.

On Wednesday, March 7, the Maine State Chamber of Commerce will host a public panel presentation titled "The Economics of the Lack of Dental Care." The event begins at 10:30 a.m. and will be held at the Augusta Civic Center.

The presention, which is scheduled to last until noon, will focus on how the lack of access to dental care affects businesses and Maine's economy. There is no charge to attend.

To RSVP, contact Amy Downing at the Maine State Chamber of Commerce at adowning@mainechamber.org.

It’s a disturbing fact that ED doctors and hospital administrators have known for a long time. The Pew Center on the States studied the problem in-depth in a report released this week.

Unfortunately for dental patients who show up in our emergency rooms, hospitals are not staffed with dentists or oral surgeons. These patients are treated for pain and told to see a community dentist. But, with this state’s current dentist shortage and so many dentists not accepting MaineCare patients, these people — often in immense pain — struggle to find and pay for prompt care and often return to emergency departments for pain treatment.

It’s a costly and ineffective way to treat people, and does nothing to address prevention practices that could reduce the need for many of these emergency visits.

Just ask Deamonte Driver’s mother.

In 2007 in Maryland, Deamonte died when a tooth abscess became infected and bacteria spread to his brain.

He was 12 years old.

His mother didn’t have the money to pay for a dentist when Deamonte first told her about the toothache, and when the pain got worse she took the boy to an emergency room. Doctors treated the pain and told her to take her son to a dentist, but this low-income woman couldn’t find a dentist that would take Medicaid and, when Deamonte didn’t get better, she took him back to the hospital.

After eight weeks and two major surgeries, Deamonte died.

Marian Wright Edelman, president of the Children’s Defense Fund, blogged last year that “his life could have been saved by a routine dental visit and an $80 tooth extraction.”

The boy died because his family couldn’t pay for a dentist.

Shelly Gehshan, director of the Children’s Dental Campaign for the Pew Center on the States, has a solution: Expand the market by licensing more independent dental hygienists and public health hygienists, and expand the function of dental assistants so that patients — children in particular — have access to routine preventive care at an early age, learning to develop good dental hygiene habits as they age.

According to Pew, dental disease is the most common chronic disease among children in this country — five times more prevalent than asthma — so doesn’t it make sense to provide low-cost options?

The Maine Dental Association is not so sure, suggesting that Pew’s assertion that rural residents do not have adequate access to dental care is an illusion.

They do have access, although it may be miles away, and many of them are covered by MaineCare, MDA says.

According to John Bastey, director of governmental affairs for MDA, members also worry that expanding the market to additional classes of dental providers might be harmful because these providers do not have the same training as dentists and might not have the skills to treat patients in crisis.

Bastey acknowledges more dentists are needed, but points out that the number of new dentists licensed each year in Maine has climbed in the past 15 years.

According to the MDA, the average number of dentists licensed each year from 1997 to 2001 was 26.6; the average licensed from 2007 to 2012 was 43.6, with 59 licensed last year.

The University of New England will open its new College of Dental Medicine in 2013, and the hope is that graduates will establish practices in Maine.

That may increase the number of dentists over time, but it doesn’t solve the MaineCare reimbursement problem.

MaineCare provides dental coverage for all children under 18 years old, but not all of those children see dentists regularly. Some, not at all.

That’s because MaineCare’s reimbursement rate — 40 cents per dollar of office costs — doesn’t make financial sense for practitioners.

That may be so, but it makes less financial sense — from a taxpayer perspective — for dental patients to seek care in emergency rooms, spending excessive MaineCare dollars there instead of spending far fewer public dollars to pay for routine preventive visits in dental offices.

If there are not enough dentists accepting MaineCare patients, and independent dental providers are eager to take them, doesn’t it make sense to support that interest to improve dental health?

Deamonte Driver’s mother would say so.

jmeyer@sunjournal.com

The opinions expressed in this column reflect the views of the ownership and the editorial board.

What do you think of this story?

Login to post comments

In order to make comments, you must create a subscription.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must hold a valid subscription allowing access to this website. You must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your SunJournal.com profile. To subscribe or link your existing subscription click here.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned from posting comments.

Advertisement

Comments

Dave Wilson's picture

I have a bad toothache

I make $731/mo SS. I have medicare and the Quimby/Mainecare. All I want is my tooth pulled and am willing to pay for it, Can't get it done without a full examination and a much larger than necessary cost. I'm angry about it.

MARK GRAVE's picture

Unfortunately the x-ray is

Unfortunately the x-ray is necessary to ensure there is no infection taking up residence in your jaw.

MARK GRAVE's picture

I ignored a cavity for 1 year

I ignored a cavity for 1 year because I did not have the money. It cost me much more than an x-ray to stop the infection in the end. The infection started to enter my jaw bone. This is serious stuff.

Dave Wilson's picture

thank you

for the good advice. I'll try harder to find a way.

 's picture

You're correct ,Dave, instead

You're correct ,Dave, instead of paying fifty dollars to have your tooth pulled, you have to have an 'examination,' x-rays and end up paying over two hundred.

 's picture

Obviously the disagrees

Obviously the disagrees haven't been to a dentist for a while, or have insurance so they don't have to pay

Jennifer Chretien's picture

Dental care is expensive, I

Dental care is expensive, I haven't been to a dentist for a cleaning in 5 years because I simply can't afford it. In the last 6 months I have called the dentist I have seen in the past, the community dental office in my area, and the UNE dental hygiene clinic to see what it will cost to be seen. Since it has been so long a full set of x-rays is required, to be seen locally it will cost a minimum of around $125. I don't have $125 in my budget to buy groceries, and payment plans are not looked upon favorably, which I do completely understand. To go UNE will cost $50 including the x-rays, though I don't remember if you actually get seen by a dentist after the cleaning. This on the surface this cost less but I need to take a day off from work plus gas to drive to Portland and back, so it isn't necessarily less in the end. I'm not saying that I expect the tax payers to cover the costs, I would like to do it myself, unfortunately some of us simply don't have the means. I have Maine Care and yes it would initially pay for me to see my Dr or go to the ER if I had a problem. Personally I would like to avoid that and be able to afford to see my dentist for preventive care.

MARK GRAVE's picture

Jennifer, “…, and payment

Jennifer,

“…, and payment plans are not looked upon favorably”

Why can’t you set up a payment plan to yourself and then go see the Dentist when you have $125?

If you can afford a payment plan from the Dental office, you can certainly afford to budget a payment plan to yourself. Moreover, it would be a more efficient use of your money since you will not have to pay finance or service charges.

Jennifer Chretien's picture

That's a good idea, I have

That's a good idea, I have been able to do that for things that cost less. For some reason I hadn't thought of that for the dentist, I'm not sure why. Thanks

Steve Bulger's picture

UNE Dental School

I'd be curious to learn whether or not the University of New England's new Dental School will have a public clinic staffed by third-year dental students where could go for dental and oral health care at reduced-fee or no-fee services. In addition, does the American Dental Association promote a certain amount of pro bono work just as the American Bar Association does for its members?

PAUL ST JEAN's picture

So, if everyone has access to

So, if everyone has access to free dental care, it will be cheaper for the taxpayers than having the same people go to emergency rooms for treatment. Either way, the taxpayers are saddled with the burden of paying for it. There has to be a better way.

Advertisement

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...