Democrats accuse LePage administration of ‘breach of trust’ on DHHS errors

AUGUSTA, Maine — State Sen. Elizabeth Schneider on Wednesday accused the LePage administration of covering up financial problems at the Department of Health and Human Services and committing a “breach of trust” with lawmakers for not alerting them sooner.

Bangor Daily News

Elizabeth Schneider

Schneider’s words came during debate on the Senate floor over LD 1870, a minor supplemental budget bill not directly related to problems at DHHS.

But the Orono Democrat used her time to levy criticism at the department and its commissioner, Mary Mayhew, for providing bad information to the Appropriations Committee during recent budget negotiations.

“There is absolutely a cover-up that has occurred,” Schneider said. “I don’t see how going forward we can trust the information we’re being given, at least by the Department of Health and Human Services.

“We made decisions in the dark. I hope as a body that we will look into this.”

Sen. Roger Katz, R-Augusta, defended Mayhew on the Senate floor for her hard work and said lawmakers shouldn’t rush to judgment before all the facts are laid out.

Lawmakers spent several weeks in January and February poring through the details of a proposed $220 million budget by Gov. Paul LePage that attempted to address a shortfall in DHHS.

The initial budget proposal contained a number of cuts to MaineCare services, including the elimination of an estimated 65,000 people from eligibility.

The Appropriations Committee eventually rewrote the governor’s budget proposal and the House and Senate passed a bill last month that addressed the shortfall just for the remainder of fiscal year 2012.

Shortly after the 2012 supplemental budget passed, though, Mayhew informed lawmakers of a problem she said she knew about while the budget was being discussed.

A computer error within the MaineCare program had led the state to continue paying medical bills for some beneficiaries after they became ineligible for the program. DHHS is trying to attach a dollar figure to the bad payments made over the last year and a half, but it’s likely the state will have to repay the federal government. Two-thirds of MaineCare’s funding come from the feds.

Mayhew has told lawmakers she plans to get to the bottom of the computer glitch and is tentatively scheduled to appear before the Appropriations Committee on Friday to update its members.

On Wednesday, Mayhew took the high road in responding to the criticism.

“The challenges of multi-faceted data systems have long been associated with this Department and I am committed to working with the Legislature to resolve these issues,” she said in a statement. “I am aware of the critical need for systems that produce accurate and reliable data to guide decision-making.

“Our organization is large and our day-to-day world is complex. Potential problems arise with regularity and are resolved continuously. I plan to do this work in a way that continues to reflect a high level of professionalism, transparency, personal accountability, courtesy and respect.”

The Legislature still has to deal with an estimated $85 million to $90 million DHHS shortfall for 2013, and some lawmakers are wondering how that’s possible given the department’s recent track record.

With a statutory adjournment date of April 18 approaching, it’s likely the Legislature will adjourn next month but then reconvene later this spring to deal with the DHHS supplemental budget for 2013.

Sen. Joseph Brannigan, D-Portland, a longtime lawmaker, said he believes the Appropriations Committee was “badly informed” by the administration during the budget negotiations and said he’s never seen budgets done that way.

“I’ve complained from the beginning that this budget is being done in pieces. I can’t remember when we’ve ever done this in the past; can’t even keep track of how many pieces of the budget there are or that we’re being asked to vote for,” he said.

Even during the 115th Legislature, when state government shut down briefly because of a budget standoff between Democrats and Republicans, Brannigan said the budget that eventually passed was a whole budget.

“We didn’t do it in pieces,” he said. “We should see the whole picture.”

LePage, though, has been clear that he wants to deal with the DHHS shortfall separately, and he hasn’t been shy about criticizing Democrats over their role in the process. Earlier this year, the governor accused Democrats of stalling and obstructing.

In light of the DHHS problems, Democrats now are saying they were right to put the brakes on the governor’s budget.

What do you think of this story?

Login to post comments

In order to make comments, you must create a subscription.

In order to comment on, you must hold a valid subscription allowing access to this website. You must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. To subscribe or link your existing subscription click here.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned from posting comments.



Jeff Johnson's picture

Why do I feel that if this

Why do I feel that if this were the budget of a private company, the issue would have been discovered, addressed, and solved before umpteen million dollars was lost?

Our government systems are inefficient, and we need more "Real World" businessmen to run them. Not career politicians that have never held a real job.

Pat Morin's picture

Dhhs budget cuts

Amazing how SHE know about these 19000 and hide it and then had the NERVE to stand by this man to cut monies to people and programs that really need that money or assistance. It totally befuddles me to think how our state is being lead array and their excuses around every block. Me thinks the administration knew and used other means to try and cut monies. Now that it has come to light, they walk away and wont let it be audited. SHAME ON THIS ADMINISTRATION AND HIS LACKEYS! !

JOHN PAINTER's picture

It is unfortunate for all

It is unfortunate for all Mainers that there is such political rancor related to MaineCare, we have very real challenges looming none the least of which are clear time sensitive mandates from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid (CMS) of what Maine must do to address a number of serious problems we have or face federal intervention which could include more in-depth audit of our system (usually at the states expense), withholding of payments, clawback of payments for services not allowed, etc.

While Maine clearly needs to address a potential error of paying for some 19,000 MaineCare beneficiaries who lost eligibility. Our system needs to strive for no errors, the issue as the Commissioner points out, is complicated because over the decades Maine never merged or created a clear process for eligibility and payment systems or personnel to communicate. Along with that, an error rate of around 6% in Medicaid programs is within the 3 year rolling rate PERM (payment error rate measure) which CMS evaluates states with. In other words, while 19,000 eligibility errors is not good, it is within the average of errors which happen in all states Mediciad programs.

If the Legislature is not aware of these historical issues with our MaineCare system, that would certainly be a problem. I don't think that is the case, how the issues as characterized by Senator Schneider comes across, is just plain unhelpful politicking.

What continues to remain unaddressed by either the Administration or Legislature is the Damocles Sword of the directive by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid (one directive from 2008, and another from this past December 23) to correct our states billing practices regarding bundled rates, billing which did not get submitted before the end of the year which qualified for ARA "enhanced FMAP" (Maine will not be able to draw down that enhanced rate) and the issue of paying back Medicaid at the "enhanced FMAP" for errors submitted over the past several years.

These are not partisan problems, these are Maine problems, we need our elected officials to understand with guidance from DHHS, and thoughtfully and timely address to help assure future (hopefully effective and efficient) functioning of our states social service systems, there are too many frail elderly ads seriously disabled citizens to let these issues to become political fodder and go unaddressed.


I don't feel that the issue

I don't feel that the issue is the problem with the computer system. There are glitches in everything within all departments. I feel the issue is that the legislature was asked to make uninformed decisions. The commissioner knew there was a problem in January and yet did not come forward with that information until after the legislature voted to cut 19,000 people. This is from an administration that consistently says they want transparency in all areas. Well you can't have transparency until you have trust and honesty and hiding things goes a long way towards building even more distrust.


Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...