Jennifer is fresh out of high school and itching to backpack across Europe.
Amanda is a 30-year-old with cystic fibrosis who needs a double lung transplant.
John wants to have his book made into a movie.
Victims of fire, grieving widows, Little League teams headed for championships. Lots of people need to raise funds fast these days and lots of people are turning to the web to do it, hoping crowdfunding will answer their prayers. But even the most charitable among us can’t give to everyone, so who gets the money?
As it turns out, it often comes down to who presents the best case, not who has the greatest need. When you play the crowdfunding game, you better go in with a plan.
“Everybody and their brother seem to have their hands out with the GoFundMe and the Indiegogo,” says local author John Brubaker, referring to two of the most popular crowdfunding websites dedicated to such fundraising. “A ridiculously high number of them fail.”
Roughly 60 percent of crowdfunded appeals will fail to meet their goals, according the experts. That includes people who need money for legitimate things, like expensive medical procedures or a life disrupted by fire.
Meanwhile, less substantial crowdfunding projects can hit it out of the ballpark – like the Ohio man who set off to raise $10 to make a potato salad and ended up raising $55,000.
“He was basically making a mockery of it,” Brubaker says. “It ended up going viral. He ended up on the ‘Today Show’, ‘Good Morning America’.”
Wait, why are we letting this Brubaker character run off at the mouth?
Oh, right. Because this Lewiston author managed to raise more than $33,000 in 30 days for his effort to adapt his book “Seeds of Success” to film. Brubaker’s Kickstarter campaign was such a smashing success, now authors and others in need of money are taking a close look at his winning formula.
Was it simple luck that made Brubaker’s project such a success? Was it just a matter of fluke timing, or of being in the right place at the right time?
“I don’t think there’s any luck involved at all,” Brubaker said.
No, Brubaker succeeded, according to those who make a career out of fundraising, because he came in with a plan. He did his homework, he surrounded himself with talented people and he poured his own hard-earned dough into the project – between 10 and 20 percent of his goal – long before asking anyone else to do so.
That and he worked his derriere off.
“You’ve got to do your homework and your research,” Brubaker says. “You have to treat a crowdfunding campaign like it’s a full-time job, because it really is.”
4 out of 100 donate
In his Kickstarter campaign, Brubaker surpassed his goal of $30,000 in less than a month, ending up with $33,517 in contributions. With that achieved, the process is now underway to transform “Seeds of Success” into a film.
The fictional story of a man on a quest to become a better coach, teacher and person, the manuscript is now in the hands of a Hollywood script writer who will begin to prepare it for the big screen, while the rest of the team gets about securing corporate sponsorships for the film.
With all that going on, there are those who consider Brubaker a fundraising guru. Brubaker somewhat disagrees: If there is such a thing as a crowdfunding guru, he says, it is Jodie Bentley, an actress, producer and marketing coach now based in Los Angeles.
Bentley literally wrote the book on crowdfunding. For those hoping that simple luck or the kindness of the universe will carry them through a funding campaign, Bentley’s view is as grim as Brubaker’s.
“There’s a lot of work that goes in at the beginning. A lot of people don’t do that,” she says. “Only about 4 percent of the people you ask are actually going to donate.”
Four percent. That’s four out of every 100 people you ask. Whether it’s for your ski trip to Switzerland or a heart transplant. The rest will either promise money that is never produced or they’ll just laugh in your face.
How to overcome these staggering odds? Both of these gurus agree the first step involves surrounding yourself with people who are smarter than you.
“What we learned, and what most people don’t do in fundraising, is you must build a team,” Bentley says. “Crowdfunding is not a go-it-alone business.”
Brubaker did just that, researching other campaigns, hiring pros to help him get the message out there the way he wanted, and bringing aboard talent by offering incentives. (See related story on Brubaker’s team-building success.)
The campaign itself is critical, and experts say it must start big — you should shoot for raising 25 percent of your goal in the first 36 hours.
Brubaker and his team went so far as to host launch parties, first in Portland, then in New York and Philadelphia.
“I think that’s what got us over that hump initially,” Brubaker says. “Taking our show on the road, getting people excited and kind of beating our own drum. You can’t do it all online. There’s a lot of skepticism on the Internet. People want to see the whites of your eyes. They want to know that their money is going to be put to good use. You can’t underestimate the importance of face-to-face.” (See related story on Brubaker’s fast start.)
From tango lessons to a sick child
Technically, crowdfunding has been around for hundreds of years. It’s just never been so easy, to the point where pretty much anybody can create an appeal in a matter of minutes with a computer or smartphone.
Modern crowdfunding goes back to the early 2000s, with more and more online platforms being created as the first decade ended. While entrepreneurs, companies and large groups were often the most frequent participants, more and more individuals have gotten onboard. The causes are infinite.
Complete strangers have been known to raise a defense fund for cops involved in shootings. Others have tried to raise money in support of a guy in Kentucky who shot down a drone he caught spying on his daughter. (GoFundMe, for reasons that aren’t clear, would not allow campaigns to be launched in defense of the drone shooter, according to Brubaker. He knows this from personal experience: He tried to start one.)
Regardless of experts’ advice on the best ways to mount a crowdfunding campaign, thousands of new campaigns pop up all the time on sites like Kickstarter, GoFundMe and Indiegogo. (There are costs associated with crowdfunding websites, which often take a percentage of the money raised. Check each website for details. See related info box.)
Here’s a fast look at what’s out there just locally on GoFundMe:
* A Lewiston man trying to raise money for his soldier son, who became partially disabled while serving in Iraq. The goal was $10,000 to help the soldier’s family. In four days, more than $2,000 had been donated.
* A Sabattus man trying to raise $10,000 to bury his father. After four days, $1,875 was given.
* A Hebron woman trying to raise $20,000 for a sick child. After six days, the campaign had nearly reached its goal – $19,965 had been donated.
* In Lewiston, a co-ed softball team trying to muster $6,500 to travel to a tournament in Orlando. After a month, $1,470 had been raised.
* A Portland-based progressive rock band trying to raise $5,000 to go on tour. After a week, they were about halfway there.
* A Windham man trying to raise $600 for tango lessons. In one month, donors had contributed $500.
The frivolity of some campaigns understandably bothers those who have serious financial needs.
“If they just want a trip to wherever, I see that as BS,” said a Lewiston woman named Paulette who responded to a crowdfunding query. “It kills me that people are out there raising money for trips and for fun things. Put some money aside and save up for it yourself.”
As it turns out, Paulette has a brother with cancer and a sister-in-law tagged with some hefty medical bills.
“She just has no idea how she’s going to pay any of these bills,” Paulette says. “It’s well over $100,000. She’s going to have to use all the money she has. I wish to God I had the money to help her. Unfortunately, my husband and I are living on Social Security. We don’t have the money, either.”
Focus, focus, focus
Brubaker sympathizes with those who feel compelled to rush things. But his prognosis for hastily prepared or frivolous campaigns – the potato salad campaign experience being the exception – is not good at all.
The differences between the big and flashy campaigns, like Brubaker’s, and the more down-to-earth efforts are obvious. If you’re working on an artistic endeavor, there is time to plan, to gather a team and to get all the details just right. If you suddenly need money because your house burned down or your son was hurt in a car wreck, circumstances won’t likely allow for that level of effort. So, what can be done if you have to — or just want to — slap a campaign together in haste?
Brubaker’s advice: Don’t do it. A thrown-together campaign will look shoddy, and to many people that will raise questions about its legitimacy, he said.
That said, clearly, based on just the GoFundMe activity locally, people are donating to campaigns that run the gamut of need and production quality.
“If you absolutely have to slap it together,” Brubaker continues, “I think you focus on that one person. You tell the story.”
Remember that powerful SPCA commercial that so troubled you? It featured singer Sarah McLachlan posing with abused dogs and cats while sad music played in the background. As Brubaker points out, the commercial never shows groups of dogs or packs of cats. It focuses on a single animal at a time, and there’s a reason for that. Show an average person a big group of suffering animals – or suffering kids, for that matter – and that person will be overwhelmed: There’s just no way he or she can help all of them.
“I can’t help a thousand dogs at the shelter,” Brubaker says. “I’m only one person.”
Show them one emaciated dog or one malnourished cat, however, and the effect on human empathy is powerful. It’s just one, after all. Maybe you really CAN make a difference with a donation. And the same applies to a simple crowdfunding campaign, Brubaker says.
If you need to raise money to help your ailing gramma, make your campaign all about her. Focus on her life, her woes and her needs. If a stranger on the web feels like his donation might help, he’s more likely to drag out his checkbook or reach for the phone.
It also helps, Brubaker says, to choose your platform wisely. Kickstarter is often used for long-range projects like his book-to-film endeavor. Indiegogo seems geared toward musicians and other independent artists. And GoFundMe commonly serves as a repository for emergencies and tragedies that befall us, with a few Little League teams in need of walking-around money thrown into the mix. If your favorite aunt needs a few thousand dollars for a prosthetic leg, in other words, you’ll likely have more luck on GoFundMe than Indiegogo.
Crowdfunding phrases to avoid like the plague
* “Give just a little.”
* “Check on the link.”
* “Click on our project and look it over.”
* “Every little bit helps.”
* “Even small amounts make a difference.”
* “Can you do $5?”
Source: Jodie Bentley’s “Secrets of the Crowdfunding Game”
The cost of fundraising
There are costs associated with crowdfunding in addition to whatever is spent putting your campaign together. Many crowdfunding websites charge a percentage of what is raised, and also charge fees for donations made by credit card, Paypal, etc.
Here are the fee statements made by three of the more popular crowdfunding websites. Look at each website for full details.
Kickstarter: If your project is successfully funded, the following fees will be collected from your funding total: Kickstarter’s 5% fee, and payment processing fees (between 3% and 5%). If funding isn’t successful, there are no fees. Source: Kickstarter.com
GoFundMe: While it’s free to create and share your online fundraising campaign, GoFundMe will deduct a 5% fee from each donation that you receive. Since our fee is deducted automatically, you’ll never need to worry about being billed or owing us any money. Source: GoFundMe.com
IndieGoGo: It is free to sign up, to create a campaign and to contribute to a campaign. When your campaign raises funds, Indiegogo charges a 5% fee on the funds you raise. Source: support.indiegogo.com
How Brubaker built a winning team
John Brubaker built his team carefully. He hired Colby Michaud, owner of Praxis Production Studios in Lewiston, to create a video for the campaign. He hired someone to craft a messaging game plan, and someone else to design a landing page.
He researched other campaigns – 10 that had succeeded and 10 that had failed. He mobilized his base: friends, readers, colleagues . . . not to mention people like California-based marketing expert Jodie Bentley, who already had experience in running successful campaigns.
“You’re tapping into the minds of experts who have been there, done that,” Brubaker says, “who have already gone where you’re going.”
He drew people into his project, not by appealing to their generosity, but by offering incentives.
“Offer them an opportunity to get on board in a way that would be fun for them,” Brubaker says. “Maybe they can be in the film. Who wouldn’t want to do that?”
It’s a method the experts consider crucial to the process. Whether you’re asking someone to help with your campaign or outright begging them for money, it’s important to remember the question that rules just about everything: What’s in it for me?
“How am I going to get people who want to work on my project?” says Bentley. “Well, you have to find a win-win. There’s got to be a win in it for everybody.”
How Brubaker started big and fast
Crowdfunding experts like Jodie Bentley and John Brubaker say a good campaign takes several months to prepare before launch. Everything and everyone has to be in place. Why?
Because once a campaign starts, it has to start big: The experts say you should shoot for raising 25 percent of your goal in the first 36 hours.
“The whole thing is built on momentum,” says Brubaker. “What that does is, it’s kind of like you become a trending news item, like you would on Twitter or Google. You become trending on Kickstarter and you make it onto the home page. We were the hottest trending film project on Kickstarter when our campaign started, just because we mobilized our base. We gave them that ‘What’s in it for me:’ We gave people a good reason to get on board.”
Brubaker continues: “But we also explained to them that we needed their help right away, not a week for now. We want to be trending. What that does, when you’re trending, random people that you don’t know are going to see your project. If it looks compelling and there’s quality video, they’re going to click on it. Get them to click on your video and that should give them a reason to want to get on board.
“If you have momentum,” Brubaker says, “anything can happen.”
His project reached its 25 percent mark within 36 hours and it just grew from there. Complete strangers came to his Kickstarter page, liked what they saw and donated, including one man who was compelled to contribute a sizable chunk because of the faith-based nature of Brubaker’s work.
“He felt like he was called upon by God to contribute,” Brubaker says, “and he contributed a large amount of money.”