Richard Rodrigue, right, embraces his daughter Stephanie, 17, after she walked the runway in her high school’s pre-prom fashion show in Lewiston on Thursday, March 16, 2017. Rodrigue is proud his daughter is part of a diverse school whose students speak dozens of languages, and hail from dozens of nations. Though he is conflicted; “There’s got to be a point in time when you have to say, ‘whoa, let’s get the working people back up, let’s bring the money in.’ But they keep coming, keep coming,” Rodrigue said. “I guess it just boils down to: What’s enough? Is that wrong? Am I wrong? Am I bad? That’s how I feel.” Rick Rodrigue, left, stands with his daughter Stephanie, 17, at their home in Lewiston on Thursday, March 16, 2017. His daughter attends Lewiston High School where students speak dozens of languages, and hail from dozens of nations: Somalia, Djibouti, Congo, Yemen. “It will help her in life,” Rodrigue says. “The world is not all white.” Yet in November 2016, Rodrigue voted for Donald Trump. Rodrigue’s reasoning: America is struggling, and America needs to take care of its own before it takes care of anyone else. Trump supporter Stephanie Rodrigue, 17, picks up one of the campaign signs she’s collected in her room in Lewiston on Thursday, March 16, 2017. Although too young to vote, Rodrigue supported Trump, so much she bellowed his name at pep rallies, affixed a campaign sticker to her laptop and came to be called by her classmates “the mini-Trump.”
LEWISTON — Richard Rodrigue stood in the back of a banquet hall, watching his blond-haired, blue-eyed daughter mingle among her high school classmates. These teenagers speak dozens of languages, and hail from a dozen African nations.
They fled brutal civil war, famine, oppressive regimes to find themselves here, at an ordinary high school pre-prom fete in this once-dying New England mill town, revived by an influx of some 7,500 immigrants over the last 16 years. Rodrigue smiled and waved at his daughter, proud she is a part of it: “It will help her in life,” he said. “The world is not all white.”
Rodrigue believes the refugees resuscitated his town — plugging the population drain that had threatened to cripple it, opening shops and restaurants in boarded-up storefronts. But he also agrees with Donald Trump that there should be no more of them, at least not now. America is struggling, he says, and needs to take care of its own before it takes care of anyone else.
His working-class community, built along the banks of the Androscoggin River in the whitest state in America, is a place that some point to as proof that refugee integration can work. And yet for the first time in 30 years, voters in Androscoggin County chose a Republican for president, endorsing Trump’s nativist zeal against the very sort of immigrants who share their streets and their schools.
Rodrigue knows he was born on the winning end of the American dream. His grandfather fled poverty in Quebec and moved to Maine to toil his whole life in the textile mills. He never learned English, faced hate and discrimination. Two generations later, Rodrigue owns a successful security company, lives in a tidy house in a quiet neighborhood and makes plans to send his daughter to college.
Immigration worked for him. But it feels different today, as the county of 107,000 people tries to find its footing. The sprawling brick mills that line the river sit mostly shuttered. A quarter of children grow up poor. Taxpayers pick up the welfare tab. So Trump’s supporters here tie their embrace of his immigration clampdown to their economic anxieties, and their belief that the newcomers are taking more than they have earned.
“There’s got to be a point in time when you have to say, ‘Whoa, let’s get the working people back up. Let’s bring the money in. But they keep coming, keep coming,” Rodrigue said.
His community has been an experiment in immigration and all that comes with it — friendships, fear, triumphs, setbacks — and he knows that Trump’s presidency marks another chapter in that struggle for the American soul.
“I guess it just boils down to: What’s enough? Is that wrong? Am I wrong? Am I bad? That’s how I feel.”
Ardo Mohamed, of Somalia, places a freshly-cooked Sambusa in a display case in her store in Lewiston on Friday, March 17, 2017. Mohamed came to Lewiston in 2001, among the first immigrant families. She fled Mogadishu in the 1990s, when militiamen burst into the home she shared with her parents and nine siblings, and started shooting. She watched her father die, as the rest of the family ran into the woods to escape. They wound up in overcrowded refugee camps, separated for years, then Atlanta, then Lewiston. “We went from a big city to a small city, for our children to have a nice life,” she said. “We wanted to be safe, just like you do.” A woman carries goods on her back after shopping at one of the many stores downtown owned by African refugees who have settled in Lewiston on Wednesday, March 15, 2017. Maine offers a welfare program called General Assistance, which provides impoverished people with vouchers for rent, utilities and food. The amount refugees has bounced up and down over the years, but it accounts for less than 1 percent of the budget, said deputy city administrator Phil Nadeau. (AP Photo/David Goldman)Victoria Schalk, 22, left, and Melinda Blais, 27, right, share a traditional Somali meal with college classmate Nasteho Issa, 21, at restaurant and market opened by one of the first Somali families who settled in 2001 in Lewiston on Wednesday, March 15, 2017. The population had plummeted in 2001 as the paper mills closed. Downtown storefronts sat boarded up, ringed by sagging apartment buildings no longer needed to house workers since so few remained. The refugees saw possibility in Lewiston’s decay. Word spread quickly and friends and families followed, by the hundreds. The town morphed in a matter of months into a laboratory for what happens when demographics and culture suddenly shift. U.S. flags hang outside a downtown building whose storefronts are made up of businesses started by African immigrants who have settled in Lewiston on Friday, March 17, 2017. Maine’s immigrants from Sub-Saharan Africa made $136.6 million in income in 2014, and paid $40 million in taxes, according to a report from the New American Economy, a bi-partisan coalition pushing for immigration reform. Women wearing traditional muslim head coverings walk past one of the many stores downtown owned by African refugees who have settled in Lewiston on Friday, March 17, 2017. The refugees saw possibility in Lewiston’s decay. Word spread quickly and friends and families followed, by the hundreds. The town morphed in a matter of months into a laboratory for what happens when demographics and culture suddenly shift.A woman wearing a khimar leaves after shopping at one of the many stores owned by Somali immigrants who have settled in Lewiston, Maine, Friday, March 17, 2017. In August 2016, candidate Donald Trump stood on a stage in Portland and singled out the Somali community as criminal. The police chief quickly refuted the charge as false, since crime has decreased in Lewiston after the refugees arrived, but it continues to linger in the minds of many. (AP Photo/David Goldman)
No one invited the Somali refugees to Lewiston.
They fled bullets and warlords to eventually be chosen for resettlement in big American cities, where they were unnerved by the crime and drugs and noise.
In early 2001, a few refugee families struggling to afford housing in Portland ventured 30 miles north and found a city in retreat. Empty downtown stores were ringed by sagging apartment buildings no longer needed to house workers because so few workers remained.
The refugees saw possibility in Lewiston’s decay. Word spread quickly, and friends and families followed. The town morphed in a matter of months into a laboratory for what happens when culture suddenly shifts. Maine’s population is 95 percent white, and its citizens were abruptly confronted with hundreds of black Muslims, traumatized by war and barely able to speak English.
Ardo Mohamed came to Lewiston in 2001. She fled Mogadishu in the 1990s, when militiamen burst into the home she shared with her parents and nine siblings, and started shooting. She watched her father die, as the rest of the family escaped into the woods. They wound up in overcrowded refugee camps, separated for years, then finally Atlanta, then Lewiston. Now she fries sambusas with her sister at a shop she owns downtown.
“We wanted to be safe,” said the mother of five, “just like you do.”
When the refugees began arriving, Tabitha Beauchesne was a student at Lewiston High School. Her new classmates were poor, but Beauchesne was poor, too. She grew up in a struggling family in housing projects downtown. It felt to her then, and it still feels to her now, that the refugees got more help than her family.
“They just seemed to take over,” she said. She doesn’t consider herself racist, though acknowledges that race and religion likely play a role in her sense that the refugees overwhelmed her community. The African Muslims, many of whom wear hijabs, stand out far more than her French-Canadian ancestors did when they arrived generations ago, she said.
That perception — one of being inundated by a culture so different from her own — ingrained in her a sense of injustice so deep it persists to this day. She’s now a stay-at-home mother of two, and she left Lewiston to move to another school district in the county because she believes the refugee students monopolize teachers’ attention.
Once a Barack Obama supporter, Beauchesne turned to Trump — and she cheers his efforts to curb the flow of refugees into the United States. She wants Trump to design a tax system that funnels less of her money to aiding those from other countries.
“I just don’t like giving money away that’s not benefiting me and, not to sound selfish, but then seeing it benefit other people,” she said. “As a business owner, my husband wouldn’t donate $500 to the Salvation Army if we couldn’t afford it. Our country needs to do the same thing.”
Taxpayers do help refugee families. Maine offers a welfare program called General Assistance, a combination of state and city funds, which provides impoverished people with vouchers for rent, utilities and food.
In 2002, at the beginning of the immigrant influx, the city handed out about $343,000 in General Assistance funds, split almost evenly between native-born Mainers and refugees, according to city records. But rumors, largely unfounded, spread that the refugees were given free cars and apartments. Locals began calling City Hall to demand answers.
Then-Mayor Laurier T. Raymond Jr. penned an open letter to the Somali community, asking that they divert friends and family away from a city he described as “maxed-out financially, physically and emotionally.”
The letter plunged Lewiston overnight into the global political cauldron. A white-supremacist group from out of state planned a rally against the Somali “invasion.” Just a few people showed up. But across town 4,000 gathered in a gymnasium to support the Somalis and try to combat the reputation of Lewiston as a racist, xenophobic city that was rocketing around the world.
And in that moment, the tide seemed to turn, deputy city administrator Phil Nadeau said. Even more immigrants came. Somali refugees gave way to those seeking asylum, from Angola, Burundi, Rwanda, a dozen nations in all. The immigrant population exploded from a handful of families to more than 7,000 people today, according to a tally by the Immigrant Resource Center of Maine. But the anxieties of old rarely seemed to resurface.
Two years ago, immigrant children led the high school soccer team to win the state championship — a moment heralded as a triumph of cultural cooperation. Outside news crews still come from time to time, Nadeau said, and “they’re always amazed that there’s nothing bad to print.”
But around the edges of the city, in the suburbs and small towns that fill out the rest of Androscoggin County, many quietly stewed. It’s there that Trump’s “America First” message took root.
David Lovewell, 59, compares the emptiness of the parking lot at the paper mill compared to when he worked there a few years earlier in Jay on Friday, March 17, 2017. “Look at this parking lot. It’s just amazing. At this time of day this parking lot was absolutely full: that’s people, that’s jobs, that’s families,” said Lovewell who voted for Trump.David Lovewell, 59, walks through the land he’s logging with his sons in Farmington on Friday, March 17, 2017. Lovewell sees a dim future for them here. A few months earlier, business got so bad he came close to losing it all, and it reminded him just how fragile the blue collar economy can be. He looked down at his sneakers, which he bought for $25 at Walmart. There used to be a shoe factory in town, he said, and another one just down the road. “They’re gone, they’re done,” he said. “And now I’m wearing shoes from China.” That’s why he voted for Donald Trump, because he doesn’t want to have to buy shoes made someplace else.
Thirty miles up the highway, Joyce Badeau greets customers by name at the hardware store where she works. She lives just outside Livermore Falls, population 3,187 — 3,064 of whom are white. She has little occasion to interact with immigrants, but her political views have been shaped by the idea of them.
Badeau voted for Obama but backs Trump now, and points to his promise to rein in immigration as one reason why.
“We’re becoming a poor country because we’re overloaded,” she said. “We can’t fix the system so long as we keep adding more broken pieces.”
She has watched the paper mills close and her neighbors lose good-paying jobs. But Badeau isn’t naive; she doesn’t believe Trump can make the mills roar back to life. That was a bygone era, replaced by email and iPhones. And his arrogance grates on her. But she hopes one day to turn on the news and not hear about crime and homelessness and terrorism — and she worries that someone who wants to hurt Americans might slip through porous borders. Trump promised to fix it all. If he can’t, she’s not sure what more America can offer immigrants.
“Because they’re leaving one country of problems and coming into another country of problems,” she said.
David Lovewell used to work at a paper mill just outside of Livermore Falls that has shed hundreds of jobs. Now he runs a logging company with his sons, but he sees a dim future for them. A few months ago, business got so bad he laid off eight employees and fell behind on his $5,500 monthly payments on the machines he uses to cut down trees.
He looked down at his sneakers, bought for $25 at Walmart. There used to be two shoe factories nearby. He wants Trump to stop his town’s slow slip toward irrelevancy.
Lovewell doesn’t like to talk about immigration. He sighs and rubs his head, afraid to seem indifferent to pain and poverty around the world. He went on a cruise to Belize with his wife several years ago, when he still worked at the mill and could afford a vacation. He stopped to buy a carving from an old man whose hands were so worn from years of whittling they looked like leather. He remembers those hands still, and the man’s dirt-floor shack with no doors and his skinny, starving dog and the kids riding around on broken bicycles.
“I struggled with it, when he did the travel ban,” Lovewell said of Trump. “At the same time, I’m seeing … people losing their jobs. Why are we so worried about immigrants coming into our country when we can’t really take care of our own people?”
So he’s looking to Trump to strike a better balance — to build an economy where his sons don’t have to battle to barely get by, and only after that design an immigration system that keeps America’s promise of open arms.
“I guess it could sound like bigotry,” he said. “But we’re hurting. Americans are hurting.”
Lewiston High School students Essa Gedi, left, and Khafiya Dualeh walk the runway for the school’s pre-prom fashion show at the Franco American Heritage Center in Lewiston on Thursday, March 16, 2017. Fifteen years ago, the school district had an enrollment of 4,500 students and falling _ a sign of a city on its knees, says Lewiston School Superintendent Bill Webster. Today, there are 5,400 students, more than one-quarter of them immigrants, and the number is going up.Lewiston high school seniors and co-captains of the soccer team, Joseph Kalilwa, 18, right, and Abdiaziz Shaleh, 19, play in Kaliwa’s room at his home in Lewiston on Tuesday, March 14, 2017. “I mean that kind of bothers me sometimes like when people you go everywhere they just see you as a refugee,” said Kalilwa who was born in the Democratic Republic of Congo and is now an American citizen. “I’m like oh well, yeah, I am a refugee but then at the same time I see myself as an American.”Abdiaziz Shaleh, 19, a Lewiston high school senior and co-captain of the soccer team walks through a snow storm while leaving a friend’s house in Lewiston on Tuesday, March 14, 2017. Shaleh, whose family is from Somalia, waited with them for several years in a refugee camp in Kenya before coming to the United States and eventually settling in Lewiston. Shaleh said President Donald Trump’s election has created fear in the refugee community, including among the many students who come from immigrant families. Shaleh also worries about the many refugees who are suffering in Somalia and other parts of Africa, where famine remains a huge issue. “We got that chance (to come to America),” he said. “I just wanted them to have the same chance.” A mural celebrating diversity decorates a hallway in Lewiston High School in Lewiston on Wednesday, March 15, 2017. Fifteen years ago, the school district had an enrollment of 4,500 students and falling _ a sign of a city on its knees, says Lewiston School Superintendent Bill Webster. Today, there are 5,400 students, more than one-quarter of them immigrants, and the number is going up. Abdiaziz Shaleh, 19, a senior and co-captain of the soccer team, grabs a textbook off the shelf during his American government class at Lewiston High School in Lewiston on Wednesday, March 15, 2017. Shaleh, whose family is from Somalia, is graduating from high school soon and plans to go to prep school in Massachusetts to play soccer and to prepare for college. “I want to become something,” he said, listing engineer, entrepreneur or a doctor as possibilities. “Anything that could be useful.” Abdiaziz Shaleh, right, a Lewiston high school senior and co-captain of the soccer team, and Essa Gedi, center, both whose families emigrated from Somalia, sit with classmate Isiah Leach, left, during lunch in the school’s cafeteria in Lewiston on Wednesday, March 15, 2017. Two years ago, immigrant children led the high school soccer team to win the state championship, a moment heralded as a triumph for the city’s embrace of its immigrant community.
Politicians have seized on the discontent.
Last August, candidate Trump stood on a stage in Portland and singled out the Somali community as causing a crime wave. The Lewiston police chief quickly refuted the charge — crime has decreased dramatically since the refugees arrived — but it stuck in the minds of many.
Maine’s Republican governor, Paul LePage, has called immigrants “the biggest problem in our state,” and suggested they bring danger and disease.
And in Androscoggin County, Republican leaders hammer the issue of refugee resettlement on their Facebook page, with post after post about the injustice they see in taxpayers helping them with assistance. They’ve dubbed it “the refugee racket,” and complain that the school system is forced to accommodate 34 languages.
Lewiston School Superintendent Bill Webster acknowledges that does cost money. But he has a statistic he likes to share with the critics.
Historically, Lewiston has had some of the lowest high school graduation rates in the state. Now, immigrant children are doing better than native-born kids. Some were illiterate in their native language when they set out to learn English. Yet an average of 78.3 percent of immigrant students graduate high school within five years, compared to an average of 73.3 percent of native students.
Fifteen years ago, the school district had an enrollment of 4,500 students and falling — a sign of a city on its knees, Webster said. Today, there are 5,400 students, more than one-quarter of them immigrants, and the number is going up. And now the immigrant children who grew up here are going off to college to get degrees, as teachers, doctors, engineers.
Several years ago, Webster and his wife sold their home in the suburbs and rented an apartment in downtown Lewiston, across the street from a mosque. They can stroll to dinner, past a yoga studio and a shop that sells artisan olive oil. There are also dozens of immigrant-owned businesses, like the Mogadishu Business Center — with two flags hanging in the window, one American and one Somali. Remaining vacant storefronts have signs in the windows, promising prospective buyers an opportunity to “be part of Lewiston’s great rebirth.”
“We never have the opportunity to redo time under a different set of assumptions,” Webster said. “But if the immigrant population hadn’t happened, Lewiston would be a community that was contracting, and potentially in a downward death spiral.”
Organizations that work with immigrants nevertheless must fight on to combat deep-seated distrust. Catholic Charities publishes a fact sheet called “The Top Ten Myths about Somalis and Why They Are Wrong.” It lists untruths like, “Somalis are draining the welfare coffers,” ”Somalis get free apartments,” even “Somalis keep live chickens in their kitchen cupboards.”
Maine’s immigrants from Sub-Saharan Africa made $136.6 million in income in 2014, and paid $40 million in taxes, according to one report from a bipartisan think-tank. But they largely work in invisible jobs, said Catherine Besteman, a professor of anthropology at Maine’s Colby College. They take out trash at hotels, do the laundry at the hospital. People don’t see them working, she said, so when they see them driving a car, or shopping for groceries, it becomes easy to assume they got it for free.
That leaves some here still feeling that the immigrants take more than they deserve.
Tabitha Beauchesne pulled a bag of bargain-brand cereal out of her kitchen cabinet to demonstrate that point. At the grocery store, she said, she sees immigrant mothers with carts piled high with name-brand food.
“I guess I’m jealous of that. I would love to buy my kids the real Fruit Roll-Ups,” she said. “But, no, sorry kids, you get the fruit packets from Walmart.”
Tabitha Beauchesne walks past a painted U.S. flag outside a neighbor’s home in Auburn on Thursday, March 16, 2017. “We have thousands and thousands of homeless people, we’ve got veterans out on the streets, and we’re expected to bring in more refugees,” said Beauchesne. “We just need to stop.” Beauchesne voted for Barack Obama twice. Then she voted for Trump.Tabitha Beauchesne stands in her living room as photos of her husband and two children hang on the wall in her home in Auburn on Thursday, March 16, 2017. Beauchesne moved to Auburn, a city right across the river, because she believed that the refugee students at Lewiston schools take teachers’ attention away from native-born kids. She voted twice for Barack Obama. Then she voted for Donald Trump, because she hopes his pledge to put America first means immigration into her hometown will stop, or at least slow down.Lewiston High School students wait backstage to walk the runway for the school’s prom fashion show at the Franco American Heritage Center in Lewiston on Thursday, March 16, 2017. For more than a decade now, their community has been an experiment in immigration and all that comes with it _ the resentment, fear, friendships, triumphs, setbacks _ and Trump’s presidency marks another chapter in that struggle for the American soul.Lewiston city council member Tim Lajoie is reflected in a frame displaying American Revolution paraphernalia as he looks out his window at his home in Lewiston on Tuesday, March 14, 2017. “The mills moved out in the 80s and we’ve had this struggle to recover economically,” said Lajoie, who voted for Donald Trump. “We’re trying to find our footing I think. Trying to find out what we look like, what’s our identity.”A U.S. flag hangs at the Franco American Heritage Center as a woman enters to attend the local high school’s pre-prom fashion show in Lewiston on Thursday, March 16, 2017. Maine is the whitest state in America, 95 percent white, and its citizens were abruptly confronted with hundreds of black Muslims, traumatized by war and barely able to speak English.A worshipper takes his shoes off before entering the Lewiston Auburn Islamic Center for prayers in Lewiston on Friday, March 17, 2017. Hillary Clinton won the election within the city of Lewiston, though by less than 1,000 votes, a far narrower margin than President Barack Obama. It was in the rural communities circling the city, among voters who do not interact daily with the refugees, where Donald Trump got enough support to flip Androscoggin County red.The sun rises over billowing smokestacks in Lewiston on Friday, March 17, 2017. In early 2001, a few Somalian families struggling to afford housing in Portland, ventured 30 miles north to Lewiston, and a found a city in retreat. This once-dying American mill town has since been revived by an influx of some 7,500 African immigrants.
So Mohamad Ibrahim now knocks on doors.
“Hello,” he says to strangers across Androscoggin County. “I am a Muslim. I was welcomed by America. I was helped by General Assistance, and that was coming from your pockets and I am grateful. I became a taxpayer. I’m not taking anything. Now I am giving.”
He wants his neighbors to know him, to know that he is normal. Trump’s election here taught him he has a lot more work to do.
“We thought, ‘Yay, it’s perfect.’ But everything was slipping.”
Ibrahim came in 2012 from Djibouti, where he risked imprisonment for opposing his government. He is one of the thousands who have flooded into Lewiston in recent years because they are seeking asylum from oppression.
With them came a spike in the amount of taxpayer assistance going to immigrants. Asylum-seekers, unlike resettled refugees, are barred from getting work permits for at least six months and many, like Ibrahim, must rely on government assistance to get by when they first arrive. The amount paid to immigrants jumped recently to nearly a half-million dollars.
And there seems to be more tension in town since Trump took office. One woman reported she was nearly run down by a screaming driver; another said someone jerked her hijab and told her to go back where she came from.
Ardo Mohamed, the Somali who cooks sambusas with her sister, is an American citizen now. Her children were born in the United States. But they worry the government will come to send her away.
“We are scared,” she said. “They say every night, ‘Mom, if they take you, where we do live?'”
Ibrahim does not blame his neighbors for supporting Trump, because he’s seen the pull of populism before. When his friends complain about the policies on immigration, he reminds them of the day, more than a decade ago, that the interior minister of their country ordered all illegal immigrants to leave or face mass arrest. He asks them how they felt, and they respond: patriotic – like their government was looking out for them.
Ibrahim has his own hopes for the president. He hopes Trump will build an immigration system that gives people confidence that those coming are good and hardworking – so that, one day, people like him will be called Americans, not refugees. But he worries it will come at a cost.
In 50 years, he thinks, the descendants of his fellow African immigrants will be suspicious of whoever comes next.
“That’s how it’s been through history. The Irish were discriminated against, and then they discriminated against the French. The French were discriminated against, now they discriminate against us, at the bottom of the ladder,” he said, laughing uncomfortably.
“I don’t hope for that, it is not my wish. We can change. But still, we are stuck being human beings.”