R. Goldman: Wildlife policy without demonization

Natural predators are a vital part of every healthy ecosystem. Without them, other wildlife become weak and sick and the overall ecology becomes unhealthy and out of balance.

No matter how many times Paul Reynolds propagandizes ("A lesson to be learned in Lolo," Sun Journal, Jan. 29) about the supposed evils of wolves, coyotes and other natural predators he so desperately wants his readers to demonize and hate, alongside him and his misguided cohorts, the actual truth will come out.

The days of unopposed demonization and abuse of Maine's and America's wildlife are over.

In his latest wildlife propaganda piece, Reynolds states that wolves and only wolves have greatly reduced the population of elk in a particular region of Idaho called Lolo.

What he conveniently neglected to share is that the elk population began declining in Lolo many years before wolves had even returned there. He also did not report that in 23 of 29 wildlife management zones in Idaho, elk populations meet or exceed Idaho's own elk population targets. Approximately 103,000 elk roam Idaho, thriving amidst hundreds (not thousands) of wolves. There are plenty of elk in Idaho for wolves and humans.

Anyone can find this information by visiting the websites of the Idaho Department of Fish and Game, and an independent group called the Rocky Mountain Elk Foundation.

No one should rely on natural predator-hating zealots for accurate information about ecology.

When the rise and fall of deer and elk populations are honestly assessed, it always seems to come down to destruction or disturbance of vital wildlife habitat, weather, disease and over-hunting by humans. Objective wildlife biologists, including the state and federal biologists I've spoken with recently, do not pin "the blame" on natural predation. They accept natural predation as a vital part of every healthy ecosystem, just as most reasonable, informed and honest people do.

Which brings us to Maine. Paul Reynolds wants Mainers to join him in the coyote demonization campaign he and others are pushing here. No matter what the actual science reveals about the devastating loss of vital deer wintering habitat to clear-cutting and human greed, the related mortality of Maine's northernmost deer population due to recent harsh winters, the lack of publicly owned and protected lands in this state — as safe havens for deer to reproduce and thrive — the coyote demonizers continue to clamor and scream for killing coyotes as their twisted solution to deer heaven here in Maine.

They are either willfully misinformed or dishonest with the facts.

Dishonesty, demonization and disrespect toward natural predators makes for immoral, wrong-headed and unhealthy wildlife policy.

Maine's wildlife and wild lands deserve better than that, as do the good people of this state.

Robert Goldman, South Portland

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Displaying comments, from newest to oldest

Gary52's picture
verified

Gerry Lavigne, retired

Gerry Lavigne, retired biologist and foremost authority on Maine's Whitetail Deer, having headed that program for the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries & Wildlife for years, blames Coyote predation as one of the major factors contributing to the deer herd decline in Maine, secondary to habitat destruction and weather. To introduce another predator into the mix for no apparent good reason whatsoever makes no sense. Deer and deer hunting support jobs and businesses in areas of the State that do not have many other options, and deer hunter license fees help support IF&W, which protects ALL of our wildlife. Anti-hunters and ill informed folks that support introduction of wolves in Maine should spend some time visiting these areas of the state whose economies have taken a hit from loss of business due to the decline in the deer population and get some first hand information instead of spouting off from the comfort of their southern Maine homes.

Robert Goldman's picture
verified

Nice try, Gary, but no cigar

Gary: not a single person I have spoken with, not one Maine farmer, not one honest and decent Maine hunter and I know quite a few, not one active state or federal wildlife biologist I've spoken with recently agrees with you and your buddy Gerry Lavigne. Every honest and informed Mainer, every single one, knows without a doubt that a few really tough winters pummeled the Northern Maine deer population. And the fact that you and your cohorts cannot bring yourself to utter a single word against the greedy Mainers who are destroying so much deer wintering habitat is absolutely destroying any credibility you have. Unethical, misguided and ineffective coyote demonization, and the out of control massacre of these natural predators is seriously hurting the image of Maine hunters. Look at the Maine Farm Bureau sponsored bill that completely banned night hunting of coyotes and placed huge restrictions on baiting on private property. You and your side are sowing the seeds of your own destruction. Keep it up. You and SAM and your buddies are creating fewer kids who want to hunt and turning lots more of your fellow citizens against hunting. Fewer and fewer people are willing to go along with anti-ecology bullies and natural predator demonizers.

By the way, your silly crack about folks who live in Southern Maine is so middle school. We have lots of deer and tons of coyotes down here. You must live in an unheated tent in the middle of the Maine Woods?

Maine's native wolves were foolishly and brutally removed, so mother nature called the coyotes to fill the natural predator void that was created by human ignorance and prejudice. I look forward to the return of wolves that is coming sooner than later. The return of wolves will mean fewer coyotes and a healthier, robust deer and moose population. That's what wolves do, wherever they live the ecology is healthier. Wolves are native to Maine after all and you can be sure, as Maine's wildlife policies finally evolve and become wiser and more wholesome, they will return.

Gary52's picture
verified

Coyotes are filling the void

Coyotes are filling the void left by the extinction of wolves??? Quite a stretch Robert. The long and short of it is that coyotes have no natural enemies in Maine except humans, and as such, it falls to us to control their population by the most effective means necessary. As far as wolf re-introduction into Maine goes, that's another story that HSUS and PETA can play out with their donated millions. I agree with you that habitat destruction is a major player in the decline of northern Maine deer, and I stated that in my first post, as you can see. That is an issue that needs attention by the appropriate state agencies that can deal with the large landowners. As far as my "crack" about Southern Maine, I stand by my comment because for many businesses in the "Other Maine", hunting is a major source of income for them and the folks they employ. If you haven't lived it, which you obviously haven't, then you shouldn't be so quick to condemn it from the viewpoint of the county with the lowest unemployment rate and highest per capita income in Maine. BTW, my tent is heated...with wood.

Advertisement