Report: Maine led nation for share of fatal car crashes on rural roads

PORTLAND — A national report found 98 percent of Maine’s fatal car crashes occurred on rural, non-interstate roads in 2012 as the amount of rural road pavement in poor condition rose about 9 percentage points from three years prior. The percentage of deficient rural bridges rose one point from the 2009 report.

The latest rural road assessment released Thursday from Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit research group The Road Information Program, or TRIP, found 161 of 164 fatal Maine crashes happened on rural roads in 2012, compared with 137 of 159 fatal crashes, or 86 percent, in 2009.

Maine ranked far higher than the national average — around 50 percent — both years but jumped from fourth to the highest state in the country for the share of vehicle fatalities that occurred on rural roads.

While Maine far outpaced the national average and the next-highest North Dakota — 81 percent — for the share of all fatal crashes on rural roads, it does not mean Maine roads were the nation’s most dangerous. The TRIP report estimated Maine had two fatalities for every 100,000 miles traveled on rural roads in 2012, placing it 26th nationally. That’s half the rate of South Carolina, which had the deadliest rural roads in that year.

By contrast, Maine had the safest interstate in the country, with just 26 deaths per 100,000 miles traveled on urban roads and the interstate. For all roadways, Maine placed 26th by that measure.

Maria Fuentes, executive director of the Maine Better Transportation Association, said rural road quality is a “huge issue” every state is facing.

“There is data that shows there are more accidents on rural roads that aren’t in good shape,” Fuentes said in a phone interview. “So it’s a safety issue, and it’s an economic issue. And I think it’s something that impacts every person in the state.”

Fuentes said the problem has been exacerbated in recent years by gridlock in Washington, D.C., echoing a statement of TRIP’s latest rural roads report that calls on the federal government to boost funding for the federal Highway Trust Fund.

If Congress doesn’t allocate more money to the fund by Oct. 1, a cash shortfall projected by the Congressional Budget Office could mean $196 million in cuts to highway and transit improvements in Maine, the report states.

“The impact of inadequate federal surface transportation revenues could be felt as early as this summer, when the balance in the Highway Account of the federal Highway Trust Fund is expected to drop below $1 billion, which will trigger delays in the federal reimbursement to states for road, highway and bridge projects, which would likely result in states delaying numerous projects,” the report states.

Fuentes said lagging federal funding is matched with decreased investment at the state level. In the 1970s, she said, about 26 percent of state revenues went to transportation; that figure is now closer to 10 percent.

“With the federal government not being the partner that they once were with the states, states are having to figure out on their own how to maintain their system, and it’s been very difficult,” she said.

Jim Hanley, who handles government relations for Westbrook-based Pike Industries and is president of the Maine Better Transportation Association, said in a statement the rising percentage of rural road pavement in poor condition harms Maine’s economy.

“Every year [Maine Department of Transportation] posts more than 2,000 miles of state roads for months in the spring, and that has a profound effect on our rural economy — inhibiting the movement of goods and services and putting the public safety at risk,” Hanley said.

In 2012, a TRIP report estimated Mainers paid between $299 and $526 per year for car repair costs because of bad roads — a rise from October 2009.

According to the group’s website, its funders include businesses involved in highway and transit engineering and construction, insurance companies, equipment manufacturers, distributors and suppliers and others it says are concerned “with an efficient and safe surface transportation network.”

The latest report also points to agriculture as an industry bearing the brunt of bad roads. Earlier this year, USDA data showed the number of Maine farms is on the rise.

“Certainly local farming is an area in which we’re really seeing some very positive growth,” Fuentes said. “But we’re not giving them the support in terms of the transportation network that we should be.”

Ted Talbot, spokesman for Maine’s transportation department, said he couldn’t comment on road conditions broadly without knowing which roads the TRIP study identified as being in poor condition. In its three-year work plan, released in January, the department estimated funding for its core highway and bridge programs will fall about $100 million short per year.

Rocky Moretti, TRIP’s director of policy and research, said in an email the group’s data “does not include any additional data on actual bridges or roads,” but its pavement data includes rural arterials, or high-capacity roads, and collectors, which are low-to-moderate capacity roads.

While the latest report gives a general overview of the condition of rural roads in the state, Fuentes said her organization will get more specific next week, revealing its choice for the “Worst Road in Maine Contest.”

As for bridges, the report found 16 percent of the state’s rural bridges were structurally deficient, compared with 15 percent in 2010. The study is one of many issued on infrastructure quality each year.

What do you think of this story?

Login to post comments

In order to make comments, you must create a subscription.

In order to comment on, you must hold a valid subscription allowing access to this website. You must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. To subscribe or link your existing subscription click here.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned from posting comments.



Wait, how hard can it be?

Wait, how hard can it be? Maine is almost ALL rural roads anyway!

FRANK EARLEY's picture

You know Al............

Every time I think back on that incident with the voter approved bonds package, and his refusal to fulfill the wishes of the people, and at the same time I go through what I went through the other day. It burns me. I have a good mind to send a bill of my own to the Governors office, the bill for my new suspension system.......

AL PELLETIER's picture

Remember the 2010 referendum?

You know, the one that asked if Maine voters wanted to approve a multimillion dollar bond for road and infrastructure improvements? You know, the one we approved knowing our roads and bridges were in serious disrepair?
Come on now, you remember don't you?
It was the one LePage threw in the trash and said he'd approve the bonds when he was good and ready. Now do you remember?

FRANK EARLEY's picture

If there was ever any doubt????????????????????

The other day while I was in the Leeds area, the air compressor in my Lincoln went south on me. Now anyone who ever thought a road was bad, hasn't ridden on one under these circumstances. Under normal conditions, my 6000lb vehicle is usually pretty smooth on the worst of the unmaintained roads in Maine. Once I lost the air in the four air struts, I may have just as well been driving a 2x6 with four wheels nailed on the bottom of it. It was like the front end would hit a bump and before you come close to handling that bump the rear wheels hit. I had a friend with me and I thought she was going to exit the truck and walk the rest of the way home. An idea that didn't sound to bad to me as well. The roads were so bad in town that the minute I arrived home I ordered a whole new suspension system using the old fashioned, yet much more dependable coil spring system. I wonder if the old system with it's four good air struts and all the sensors would get me anything on Craigs List, or E-Bay????????????????


Winning numbers

So when it comes to bad roads and bridges we are near the top of the national polls. We are also near the top in heroin overdoses but near the bottom in economic development and even with Georgia when it comes to developing alternative energy. Always a bad thing to be even with Georgia. Maybe we need a governor who gets his butt off voter approved road construction bonds and gets out of the way of green energy development.


Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...