New EPA rules mean fresher air, fairer utility rates

Gov. Paul LePage has correctly complained that Maine's higher-than-average electric rates drag down our state's economy.

While Maine has the lowest rates in New England, we are still far higher than Southern and Midwestern states that burn coal to produce electricity.

One of the reasons these plants operate so cheaply is that they export their toxins on prevailing air currents to New England and dump them on our heads.

That's why Mainers should applaud new standards adopted last week by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency that will curb toxins in air pollution by about 90 percent within five years.

The new rules are way overdue, thanks to the millions spent on lobbying by the coal, petroleum and electricity utility industries.

The new rules won't come without a cost to ratepayers in the affected states, estimated at $9.6 billion annually.

But those costs are far outweighed by the estimated health care savings, estimated between $37 and $90 billion annually by 2016 when the new law fully goes into effect.

But there's more: The U.S. Lung Association estimates that the stricter standards will prevent 130,000 childhood asthma attacks each year and 11,000 premature deaths.

Maine has one of the highest asthma rates in the nation, and the "tailpipe" effect of transported pollutants is one of the biggest reasons why.

But there's more.

The new rules are expected to reduce 90 percent of the airborne mercury produced by these coal-fired plants.

That mercury ends up in our fish and wildlife and, ultimately, in our bodies. Even small amounts of mercury contribute to attention deficit disorder, developmental delays and learning disabilities.

The new rules will also force these power companies to reduce another toxic chemical, lead, in their emissions.

Over the years, scientists have found that even tiny amounts of lead can cause learning and behavioral impairment in children.

"Before this rule, there were no national standards limiting the amount of mercury, arsenic, chromium, nickel and acid gases that power plants across the country could release into the air that we breathe," EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson said last week.

The longstanding problem with fossil fuels has always been their unallocated costs. Today, we know that coal may be cheap to burn, but the medical and environmental costs are paid elsewhere in asthma attacks, acidic waterways and restrictions on eating fish.

The new EPA rule will more fairly allocate those costs back to the people who deserve to pay them, the electric ratepayers who now enjoy artificially inexpensive power.

That should help even out the disparities between electric rates in New England and other regions of the country.

And that, we trust, is one form of increased governmental regulation that our governor can fully support.

rrhoades@sunjournal.com

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Displaying comments, from newest to oldest

Mike Lachance's picture
verified

Speaking of huffing off a

Speaking of huffing off a tailpipe, Claire, Steve and Dan seem to have been stuck in the magic bus with the windows closed a bit too long. If ever there were a lobbying group to fear it would be the "Carbon is Poison" group. About the most insane connection made in the history of mankind.

Carbon Dioxide (CO2) = POISON?????????

That assertion is enough to shine a light brightly on stupidity for the ages.

Now lets talk about Mercury shall we? All those "ECO" "Green" CFL "Earth Saving" light bulbs have MERCURY in them. You CANNOT dispose of them in the trash, of you face HUGE fines.

"Oh no, its just a trace amount of mercury"... Nope. a trace of mercury can seriously screw up a kid for life.

FOLKS think twice about who's steering the Green ECO Bus, because it isnt your friends, and it isnt in the interest of anyone but the ones taking your fool-bucks and cashing. And Saving the Planet is the last thing they care about.

Claire2323's picture
verified

Clean air

If you don't believe what's in our air try hanging a piece of white cloth outside and leave it there overnight or in a rainstorm. You will be surprised at what it collects. But then don't believe your lying eyes just believe the lobbyists. They surely have our best interests in mind don't they?

hawaiian's picture
verified

New EPA rules mean fresher air, fairer utility rates

Nice editorial , Rex 11.12.26 7:45 pm √
Red ( communist ) China has no E P A . The latest . .hmm. .shall we say . . Kyoto Accords that were just agreed upon earlier this month excludes the communist Chinese from the list of developing countries , too , so they can no longer get away with emitting vast amounts of CO2 in to the atmosphere like they have up until now . Their coal is a soft , brown ( dirty ) coal that they use in their power plants , i believe . Bejing is like Mexico City . People walk around with masks over their faces and can not even see the sun some days for all the smog and air pollution
Acid rain ? Yes . It exists . It's why your ME ponds are sterile on the slopes of your mountains and the western sides are all barren ( the trees are dead or dying ) . Go take a look
b t w - It's what you can not see in the air that will harm you ( CO2 and ** what was stated above ^^ ) . That black soot one sees from diesel engines is really not at issue
Kudos to this newspaper for the excellent and balanced coverage it gives to many complicated subjects such as this every day of the week , 24 x 7 x 365 :) Here's to a Happy and Prosperous New Year 2 0 1 2
/s, Steve Dosh , Hawai'i

tron's picture

don't be so quick to applaud.

don't be so quick to applaud. If the tea radicals are successful in defeating President Obama, the new president will immediately rescind these regulations, citing 'excessive' regulation hurting the 'job creators', and with the repeal of the Affordable Care Act, the fact it will kill thousands will be irrelevant. It's the republican mantra, and the hordes of mind zombies that will echo the Fox News message over and over.

hawaiian's picture
verified

. .Right , Dan :) er. .we

. .Right , Dan :)
er. .we used to refer to the leƒt as ' radicals ' and the right as ' reactionaries .' Subtle difference
The beauty of our ' 100& legal now ' Obamacare is that one can complain about it and benefit from it at the same time √
That said , the tea partiers can now have their cake and eat it , too
Aloha from the birthstate of our President who is vactioning here with his lovely wife Michelle , and their two daughters daughters Sasha and Melia . This is the first President to have little kids in the White House since J F K . Happy New Year 2 0 1 2

Advertisement