Murder trial testimony: Frying pan missing, jacket found

PARIS — Testimony about blood stains, fingerprints and a frying pan dominated the sixth day of the murder trial of Agostino J. Samson in Oxford County Superior Court on Friday.

The 23-year-old Windham man is accused of bludgeoning to death his former employer, Scott Libby, 25, of Raymond, this past February in Bethel.

Libby was found lying dead across the front seat of his car, which had been parked on railroad tracks near the Barker Road crossing. The car had been hit from behind by a slow-moving train at about 2:45 a.m. on Feb. 20.

Police determined that Libby died of injuries unrelated to the crash. An autopsy by the state Medical Examiner's Office revealed the cause of death was strangulation and blunt-force trauma to the head, police said.

Samson, who worked at Libby's greenhouse during the summer of 2008, met with Libby late the night before at the Bethel Hostel on Route 2, where Samson was renting a room, the affidavit said. The meeting was arranged so Samson could pay Libby the $400 he had loaned and Libby could return a watch and bracelet held as collateral, police said.

The hostel is less than a quarter-mile from where Libby's car was found.

On Friday, Assistant Attorney General Andrew Benson called the prosecution's final witnesses, including Cathy MacMillan, a forensic DNA analyst with the Maine State Police Crime Lab. She was unable to confirm the presence of blood on the watch due to the small size of a stain there. However, she said the DNA profile showed a likely match to Libby; a second DNA profile could not be determined.

MacMillan said an alcohol swab found in the hostel's garbage had Libby's DNA profile on it, as well as a profile that matched Samson's DNA at certain points. One in 39 people would fit the profile, she said.

Other tests found Libby's DNA in bloodstains on the exterior of his car and on a doorknob of the hostel. A second DNA profile that did not match Samson was found in the doorknob test. MacMillan said it was possible that DNA unrelated to the blood could have been collected in the test.

Defense lawyer Maurice Porter said the partial profile matching Samson could apply to tens of thousands of people in Maine or the Boston area, where Libby sometimes worked as a bartender. MacMillan also said DNA profiles of stains found on Samson's shoes did not match Libby.

Alicia Wilcox, a latent print examiner with the crime lab, testified that a fingerprint of blood on the underside of one of the hostel doorknobs matched a known print of Samson's right pinkie. She said the lab was unable to confirm that the print was made of blood due to the small size of a sample taken. She said the print's color was consistent with other prints of blood that she has observed and was located near stains that tested positive for blood.

Porter suggested that numerous prints may have been left on the hostel doors by guests there.

Detective Scott Gosselin of the Maine State Police said he and Wilcox examined Libby's car for fingerprints, and were able to find finger marks in blood and partial ridges from fingerprints but nothing usable. He said bloodstain patterns inside the car were consistent with blood spatter from blunt-force assault and that blood on the interior of the door jamb suggested that some of the impacts may have occurred outside the car. Gosselin also said it appeared someone had gone through Libby's carry bag and glove compartment.

Under cross-examination, Gosselin said a number of objects in Samson's room at the hostel were tested for blood and all came up negative.

Hostel Manager Wyling Cambrium testified that a small cast-iron frying pan was missing from the hostel. The pan handle found in Libby's car looked similar to the one on the pan that was missing, Cambrium said.

Defense lawyer Porter showed Cambrium a statement in which he told police it had been three weeks since he saw the pan. Cambrium said Friday that he usually checks the kitchen utensils every few days to make sure they are in order.

Porter presented the court with a blue winter coat, which Samson's grandmother, Julia Larrabee of Windham, said was taken to her house after Samson moved out of the hostel. Prosecutor Benson has contended that Samson disposed of his coat after the killing.

The trial is scheduled to resume at 8:30 a.m. Monday.

mlangeveld@sunjournal.com

 

 

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Displaying comments, from newest to oldest

Apexupsaura's picture

The prosecution sure had a

The prosecution sure had a few statements backfire on them , especially the assumption about the missing jacket. However, I do have a lot of respect for the state police officers and think there was no tampering with the evidence. The problem I have with this case, there is DNA to link both men to the hostel and since they were both there, that is a normal finding. The lack of evidence linking Mr Samson to the crime scene is not there. That is disturbing. If the prosecution presented Mr Samson's belt, loaded with matching DNA evidence, I would convict him on a heartbeat. If Mr Samson strangled Mr Libby with that belt, which has been claimed, there would be DNA all over it and it simply was not there. Lack of DNA in Mr Samson's room, the crime scene, Mr Libby's car make this a very difficult, troublesome case to convict someone with so many questions unanswered. You just can't commit a crime like this with out DNA linking the individual directly to the crime scene and Mr Libby's car. If I were on the jury with this evidence, there is enough reasonable doubt not to convict Samson for the evidence does not link him to the car or crime scene. . However, I would not be convinced of his total innocence and wouldn't bet a million bucks on it either. Regardless of what Mr Libby did that evening, weather it be making inappropriate advances toward Mr Samson, or made a poor choice to go to the RT 2 cruise zone for sex, this certainly doesn't justify another human being to savagely murder. Mr Libby. Mr Libby may be guilty of making a poor choice, but there is nothing that can justify such a brutal slaying and such a person should not be able to live free amongst us and should be punished to the fullest extent of the law. We are all only human and can only try our best. In this country, we have a jury system, so whether you agree with the out come or not, you have to except the decision these people make. In the end, it is was it is and if we were all fooled, the man upstairs you don't fool and you will pay in ways you would never imagine. As a concluding comment, I don't have much respect for the Libby family and friends at all for the downgrading comments they made about Mr Samson just because they want to blame someone. He may be guilty, but prior to that, those comments were not justified. In this country, you are innocent until proven otherwise by a jury of out peers. Scott Libby was a nice kid, no question about it. Like us all, he was no angel either and far from it. However, he did not deserve this kind of fate. In a case like this, there are no winners , for we all loose

rkchrcmlvc's picture

The police in this case were

The police in this case were caught in several lies. If the cops lie about one piece of evidence, what part of their testimony can be believed? In my opinion none.

Apexupsaura's picture

TO Donald R: The collateral

TO Donald R:
The collateral was exchanged between Mr Samson and Mr Libby. The state Police were investigating Mr Samson the next day and found no such amount of money on Mr Samson or in his room which would indicate Mr Samson did not rob Mr Libby. According to Mr Samson, they did however have a scuffle for Mr Libby made sexual advances towards him. After that, Mr Libby left the hostel. From what has been told to me, Mr Libby was a very nice kid, well liked by his community, however, he was out of control with his sex life. As one put it, he has been around the block more than the Ogunquit trolley. Since this was a very brutal, savage murder to a point one would not even recognize Mr Libby, it would appear impossible for the killer to commit such a brutal, bloody crime without being loaded with DNA, and they found nothing pointing to Mr Samson. So the lack of evidence in this situation would support his innocence. Regardless of Mr Libby's sexual orientation, whether or not he was on the Rt 2 cruise zone, he was viciously murdered and the person that did this, based on the evidence, is at large. This case is one without conclusion and has a very sad ending. The important thing at this time is they don't put an innocent man away especially when the evidence shows Mr Samson was never near that car, in that car , at the murder scene or the railroad tracks. In the end, who did this will pay for God will even the score for he always does. You may fool everybody else, but you won't fool him and I do believe in Karma.

DonaldR's picture

Was it ever determined the

Was it ever determined the money/collateral exchange did indeed occur? Sounds like very little evidence to convict this man...

Apexupsaura's picture

This case is one of many

This case is one of many surprises, but the prosecution has shown everything they have. The missing coat , which the DA said could not be found and indicates Mr Samson was hiding evidence. The coat was found and was kept at Mr Samson's grandmother's house when he moved out of the hostel. The famous frying pan that Mr Samson was suppose to get from the hostel kitchen , was determined the frying pan came from either Mr Samson's place of employment or the hostel and there was no evidence on the pan handle pointing to Mr Samson. There is no evidence at the scene of the murder, the railroad tracks, or Mr Libby's vehicle linking Mr Samson to the crime. Any evidence they do have at the hostel is very marginal, inconclusive at best showing nothing. All the theories about how Mr Samson supposedly murdered Mr Libby is just not supported by any evidence and when challenged, does not hold up. The lack of evidence proves Mr Samson's innocence. Another theory that Mr Libby was apprehended outside the hostel and robbed is remotely possible, but there are a lot of holes in that too. The most likely theory, Mr Libby was a gay man and it is well known he was very promiscuous with his sex life. He also worked at a gay bar known for cruising and picking up men. Rt 2 near the hostel is a cruising and pick up zone for gay men. I suspect Mr Libby was on that road and picked up the wrong trick and that is who killed him. There obviously was no force entry into the car. In the end, Mr Libby was responsible for his own death caused by his irresponsible sex life and his luck ran out on February 20, 2009 when he made the decision to go to that cruise zone for sex. At this point I believe this case will not be solved and I hope Mr Samson is released to go home with his family for he is an innocent man not capable of such a savage killing. I'm not picking sides on this case at all, just following where the evidence leads. This case has a sad ending, but the Libby family has to accept that Scott's demise was his own fault and for them accusing an innocent individual is inexcusable. Accept the reality of it and let the healing process begin.

Advertisement