TABOR is not the answer for Maine

Moms tend to know best, and it's generally because of the lessons they have learned from experience. Wisdom my Mom instilled in me that I have since passed to my four children says this: that many times, things aren't what they seem and what looks like a good deal can end up costing you in the end.

This is much like what Maine is confronting with Question 4 on the ballot this November. Known as the "Taxpayer Bill of Rights," Question 4 is big on promises, but it will fall short on being able to deliver and will end up costing Maine families in the long run. 

How do I know this? Experience.

I am a mom and a fiscally conservative businesswoman from Colorado who has lived under the failed promises of TABOR. When TABOR appeared on the ballot for the third time before it passed in 1992, it was sold as a way to control spending, boost our economy, and give citizens greater control over our taxes. It sounded great, but what we got was quite different.

Question 4, much like Colorado's TABOR, is packaged as a simple idea. In truth, however, it is really quite complicated. It puts an inflexible and faulty one-size-fits-all formula into law that doesn't account for the true costs of running complex state and local budgets.

Colorado is the only state in the country to have approved TABOR, and it forced drastic cuts in programs and services that impact families and businesses. Firsthand, I saw what happened to our schools under this measure. TABOR resulted in fewer public dollars for classrooms and higher costs for parents as they were forced to pay out-of-pocket for basic supplies and after-school programs.

Because of TABOR, our state fell to 49th in the country in K-12 spending and now ranks near last among states in high school graduation rates. Colorado also ranks 49th in state support for higher education. As a result, tuition has dramatically increased, causing a greater burden on students and families.

TABOR failed to boost our state's economy as promised. As education and transportation funding was squeezed under TABOR's arbitrary formula — just like the one found in Question 4 — it made government a weak partner in economic development. It left our work force untrained, weakened our transportation system, and cost businesses the opportunity to grow.

Colorado lost more jobs in the last recession than all states but three. After ten years of being in effect, our state's growth rate was the lowest in the Rocky Mountain region. It is clear that TABOR failed to improve our state's business climate.

We even found that the promise of greater accountability from our politicians was false. State and local leaders were less responsive and less accountable because their hands were tied by an inflexible formula.

So after 12 years of systematic disinvestment in K-12, higher education, health care and transportation, families and businesses began to take notice. This widespread concern about the rigid formula culminated into the biggest, broadest political coalition in Colorado's history. We came together to set aside this failed idea. This effort came at the cost of thousands of hours of work from volunteers and an additional cost to families and businesses of about $9 million.

As you consider Question 4, think about Colorado's experience and whether you want to go down our same path. Be wary of the soundbite. The inflation and population-based formula is guaranteed to limit your options at the time when your state is searching for a brighter economic future.

From my experience, TABOR is not the answer.

Kristi Hargrove is a Republican and small business owner from Crested Butte, Colorado, who has spoken against TABOR in Maine. Her visits were underwritten by the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities. 

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Displaying comments, from newest to oldest

Lil's picture
verified

TABOR was so flawed and

TABOR was so flawed and harmful in Colorado, they voted to suspend it.
______________________

"A conservative is a man with two perfectly good legs who, however, has never learned to walk forward."
Franklin D. Roosevelt

Old Bill's picture

Sorry, folks, but TABOR is

Sorry, folks, but TABOR is not the answer you think it is. The simplest, best way to cut spending is to get rid of the complete morons we keep electing to Augusta. Replace them with people who have common sense, and things will improve. TABOR won't accomish that.
"The democracy will cease to exist when the government takes from those who would work and gives to those who would not." - Thomas Jefferson.

ohreally's picture

WHY is Ms. Hargrove so eager

WHY is Ms. Hargrove so eager to travel across the country to spread her message, one might wonder? Surely it's not for the public recognition, so just what is she gaining??

Ms. Hargrove's comment, regarding Colorado - "I saw what happened to our schools under this measure. TABOR resulted in fewer public dollars for classrooms and higher costs for parents as they were forced to pay out-of-pocket for basic supplies and after-school programs." is COMPLETELY irrelevant to Maine, as Maine already REQUIRES voter approval for school budgets. This TABOR like plan is working for Maine schools - why in the world would Maine lawmakers not want to expand it to the entire budget?? Oh, I guess that might affect the pork projects....Maine voters need to send this message to the Maine Legislature - "STOP spending our money without our approval!"
TABOR will do that - get out and vote YES on 4!!!

Mike Peters's picture
verified

Oh yes, TABOR is the answer.

Oh yes, TABOR is the answer. The biggest argument against TABOR is that it will force the State and the towns and cities to cut spending. It will not. It allows for increases based on inflation. Opponents say that it it will cut funds to feed children and funds to education. Opponents say the first thing cut will be high school football and anything else popular with the voting public. This is pure bull. It is meant to scare the hell out of people. What TABOR will do is force government at all levels to PRIORITIZE their spending just as we do with our family budgets at home or the business budget at work. If you haven't got the money, then you can't have the service. It is that simple. If the politicians and the progressive folk want more and expanded services, then they simply have to convince the voter that the service is vital to survival. If they do that, then spending can be increased. If not, then they will have to learn to live within the budget and to PRIORITIZE their spending. They can cut one program to save another, or cut back on spending in one area to increase it in another. The key is to put this darned government on a budget and force them to live within OUR means.

Mac antSaior's picture
verified

Ever wonder why our taxes

Ever wonder why our taxes are so out of control? Just browse jobsinme.com and see how many direct support jobs are paid with your money. TABOR is a common sense formula for out of control politicians.

It is the undauntable thought, my friend. The one that says, "I'm right!" ~Bobby Sands

Advertisement