Wind farm proposals multiply

RUMFORD – With dozens of wind
turbines proposed in a half-dozen towns in various stages of
planning, the Wind Farm Development Committee of Rumford is planning
a panel discussion on the pros and cons of such development.

The forum begins at 6 p.m. Oct. 13 in
Muskie Auditorium of Mountain Valley High School.

The local committee is particularly
concerned with tentative plans by First Wind, LLC, of Newton, Mass.,
to site a 40-megawatt wind farm on the ridge that connects Black,
South Twin and North Twin mountains. Most of the site is in
Rumford, with a small portion in Roxbury.

“We want to get more information
about it,” said Karl Aromaa, one of the committee's members. “We
want to get both sides.”

Among the panelists are: Albert
Aniel, a 30-year physician in the Rumford area; Steve Thurston, a
Roxbury summer resident and Vermont resident who heads up Peoples'
Task Force on Wind Power; J. Dwight, Wilton, a member of the Maine
Heritage Policy Center; Tom Powell, a Dixfield businessman who has
discussed a wind farm proposal in Dixfield; Steve Bennet, whose home
is near a Freedom wind farm; and Lisa Linowes, a New
Hampshire resident who is executive director of Industrial Wind
Action Group.

Aromaa said one or more First Wind
representatives are expected to appear. He is also looking for a
representative from the state or other organization, such as the
Natural Resources Council of Maine, to attend the forum.

He said the Rumford group began meeting
a couple of months ago after watching the Roxbury process which
included opposition from many of the town's residents. Independence
Wind, owned by Robert Gardiner and former Gov. Angus King, received
approval recently to construct 22 wind turbines on a ridge in the
town.

Also being looked at are a ridge in
Carthage that would accommodate 12 or 13 turbines, three in
Buckfield, 10 to 13 in Woodstock, and 8 to 20 in Dixfield.

Dixfield plans to hold a special town
meeting next week asking for action on a proposed moratorium on wind
farms until an ordinance can be written. Buckfield selectmen are
considering the same thing. Rumford selectmen turned down a request
for a moratorium last month. Carthage continues to work on the
ownership of part of the ridge where an expanded proposed wind farm could
could be sited. Most of the land proposed for a wind farm is under
private ownership.

In Woodstock, Patriot Renewables'
proposal has advanced to going before the Planning Board next month
for site plan review.

First Wind has dozens of wind projects
in various stages of development throughout the Northeast and western
states.

Another forum to explore wind energy
issues in Oxford County is also planned for 7 a.m. Oct. 23 at the
Four Seasons Function Center in Paris. That event is hosted by the
Western Maine Economic Development Council and will include
representatives from Patriot Renewables, Kean Project Engineering of Turner,
the Natural Resources Council of Maine, Thurston and others.

eadams@sunjournal.com

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Displaying comments, from newest to oldest

Philomena McPheeBrown's picture

In regard to the MMA

In regard to the MMA rejecting the resolution made by Dr. Aniel, it passed their house at an MMA meeting a few weeks after the "rejection" that is stated in your comment. Also, as far as moratoriums are concerned ,the idea here is to allow time to plan in order avoid the mess that happened in other towns.
The 2nd issue is about knowledgeable professionals giving information. How could First Wind, the interested party, be considered to be the only one to give information when there is the potential for significant bias? The citizens of the Rumford area need to have an opportunity to get more information before a large wind power project slips in to their community and gets approved. Is the goal for all citizens in our area to have an opportunity to try to get some relief on our high electric rates,or to just let the wind power companies just put up these structures with no benefit to the community where they are placed? I think we all need to think about these issues and develop dialogue to understand how major changes in our landscape forever may have the effect of potential loss or gain of property values and whether or not it may affect possible future expansion of our area as a desirable place to live. Low electric rates, if true, and appropriately located wind power projects have the potential to benefit everyone-as long as there is no harm done to the local folks that live near these structures. This is what the resolution basically states-to evaluate the potential health issues related to these structures-not to completely eliminate the potential for any wind power projects. The last issue is about the Grid and who will pay for this. We need more information about how much the taxpayers and ratepayers in Maine are going to have to pay out for an upgraded Grid. Are we going to pay for a part of this and get no rate reductions on our electric rates? Is there a decommissioning plan if the turbines become obsolete? Who will pay to take the turbines down-the town or First Wind? These are just a few of the questions that need to be addressed to understand the potential pros and cons of wind power in our area. Please think about it before accepting a delay on a moratorium.

BarrelRacer's picture

Well put CS. I was thinking

Well put CS. I was thinking the same thing, why go listen to a bunch of people who we have already heard through the Roxbury deal. BLAH BLAH BLAH flicker BLAH BLAH BLAH noise BLAH BLAH blight BLAH BLAH

dandee84's picture
verified

When this group first

When this group first approached the Rumford Selectmen to request a 180 day moratorium, the selectmen correctly pointed out that windpower in Rumford is years away as no one has even applied for permits for roads to do the testing. The selectmen feel that there is plenty of time for careful, deliberate and thorough education so the people can make wise decisions on this matter.

Ron Theriault wisely pointed out that in his examination of the subject he found much on the internet written by those with the title Dr. or Ph.D. He being quite wise did not just take those titles as the gospel that the writer or speaker was doctor of, had a Ph D in or so forth in the field they seemed to suggest they were an expert in. I must say, Ron was a step ahead of me here. He had mad a point of checking the credentials of the Dr., PhD and soforeth to see if they were indeed credible. He suggested that thre Town bring in credible speakers to educate us.

The moratorium group has now scheduled a meeting and invited a number of speakers whose names have been made public. I decided to take Ron's advice befor I ventured to the High School and see what credibility through credentials I could fid for the listed speakers. Albert Aniel is a local physician of general practice with no specialty in the relavent areas of accoustics or anything else I could find. He submitted a proposal to the MMA against wind power which according to MMA documentation was rejected 9-1. Steve Thurston is a resident of Roxbury and other than being involved in three failed attemps to ban wind power in Roxbury he has no special knowledge. Steve Bennet is a former selectmen ib Freedom with large land holdings that according to the articles I read where not of interest to the windpower developer there. He was also previously considering developing a senior community on this very large parcel at one time but again, according to what I read had given up on that plan. after Plum Creek that is understandable. He is not trained in any field relavent to windpower. Tom Powell is the business from Dixfield who recently offered to assist Dixfield in gathering information and in the articles he claims no knowledge just a desire to learn and make an informed decision. Jay Dwight is a newspaper commentator. You may remember his commentary a while ago comparing the economies of Maine and New Hampshire, no wind power related expertise here either. Then we have Lisa Linowes who has a masters degree in marketing and was formerly with Xerox, autodesk, Houghton ?ifflin before beginning several of her own startups. Again no engineering. environmental or accoustics expertise or training.

If First Wind attends this meeting, they will be the only qualified speakers and at this point, they are not coming and neither am I. I hope at some point Rumford will have qualified people address the citizens and I will attend at that time. For now, if I want hystirics, conjecture, inuendeau, and scare tactics I will read the newspaper or a fiction novel
If we could only return to common sense...

johnc77's picture

What will happen to the

What will happen to the paper mills energy supplying boiler??Shut down? More lost jobs?
What wil happen to the Falls supplier? Shut down? More lost jobs?
What will happen to the energy supplier in Smith Crossing? Shut down? More lost jobs?
Who stands to gain from this venture?
And just where do you think our govenor is going to be imployed after his term? With his friend Angus? HMMMMM!!

pumpernickel's picture
verified

Let's learn from what has

Let's learn from what has happened in other towns and not have a situation like this-
http://waldo.villagesoup.com/print/Print.cfm?StoryID=178160

BarrelRacer's picture

Bring on the wind mills!

Bring on the wind mills! Wind mills= less mills on the tax bill.

to be or not's picture

If you see this I want a

If you see this I want a wind mill in Waterford there are two of us my friend has more land but I can have one .all we want is a slight charge for use of land and free electricty.

Advertisement