Join the community!

Login, register or Connect to comment.

Columns & Analysis

Cities have no direction - let's give them one

Published on Sunday, Jul 19, 2009 at 12:12 am | Last updated on Friday, Jul 17, 2009 at 12:12 pm 4 Comments
This has been a week that's shaken Lewiston-Auburn.

There was the move to fire Jim Bennett, without cause or public discussion. Then, within 24 hours, a major anchor of this community's history was lost to a mighty blaze.

A old phrase, with a local spin, is aptly applied here: while the councilors fiddle, Lewiston burns.

Those in seats of power have chosen to occupy themselves with unimportant matters, and have neglected the community's priorities during a crisis.

No attempt is being made, of course, to tie limited leadership to the burning of the Cowan Mill. But the inferno created a visual demonstration of the real challenges facing this community beyond the personality conflicts that exist among the power elite.

How soon we forget, due to recent successes, that Lewiston was regularly called the "armpit of Maine" along with other adages intended to demean and belittle the people of this community.

Local politics were viewed as corrupt and economic development was at a relative standstill.

Reputations are fragile. And with a couple of major events last week, it appears there is something unpleasant hiding behind the attractive façade built in the last 10 years.

While some in the readership area of this paper, and in particular those holding seats of influence, may not monitor public opinion elsewhere, the reactions by outsiders to these events are real.

The city council for Maine's second largest city abruptly votes to buyout the contract of the city administrator, citing disagreement on the direction of the city and calling for a new way forward.

When asked to explain the old direction or what this new direction was, councilors either stumbled to say they didn't know or refused comment at all.

And with modern media, these quotes were not only in print, but uploaded in sound clips to the Internet.

Take a social networking site like Facebook, too. Many young professionals in this community, while posting what they believed to be tragic news of the loss of history, heard reactions from away noting this was just an old mill town in ruins anyway.

And that's a sample of the more polite comments.

The crisis in Lewiston-Auburn as a whole goes well beyond the exit of Bennett and the loss of the Cowan.

This region still lacks a cohesive downtown district offering the amenities that would attract more young professionals and visitors.

As service center communities, there is a constant struggle to hold the line on budgets and keep taxes as reasonable as possible.

Our inland location creates a challenge for access to transportation systems, as the state plans for passenger rail and the future of the interstate highway.

The list could easily go on. Instead, what have those in power been focusing on?

Egos scrapped a plan to create one downtown master plan for both cities. And despite a citywide commission, which I co-chaired, recommending a joint plan be created first, councilors who believed they are much wiser have moved unilaterally to destroy Bates Mill No. 5.

An effort to consolidate back office operations at the respective city halls and lower the local tax burden was abandoned. The commission appointed to study future means to save taxpayer money through consolidation was disbanded.

There were fights over which side of the river should get big-box stores. There was a legal battle to stop a hotel project.

As we've fought with each other over petty issues, the state's long-term plan for passenger rail was rolled out.

Small, sprawling and wealthy coastal communities will be the first to be connected to Portland and Boston, leaving any hope of connecting to Lewiston-Auburn relegated to a "dead-end" as New England seeks other routes to connect to Montreal via New Hampshire or Vermont.

It has been the same old song in this community for too long. There are members of the public that have long had concerns about the petty issues that hold us back.

If that's you, do something about it.

There are members of the business community that rant about the lack of leadership in moving this community to the next level.

If that's you, do something about it.

The rallying cry of the current Lewiston council is for a new direction. I could not agree more.

Let's see if the community rises up by election time this November to provide one — for both sides of the river.

Jonathan LaBonte, of New Auburn, is a columnist for the Sun Journal and an Androscoggin County Commissioner. E-mail: jlabonte08@gmail.com

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Displaying comments, from newest to oldest

Epotvin11's picture
verified

Robert Reed wrote: "As an

Robert Reed wrote:

"As an elected official on a county level, Mr. Labonte would have done more service to his community by writing a more inspired piece to show the people that we could move forward and he wished to be part of theat moving forward."

So tell me Mr. Reed.. where is your inspiration to your constituents?

On nearly a daily basis for the past two years i've read nothing but negativaty below your name in your comments.

So what's your vision to move forward? Ah yes.. you do not have one.. that's another "grey area" for you isn't it.

Rinoblast's picture

If only there was a group of

If only there was a group of elected officials whose purpose was to represent the surrounding towns as one area. We could even name this new unit after the river that runs through the towns. Oh, wait...

DA01's picture

What has Mr. Labonte done as

What has Mr. Labonte done as an elected official? Maybe he should lead by example. It’s easy to talk. It’s tough to make important (sometimes) difficult decisions for the better of the communities. If he doesn't like the current status of the Twin Cities then maybe he should agree with the council that Mr. Bennett was the problem.

Robert61's picture

It's always interesting to

It's always interesting to see one elected official advocating the voters oust another group of elected officials. Perhaps young Mr. Labonte should consider that before speaking or writing. Now on to the heart of my response.

It was the AUBURN city council that disbanded the concept of joint services or consolidation, not LEWISTON. Once Auburn said no, Lewiston had no dance partner, although we continue to have discussions with other communities about shared resources and equipment. Doesn't the column author live in Auburn and as such why an outcry about Lewiston? Why not turn his concerns to the Auburn city council and not point to Lewiston at this time?

As to the concept of downtown and doing things to improve the area, I'm not sure a recession is the appropriate time to spend money we don't have. Even Mr. Labonte admits in his column that there is a real need to hold the line on taxes and spending. The work we do now is to create the strategy and start to implement policy that will help, not hinder that vision. And by strategy I mean a true citizens vision, not that cooked up by two people and fed to the city as if everyone had a common goal.

And shocking that one member of a group that gave a recommendation to save the Bates MIll 5 is upset because that recommendation was not followed. Personally it was an easy decision and one we made by looking at and listening to the engineer reports which deemed the building structurally unstable. If you do not believe it unstable and dangerous then ask yourself - why is the city no longer allowing use of the building for cold storage that helped reduce the ongoing maintenance costs? A small group of people have such an ego in wanting a convention/conference center in that location that they will not see the obvious and turned a blind eye or gave little creedance to the value of the land if the building had been removed. If you don't beleive that, then ask yourself, why so much effort in the report surrounding the conference concept and virtually nothing but lip service to a casino, similar to what Bangor did. They will probably tell you a casino is not the right tool for economic development - but ask them if a conference center propped up by the city with no guarenteed revenue stream is a better option and huge costs to the taxpayer (Colisee)? Who's lacking vision then?

As an elected official on a county level, Mr. Labonte would have done more service to his community by writing a more inspired piece to show the people that we could move forward and he wished to be part of theat moving forward. As an example, instead of talking about a council fiddling while the city burned (thanks for trying to link the mill to our decision) he could have written from another old adage - "from the ashes the Phoenix will arise". That would have been a much better vision for what this community needs right now, and not another Auburn resident taking pot shots at the Lewiston Council. I look forward to the election, even if it proves to be a referendum on what occurred this past week. The fiscal concerns I have raised will still be raised and the taxpayers will have to decide what was mor important to them, one personnel decision or the ability to form policy and budgets for a city struggling to find its identity.

Advertisement

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...