Friday, November 20, 2009 in Lewiston, Maine

Auburn-Lewiston:
Broken clouds, 51.8 °F

Long nights, idle hands in jailhouse

If duct-taping and chokeholds are how Androscoggin County Jail guards treat each other, how do they treat the inmates? Probably better.

The firing, resignation and suspension of three jail guards for late-night pranks is an embarrassment to Androscoggin County and the sheriff's office. Jailhouse surveillance video caught employees acting like idiots, duct-taping a colleague to a chair and rolling man and chair into the elevator, and choking a co-worker until the man became woozy. Both occurred during late-night or early-morning hours.

What this behavior shows, to us, is a lack of professionalism in the jail, as well as a lack of actual work to do during graveyard shifts. The jail administration seems to have a few idle hands on its payroll. And we know what mischief idle hands can come up with.

The surveillance video proves it.

The Androscoggin County Commission was right to uphold the firing of one guard by Sheriff Guy Desjardins. Although the union complained it was unjust, an example must be set that this type of juvenile behavior is intolerable. The jail is a workplace, not an off-hours clubhouse.

Go choke and duct-tape your buddies on your spare time, on your dime, not on that of the public.

At its core, this is a management issue. Jail personnel must have either ignored, or completely disregarded, the possibility of punishment for their actions, otherwise they likely wouldn't have behaved so cavalierly. So, what can be done to fix it?

Our first thought is the same suggestion we've always made: a charter. Let's take Androscoggin County — a relic of the Middle Ages shire town governance — and give it a professional management structure. Too many questions and loopholes in authority now exist.

In the current budget proposal, commissioners have set aside $10,000 for a charter commission. That's a good start. Now,  officials within the county who support a charter — which include Sheriff Guy Desjardins — should put their minds where this money is.

These jail incidents, too, should influence talks on the budget. Taxes to Androscoggin County towns are proposed to increase by 4.24 percent, according to present calculations. Taxpayers will pay almost $10 million to run county operations, a giant chunk of which is the jail.

This money is not well spent if it's paying guards to fool around during the overnight shift. And why should other critical services be given to the county — such as dispatching — if there's video evidence of employees not exactly taking their positions of authority seriously?

To be fair, the incidents involving jail guards could be extreme and unusual. And the county acted wisely to rectify this situation.

Yet the fact remains: the county, top to bottom, needs to put its house in order. We can overlook stupid antics, if we're assured the organization is doing the best job for taxpayers. We aren't.

editorialboard@sunjournal.com


Comments

Old Bill's picture

Old Bill says

Sorry, ed, but you are just as out of line as the sherrif and the commissioners were. Was this unsatisfactory behavior? Yes. Did it truly rise to the level of behavior deserving termination? No. I know Cpl. Gorham to be a dedicated, conscientious worker. The most that should have happened to him is a suspension, with or without pay, and a demotion. But firing him sent the employees the wrong message, one which they have had to contend with for far too long; the sherrif and commissioners just don't give a damn about them. ReaganRepublican I agree with you on your last statement; the people of Androscoggin County need to reconsider Desjardins as sherrif. It all stops at his desk, no one else's. He bears the utlimate responsibility for this. Desjardins MUST GO!
"The democracy will cease to exist when the government takes from those who would work and gives to those who would not." - Thomas Jefferson.

Posted 1 week ago (permalink)

StoshDosh's picture

StoshDosh says

. .i am lost . Were these prison guards male or female , or both ? More information , please :)

Posted 2 weeks ago (permalink)

tron's picture

tron says

All your questions will be answered when we see the video.

Posted 1 week ago (permalink)

veritas's picture

veritas says

ReaganRepublican:

"Employing the most qualified people available?"

Any chance you get what you pay for here????
------------------------------------------
When I was a young Sailor - I drank like a Sailor, fought like a Sailor, and screwed like a Sailor. Now that I am old and wise - I have a few scars, but many fond memories.

Posted 2 weeks ago (permalink)

ReaganRepublican's picture

ReaganRepublican says

The editorial board has made some useful recommendations. But let's not get carried away and lump the entire county public safety division into one mess. Dispatch and the patrol division are largely problem-free. I never have issues with county deputies or county dispatch; I cannot say the same for the local municipality's police departments or the LA 911 center. But the point of the county charter is well-taken. I would suggest that it also include a civilian review board to approve the promotions of personnel within the Sheriff's department, in particular administrative positions. The county commissioners have been hopelessly derelict in this responsibility over the years, rubber stamping recommendations for administrative and supervisory promotions from the Sheriff's office without even a surface review of the candidates who apply. Case in point is the current Chief Deputy Eric Samson, the chief patrol deputy in the division who has never even been to the police academy. Someone in the Sheriff's office thought he was qualified to supervise law enforcement officers with more than a decade of experience and college educations. The county commissioners approved this appointment and thought that was a useful way to spend tax payer money. The internal administration is largely inept as is evidenced by its on going internal problems highlighted by this incident and many others that have never been made public, I am sure. The administration is more concerned with promoting personnel who will protect those secrets rather than make serious changes that will benefit the tax payer. The Sheriff's office has a responsibility to see to it that tax payer money is spent employing the most qualified people available and they don't. Poor supervisors result in poor behavior. But we cannot simply blame the Sheriff. The jail adminstrators also bear some of the responsibility. Oversight is clearly lacking. Is management not up to this task? If they are not, who promoted them? When job performance stoops to this level, clearly there is a problem with the management. This is not the first such public incident regarding bad behavior in the Sheriff's department, in particular the jail. Where is the jail management? Change in the Sheriff's department needs to start with Desjardins, that is true. Perhaps Desjardins needs to take a look at his administration. If he is unwilling to do that, perhaps voters need to reconsider him in the next election.

Posted 2 weeks ago (permalink)

Contests
Radio City Racing
NASCAR fantasy racing at its finest. Weekly prizes. Grand prize is a flat screen TV. Click here to play!
Copyright 2009 Sun Media Group