Our View
So, can you hear ME now?
The suggestion from Jim Miclon, head of the dispatch center in Oxford County, to use land-line telephones instead of cellular phones to call 911 indicates a major problem for Maine. Prevailing, popular technology is making it more difficult to report, and respond to, emergencies.
And we all thought cell phones made our lives easier.
"We have wasted much time in an emergency situation just trying to figure out what town and what service to send when cell phones are used," Miclon said recently. He added, "I have stood in the communications center dispatch room watching and listening to my staff struggling to get caller and location information from cell phone callers."
(This does seemingly contradict what Miclon told us in August, when he said 85 percent of calls into the Oxford County dispatch from cell phones were handled correctly.)
Regardless, when seconds count, confusion or misunderstanding of critical information is intolerable. Miclon deserves credit for saying what many think: Emergency responders, like dispatchers, cannot direct and coordinate responses effectively with cell phone information.
This seems a failure of technology and accountability. Wireless communication providers are supposedly certified as compliant with Federal Communications Commission regulations for triangulating cell phone signals in Maine, and have been since 2005.
Miclon's sentiments — and the bizarre circumstances surrounding the response to a fire on the Dixfield-Carthage border last summer — indicate this compliance is questionable. What good is some arbitrary regulatory compliance if dispatchers cannot find people or places in an emergency?
Hastening this problem is the steady conversion of communications from wired to wireless. Cell phones are ubiquitous and convenient. More than half of 911 calls in Maine now come from cell phones, a figure that has nearly doubled since the year 2000, according to state data.
So, in reporting an emergency, people have become more likely to reach into their pockets for their cell phones, than to spring toward the nearest land-line telephone to call. And among the scores of tourists who visit Maine annually, this percentage is perhaps much higher.
This is a grave concern, as it means those who may know the least about their location or terrain are reporting emergencies through a method that cannot accurately locate them.
When Maine's E-911 system was initiated, it was built around the presence — and dominance — of land-line telephones. This foundation is rapidly becoming outdated, which indicates the need for communications officials and emergency responders to start re-thinking 911.
Miclon's concerns are a call for action. Are more towers the answer? Better technology? What role do wireless firms play, given their curious state of "compliance" with FCC regulations? At some point, confusion over a location will turn tragic. Let's not wait for that happen.
Let's be heard. Now.
Advertisement
Displaying comments, from newest to oldest
verified No one claimed the
No one claimed the technology was perfect... At least they know of the issue and something needs to be done about it. There have been a couple of times when I needed to call 911 using a cell phone. I think what irritated me the most was having to tell someone my name and info and what happened-then had to be transferred to the correct dispatch center. For me, no matter where I was it took the same amount of time for rescuers to get to the scene. This goes hand in hand. Response time is not good enough and cell phone/location is not good/fast enough. However this is the real world-its not like everyone sees on tv (Trauma-Life in the E.R., etc.) I needed direction on how to care for someone who was unresponsive and dispatch hung up with me,"Oh-they'll be there in 20 min." Not good enough!
"Small minds discuss people, Average minds discuss events, Great minds discuss ideas"~E. Roosevelt
. 09.11.17. 10:20 am-ish. i
. 09.11.17. 10:20 am-ish. i never ass u ME . Get an iPhone® . They give 9.11 your locations , i m m e d i a t e l y or OnStar® . It does also . Now on to Fail Point :) http://www.fprestructuring.com
Assuming people no where
Assuming people no where they are at the time of a crisis,doesn't make sense to call information and ask for that towns rescue?You would then go directly to fire or police.I have had two instances in the last two years.One was a fifty five year old man that suffered a heart attack and died.I called 911 from my cell and by the time rescue got there 25 minutes had gone by.My son and myself did C.P.R. all that time.I kept looking at my watch in disbelife.Rescue finally showed up and it was to late.Rescue told me they only got the call 8 minutes prior.That meant the dispatch took too long.This year Ihad a 81 year old neighbor that had mixed draino and later on in the day added bleach to a stuffed up bathroom sink causing a chemical reaction sulfuric acid, putting her into cardiac arest.Idid C.P.R. on her for 20 minutes until rescue showed up.Again 911 cell phones were used for the call.I asked fire and rescue why so long?I got the same response and they in towns 20 miles apart from the other incident.Rescue response was 5 minutes after they recieved.The woman died on the way to the hospital.It's very frustrating and hard to understand at this day and age that we cant do better.Response time is critical as everyone knows.I still wonder if it would be better to call your local fire and police.
verified Many disabled but active
Many disabled but active people depend on cell phones as their only phone because it goes where the caller goes.
Maine needs more towers is an understatement just as ISPs and phone companies need more hardware to handle the growing demand for fast, convenient data transfer.
Within a decade residential
Within a decade residential landline seems likely to be discontinued in very rural areas of the state. However caller identity is supposed to be transmitted by the cell phone carrier with each cell phone call to 911, and if that doesn't happen then that's an issue for the FCC to deal with.
Isn't caller location (not
Isn't caller location (not identity) the issue?
verified Northern Maine has few
Northern Maine has few towers and huge tracts of landmarkless roads. The nearest hospital can be 45 minutes to 2 hours away. In situations when seconds count, "take a left where the old barn used to be" and "if you get to the Griffin farmstead you've gone too far" doesn't really work very well. More towers would take away from the natural surroundings, but that may be what is needed to help triangulate a cell phone and lead emergency workers to an injured person. Would better satilite coverage help? Better tracking equipment for call centers and emergency personel?
verified I've heard of cell phone
I've heard of cell phone companies renting out church steeples (and they pay good money for it) as a cell tower... its discreet and wouldn't 'take away from the natural environment'.
"Small minds discuss people, Average minds discuss events, Great minds discuss ideas"~E. Roosevelt
"This does seemingly
"This does seemingly contradict what Miclon told us in August, when he said 85 percent of calls into the Oxford County dispatch from cell phones were handled correctly."
No it doesn't.
Just because "We have wasted much time in an emergency situation just trying to figure out what town and what service to send when cell phones are used" doesn't mean that the agency wasn't 85% accurate when handling cell phone calls.
Your jab at Miclon wasn't necessary.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Most Popular Today
verified on "P. Nachman: Confidence probably misplaced"
The cost of Medicare fraud
The cost of Medicare fraud today is estimated to be $60Billion for which the Federal Government does little about. That amount is nothing to ignore, especially when $0.38 of every federal dollar spent is borrowed.
While we agree there will be fraud in oBamaCare, we both cannot make assertions to its magnitude since we cannot attempt to measure it at this point.
Perhaps you don’t care about the waste, cost, or fraud with Medicare or evolving oBamaCare, some of us do, particularly if we are paying for it.
Let me reiterate – the Government is has an abysmal track record when it comes to financial responsibility and efficiency, I expect no improvements.
Perhaps that is okay for people receiving the benefit but pays not.
verified on "P. Nachman: Confidence probably misplaced"
Mr. Nachman has a perfect
Mr. Nachman has a perfect right to write whatever he wants, however most papers, including this one, generally lets its readers know any agenda a letter writer may have. Otherwise they should publish them as an opinion piece instead of a LTE. I found it extremely amusing that after revealing only a portion of Mr. Nachman's background, leblanc accuses me of being a xenophobe. The irony of it all.
verified on "Turning back the clock on social care"
you're right, I consider a
you're right, I consider a tax cut of $140 million a year massive, surprisingly, to you that appears to be a pittance.
In order to make comments, you must verify your account.
In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.
Login or create an account here.
Our policy prohibits comments that are:
- Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
- Excessively foul and/or vulgar
- Inappropriately sexual
- Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
- Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
- Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.