Friday, November 20, 2009 in Lewiston, Maine

Auburn-Lewiston:
Clear sky, 44.6 °F

Sheriff to bring proposal for police coverage to Bethel

BETHEL — Oxford County Sheriff Wayne Gallant will meet with selectmen and the Budget Committee on Nov. 23 to share a formal proposal for police coverage for the town.

Selectmen are trying to determine whether it is in the town's best interest to continue operating a police department, or to disband it and contract with the county, Town Manager James Doar said.

"There was a lot of discussion over whether or not, but ultimately, it boiled down to the selectmen wanting to at least hear something formal from the sheriff," Doar said Tuesday.

"There is a cost savings there, and I think they're just going to have to weigh out what the exact services would be, and if the cost savings is worth it," he said.

The matter came up because Doar suspended police Chief Alan Carr on Sept. 25 without publicly stating why. Carr resigned on Oct. 20 for personal reasons, leaving Doar and Sgt. S. R. White to run the Police Department as they had done since Sept. 25.

Prior to Monday night's meeting, Doar gave selectmen a memo containing a draft proposal that Doar said he and Gallant worked out informally. According to Doar's figures, Bethel spends about $313,000 a year to maintain single-officer, 24-hour coverage seven days a week. Switching to county coverage would cost the town $295,000 a year, a savings of $18,000,. according to the proposal.

"I went down to talk to (Gallant) and said, 'Is it even possible? This is what we expect,'" Doar said.

The draft proposal states that the county would provide three deputies — all graduates of the Maine Criminal Justice Academy — to give Bethel police protection 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

That protection includes:

• Patrolling the town.

• Responding to residents' calls for aid and to complaints.

• Enforcing state statutes and local ordinances, and rendering assistance in emergencies.

• Exercising statutory and common-law powers and duties of a sheriff to benefit Bethel.

Additional services would include:

• Providing monthly written reports of activities.

• Sending a representative to selectmen meetings and periodic meetings with Doar, as requested.

• Reports of all complaints received against deputies and the county's response to such complaints.

• Delivering meeting packets as prepared by Doar to individual selectmen.

County coverage services would be provided for one year, with a renewal option of three to five years.

The proposal further states that deputies assigned to Bethel can leave town limits to respond to emergencies in area towns, but must return to Bethel as soon as possible. Prior to permanently assigning or reassigning any deputy from the town, the county would have to consult with Bethel.

The county would provide all equipment being used by deputies covering Bethel, and Bethel, in turn, would sell to the county its police cruisers for $1.

Cruisers covering Bethel would be marked "Oxford County Sheriff's Office — Bethel Patrol."

"This is kind of a hybrid of what I'd want to see, and what the sheriff would want to see," Doar said. "Like selling the cruisers to the sheriff for a dollar is something that he wanted to see, so we threw it out there."

The matter, once decided by selectmen, must go to a town meeting vote.

tkarkos@sunjournal.com


Comments

T says

I thought Reagan Republican's were in favor of a smaller, centralized government and increased local control. Am I wrong ReaganRepublican?

Posted 1 week ago (permalink)

ReaganRepublican's picture

ReaganRepublican says

Don't create a controversy when there isn't any. This would be a decision of the local towns and deputies would be assigned to those towns, or did you not read the article? I am not in favor of preserving a government program, in this case the Bethel PD, or any small PD for that matter, because the entrenched political establishment or a comfortable police chief in that town wants to preserve it at the expense of the taxpayer. When the same service can be provided cheaper and just as effectively, then it should be done. This is not a federal or a state mandate, this is the citizens of Bethel deciding to contract, not being forced to contract, with the sheriff's department for the same service at a lower price. This is local control. The citizens of Bethel can also choose not to renew the contract. Doesn't get much more "local control" than that, does it? By the way, these would all be ideas that Reagan would approve of...perhaps you should read his writings. Reagan would be against the government walking in and taking over against the will of the citizens...much like they have every other program once entrusted to the locals. I might also submit that the existence of the sheriff's office predates the municipal police in American history.

Posted 1 week ago (permalink)

T says

"This would be a decision of the local towns" ...Yes, to hand over local control to a larger, more centralized government.

"The citizens of Bethel can also choose not to renew the contract." ... It's like any other bureaucracy. Once the town is locked into a five year contract, it would be next to impossible to change the system, much like what we have in Augusta.

"When the same service can be provided cheaper and just as effectively, then it should be done" ...That's what they always say in Washington, D.C.

You don't sound like a Reagan Republican. You sound like a "tax & spend" liberal willing to send local control out of town.

Posted 1 week ago (permalink)

ReaganRepublican's picture

ReaganRepublican says

Give me a break, you don't know anything about me...I am FAR from a tax and spend liberal and if you can say that based on my post you have NO understanding of what I just said. Better to continue to overpay for a PD? Better we tax the citizens of Bethel to spend for PD services that they could have cheaper in the SO? And if you knew ANYTYHING about Reagan you would know that he said that the first rule of bureaucracy is to preserve itself and he was against preserving government agencies just for the sake of preserving them (in this case Bethel PD). You must have missed where I said this is not a federal or state mandate. Nobody is forcing the citizens of Bethel to contract with Oxford SO. This is the citizens of Bethel being provided with a cheaper alternative...that is a competitive bidding process. You don't get more "free-market" than that. If the Bethel PD cannot do it cheaper than the county, don't the citizens of Bethel have a right to decide? This is not like Social Security where the government has taken my money without my consent for the pyramid scheme they call retirement, or what they are about to do with health care. You have government mandates confused with contracts. Mandates are not contracts. I would love to be able to say to the U.S. government that I don't like how they are handling my social security taxes and get a refund, wouldn't you? Contracts expire, mandates don't...especially the federal and state kind. This isn't even close to that. The citizens of Bethel get to CHOOSE. Control is not going "out of town" when the citizens of Bethel get to decide. That IS local control. It is Bethel money that pays for it, it is the Bethel citizens who will want it (if they choose), and the contracted deputy doesn't leave town limits except for emergencies. If they don't want it, it doesn't happen. Federal and state mandates don't give you a choice, it happens whether they want it or not. They force it on you, do it more expensively and less efficiently, and tell you tough luck while still sending you the bill (see above social security example). BIG difference.

Posted 1 week ago (permalink)

ReaganRepublican's picture

ReaganRepublican says

Excellent idea for the town of Bethel. Perhaps some of smaller towns in Androscoggin County should consider contracting their police services to the Sheriff's department, too. Problems in the jail notwithstanding (which is now run by the state), the Sheriff's office does not seem to be experiencing any problems with their patrol responsibilities. I, for one, would like to see a greater county law enforcement presence. Sabattus, Mechanic Falls, and Livermore Falls should approach Desjardins on this. There are real savings to be had and it apparently works well in Poland.

Posted 1 week ago (permalink)

Contests
Radio City Racing
NASCAR fantasy racing at its finest. Weekly prizes. Grand prize is a flat screen TV. Click here to play!
Copyright 2009 Sun Media Group