Snowe vows to continue work on health care reform

LEWISTON — U.S. Sen. Olympia Snowe, R-Maine, said Thursday she will continue to work for health care reform, though she may not vote for the legislation.

Russ Dillingham/Sun Journal

Russ Dillingham/Sun Journal United States Senator from Maine, Olympia Snowe, talks with the Sun Journal editorial board about health care Thursday morning at the Sun Journal.

Russ Dillingham/Sun Journal

Russ Dillingham/Sun Journal United States Senator from Maine, Olympia Snowe, talks with the Sun Journal editorial board about health care Thursday morning at the Sun Journal.

"I'm going to continue to make all the improvements that I can, within the capacity of my position, and whether I can support it in the end or not," she said during a meeting with the Sun Journal editorial board.

"There are a number of issues that are still at stake for me on this, beyond the public option, and I am going to continue to work through those issues," she said.

The U.S. House of Representatives passed a health care bill last weekend. Senate Democratic leaders are now merging bills from two committees into one piece of legislation for the full Senate's vote.

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nevada, has said he expects the Senate bill to include a version of the so-called "public option," a government-run health care plan in which states could choose to participate.

Snowe said that despite public opinion polls showing support for a public option in Maine and nationwide, she believes it's not the best way to reform the system.

"It seems to me, it's more appropriate to allow the private sector to demonstrate it has the capacity to offer affordable rates under a restructured market," she said. But she understands why people mistrust the private insurance industry, which has continued to raise premiums by double-digit percentages each year.

Under the reforms included in both House and Senate bills, insurance companies would no longer be able to refuse coverage to people for pre-existing conditions or to be charged different rates depending on their gender or age, or to place lifetime caps on coverage, Snowe said.

She continues to support a "trigger," which would kick in if private insurance companies fail to meet coverage and affordability standards established by the federal government, she said. It's a proposal she's been pushing since the spring.

"The incentive of the threat of a trigger could be sufficient enough to prompt them to offer affordable plans and be very competitive," she said.

The coverage that would be triggered if insurance companies failed to comply with the standards would not be government-run. It would be a nonprofit with negotiated rates, not government-set rates.

Snowe believes Sen. Reid will have a tough time rounding up the 60 votes needed to move his bill forward. Many moderate senators, Republicans and Democrats, have aired concerns about the proposals that have been made so far, some even have suggested that the bill should be completely re-written.

Snowe, who spent months working daily on crafting the bill passed by the Senate Finance Committee, said she welcomes all suggestions for improving the legislation.

"It's so important; if anyone has a viable alternative, I say, 'I welcome it,'" she said. "If someone has an instant solution, I welcome it. If they can achieve the same goals we're attempting to accomplish, like in the finance bill, making a good-faith effort, then fine. But you can never get to a point in a committee process where you're ever going to get a perfect bill."

She will continue on the path to improving the bill, despite the difficulties, she said.

"I take a lot of criticism for being where I am," she said. "I have to sort of balance that all out, with my obligations to my constituents and so on, sorting out the need here in this state and across this country, finding good policy that works."

rmetzler@sunjournal.com

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Displaying comments, from newest to oldest

Mike04938's picture

. .Hmm. .let's see : 6 2 F ,

. .Hmm. .let's see : 6 2 F , , has health insurance already and will collect social security when she retires soon , married to former Maine Governor John R. McKernan Jr. Who am i describing ? Sen. Olympia Snowe :)

RpsNoMore's picture

"who is behind this health

"who is behind this health industry controling OLIGARCHY?"

Health care insurers were given a road map for abuse. They were allowed to spiral health care costs and sidestep anti-trust laws thanks to Congressional Republicans.

That health insurers were allowed to increase costs by over 300% since 1995 with more on the way if a strong reform bill does not pass is evidence of legislative malfeasance.

Also, limits need to be placed on the ways in which health care insurance companies are allowed to spend money to influence congress and public opinion. Some estimates place their ongoing campaign to stop a public option at $1 million a day. That's $1 million a day from the pockets of hard working Americans, many of whom were denied the coverage they paid for thanks to these same companies denying claims.

Winterbear98's picture

COMMON SENSE

COMMON SENSE
YOUR 100 PERCENT RIGHT

RpsNoMore's picture

The IGNORANT may scream

The IGNORANT may scream "Socialism!" at every turn, but they're basically children playing in a sandbox.

If they were smart, they would realize that OLIGARCHY, or rule by the wealthy at the expense of all, is what has been going on in practice with health care in America.

But they aren't smart so they'll just scream "Socialism!" and likely not even realize that CAPITALISM is NOT a monopoly by health care insurance companies. Any part of a capitalistic economy that is allowed to erode all other parts, tips the entire system to OLIGARCHY which is, on balance, possibly more damaging than socialism because there is no restraint whatsoever. As those who are in control by virtue of their enormous wealth, gained thanks to the unfair exploitation of the many, gain more wealth the very nature of Democracy buckles under the weight of economic injustice.

This is where we have reached: OLIGARCHY that seeks to preserve itself by convincing the most ignorant among all Americans that what would benefit them most is in fact the thing that will drive them into the sea.

Sick

robert's picture

RpsNoMore...so you are the

RpsNoMore...so you are the ALL MIGHTY intellect here...thank you for bestowing your wisdom onto our plebian existance. OK smart guy...by your own inference you seem to be "in the know" could you SPECIFICALLY and not in broad-stroke fashion let the rest of us "uneducated" people know who is behind this health industry controling OLIGARCHY? You see what I'm noticing is a government that has taken over 2 of the 3 big automakers, Wall street, and has its eyes on health care. So it would appear the power is in the hands of a small faction called the White House. Oh I can't wait until class begins and you can teach us all the wisdom you have in that head of yours. I just hope you don's sound like charlie Brown's teacher though.

dandee84's picture
verified

What happened to Obama's

What happened to Obama's promise of making affordable insurance coverage available to every AMERICAN CITIZEN that wanted it? This bill makes it mandatory I buy insurance or pay a hefty fine whild illegals continue to get a free ride either way. This plan wont take effect until well into his second term if American's get suckered in again and give him another bite at the apple.

Obama has beeen feeding us a line on N1H1 vaccine for a year now and still doing so. How many of you have sick kids at home who were promised vaccine the first week of school and it still isn't here? Only 1 in 6 children has been able to get vaccine. The adult population is in worse shape with many healthcare and emergency service people unable to get vaccine. Today we find Americans are going to be short millions of doses again this week, but not to worry this will be a long flu season and they will get to everyone eventual. Our young adults, those most at risk have given up trying to get vaccine and only 16% are trying now. YES, MR. PRESIDENT IT IS GOING TO BE A VERY LONG FLU SEASON OUT HERE ON MAIN STREET AMERICA FOR AMERICAN CITIZEN'S.

Obama has not kept a single promise, more troops are being deployed to Afghanistan and Iraq everyday we are not getting out, which was his adamit pledge. McCain was tauted as a warmonger for being honest and saying it would be one step at a time for the safty of our troups and we would not be going back to finish an unfinished job again. Well Obama sure did not keep his promise.
If we could only return to common sense...

clakdaddy's picture

I am not sure why the public

I am not sure why the public option is such a bad idea. If the insurance companies are so great, why don't we keep thing the way they are? We have had failed banks, failed investment companies, & failed large businesses and the so called "experts" say we can't let that happen, so we bail them out. Who is going to bail me out? Who is going to pay for my medical plan? We gave the insurance companies plenty of chances to fix the problem, lets give the public option a chance before telling everyone it is a bad idea. How do we really know what will happen? Maybe if some insurance companies fail, the others will find a better solution. It seems to me its all about the $$$.

DR's picture

I think Olympia's made a

I think Olympia's made a couple good attempts at bridging party lines and exercising compromise in order to pass legislation. Nobody who isn't willing to compromise, and work with others to find solutions, belongs in a public office. It's not ALL ABOUT YOU. It's all about EVERYONE. It's time for politicans to stop talking, talking, talking and DO something. The United States would not exist today if the same cowards were sitting in Congress then, as now.

I'm disgusted that this country still doesn't have a comprehensive health plan to cover ALL Americans. We've given billions of tax dollars to other countries to help their economies and their citizens (among other things), but we don't have a national health care plan to help our own people in need. It's unbelievable and dishonorable.

Sure, if you're an illegal immigrant you can go to any hospital and get treatment. But if you're a citizen working your tail off and lose your health insurance along with your job, or can't get health insurance because you have a "pre-existing health condition", oh, too bad for you. Go find a place to die and don't let the door hit you on your way out. God forbid we prevent the holy insurance companies from making enormous profits. After all, America is all about satisfying corporate greed, right? Sure seems to be, these days.

All those Senators and Representatives who are behaving like self-centered, entitled brats need to stop focusing on their insignificant little political kingdoms and do what's right for the citizens of this country. Which is not to listen to the equally bratty whinings about "it might cost me something!" but to do instead what is truly necessary for the health and well-being of all citizens.

Susan2's picture

This RINO needs to be put

This RINO needs to be put out to pasture! She is uninformed and senile.
We have about 5 more years of her mouth and treason within her suppossid party.
Collins is gone in about a year. I'm embarrassed by these two Leftist Bobsie Twins.
May she follow Obama right into the dumper.

Liberals are highschool, and Conservatives are college.
I was a Liberal and then I got knowledge, now I'm an Independent that's for the gays, abortion and AMERICA.!

lead dog's picture

Susan, you should check

Susan, you should check facts before you submit wrong information. We reelected Susan Collins last year when she ran against Tom Allen. We are stuck with her for 5 more years. Snowe's last campaign was in 2006. We will have a chance to replace her in 3 years.

kmysnyk's picture

listening you need to get

listening
you need to get more knowledge....

mad dad's picture

All federal employees have a

All federal employees have a open season period once each year where they can choose insurance coverage from a list of programs and coverages from various insurance companies. I think the insurance companies should be required to furnish these same programs and coverages to the general public at the same RATES as they offer to the federal employees. There are other adjustments to the present system that should be addressed, but I think this is the big one.

BillTheGorilla's picture
verified

She is not a Republican she

She is not a Republican she is BIG BUSINESS !! She could care less!! She has GREAT HEALTH CARE, SHE is Filthy RICH She does not care about Mainers VOTE THE OLD LADY OUT her time has come and gone !! LOOK around everyone that does not already pay has better coverage than us that do!! Whats wrong with that picture ?? What we have makes a few Extremely RICH and the Heck with the rest of US never before has this happened in our great country !!! Its time for a change and even though the perposed plan is flawed its better than whaat we have now!! It seems we all have forgotten the WE in this here U.S.A. !! Stop the arguing and both sides come together and find common ground ! Otherwise unless your a millionaire....we loose !~

JohnnyP's picture

"She is not a Republican she

"She is not a Republican she is BIG BUSINESS !!"
-That's like saying, "She is not a women, she's a female!"

skippy's picture
verified

While there is some good in

While there is some good in the proposed legislation in Congress taking money away from seniors (Medicare) and a government run insurance plan are two reasons to pray for its failure. What has the government run according to promises in its history. Social Security was supposed to be invested for our benefit, not used to run the governments day to day business as it has been. Look at anything else the government has operated and see the cost and lack of public benefits. Senator Snowe is to be commended for the position of influence she had on that committee. She is a sincere politician who is doing the best possible for Maine. As to the bill that came out of the House, no one including Rep. Pelosi expects it to be enacted. Taxes and mail are two of the items with the highest increases in costs to us; do you want to add insurance to tht list?

thehotoneisinthehouse's picture

This is just smoke to cover

This is just smoke to cover up for the RNC of do nothing but vote NO

The Right has been "working"on this for decades and they keep voting against all that try to reform and bring cost down.

Winterbear98's picture

hospital costs have gone

hospital costs have gone crazy? 12 dollars for a asprin. people have to understand health care cost have never been higher something has to be done.I certainly dont think takeing 400 billion out of medicare for the old to pay for it MAKES ANY SENSE GOVERMENT HEALTHCARE YA RIGHT WHERE ARE HINI SHOTS CHANGE WHAT CHANGE OBAMA

the_poorman's picture

She better hurry up and come

She better hurry up and come up with something that will work because all her ideas so far have been fail.

Any problem that can't be solved with taxcuts, republicans pretend doesn't exist.

fixit001's picture

For over 150 years Insurance

For over 150 years Insurance was cheap and affordable in 25+ years the cost has soared to unbelivable hights!!! For over 150 years political contrbutions were considered reasonable and for 25+ years the coffers of our political candidates have soared to unbelivable hights. And for 150 years OUR CONSTITUTION was REVERED BY OUR ELECETED OFFICALS and in 25+ years the constitution is nothing but a hinderance to our political members. DOES ANYONE SEE A CAUSE AND EFFECT HERE???? ALL LOBBISTS MUST BE BANNED AND IF REFUSAL IMPRISONED FOR LIFE AS WELL AS ALL POLITICAL MEMBERS WHO ARE ON THE TAKE!!!!!

Why was this healthcare bill brought forth in the first case??? for us hell no the political Leeches are having a much,much harder time getting payola because companies are stressed so what would spike thier coffers but this so called reform which in the end will be bussiness as normal this is all about thier pockets not our problems!!!

rstonge's picture
verified

cranky yankee, I take it

cranky yankee, I take it from your post you do not like the fact the insurance companies are making a profit. As a percentage of their revenue, what would you consider to be excessive? Are profits 2% of revenue excessive? Is 6% of revenue to excessive? What is excessive?

You seem to think that Republicans are not in favor of increased competition, actually it is the Democrats that are opposing that. The Obama Administration does not want to allow insurance companies to sell across state lines.

As for the public option be competition, that would not be exactly fair competition. Insurance companies are required to remain solvent, where the government option can print more money if they don't have enough. The public option will eventually destroy the public insurance industry and personally, I don't want my insurance in the hands of a government pencil pusher.

cranky yankee's picture

Yeah, Olympia, exactly what

Yeah, Olympia, exactly what "improvements" has the RNC brought to the table? Let the insurance companies fix the problem? Yeah, uh-huh. And I have some waterfront property in Florida I'll sell you too. Can the Republicans, with a straight face, honestly say they think that the industry that caused a big part of the problem is going to fix it? Exactly what incentive do they have to fix it? Increased competition? Nope. Increased regulation? Nope. A conscience? Nope. So then what exactly do you think it will take to "inspire" the insurance grinch's to clean up their collective acts?

And none of the discussion is talking about the other 60% of the problem-the cost of health care. We have a lot of wonderful, new technologies, miracle drugs, shiny new medical centers, much of it paid for with govenrment grants and other subsidies, so exactly when is the medical industry going to be held accountable? The Republicans say tort reform and caps on damage awards will solve the problem. In other words, if a doctor screws up and a patient is maimed, or dies, as a result, then that patients life, and quality of life, is now worth what? Pennies on the dollar? Hope that never happens to a Republican, as I'm sure his/her team of lawyers would be working on an eight-figure settlement in a New York minute!

The whole system is broken. The average person cannot afford to pay for basic medical care out of pocket, let alone for medications or any operations. In times past, people could afford, for the most part, any medical procedure they needed, however, as our technology improved, access to that level of care diminished. In this day and age, in the United States, that's shameful.

robert's picture

OK cranky...I've had to

OK cranky...I've had to force myself to read you conjecture-ladened drivel written in such broad strokes that I am calling you out. Where do you get the idea that all the "wonderful, new technologies, miracle drugs, shiny new medical centers, much of it paid for with govenrment grants and other subsidies,"? I'm thinking it is your perception and not reality. You make it sound like there is a plethera of ill-trained doctors waiting to "screw up"...You need to stop watching conspiracy theory type dramas. I personally know of 3 doctors who had to close their practices due to the cost of medical malpractice insurance. There are two other doctors who have closed their practice and switched to a new trend that is happening all over the nation, they are doctors who come to your house and do not accept health insurace only cash. Their prices are 60% less than when they had an office. Its amazing that there is such cost savings once the malpractice insurance is removed??? It seems the people who are in favor of government run health care are looking for free health care. People free is never cheap! Some think its about time the US trys to have nationalized health care...How has it worked in Canada, the UK and any other country that has it? Why do you think the politicians of those countries come to the US for health care? If you want to try something why not do so that doesn't put the US tax payers on the hook for ever? i say ever because many of the social programs enacted were sold to the public as temporary measures to see if they work. Those programs have been a financial albatross around our necks. Why not allow people to cross state lines and shop for health insurances anywhere? Why not attempt tort reform. My father was an attorney and he was in favor of this because he said it would drastically reduce the cost to the medical profession. There are so many procedures a hospital must do to avoid a law suit. How does penalizing people 12% of your income if you don't have health insurance make sense? How much would it cost the American tax payer if you allow people to cross state borders to buy health insurance? I say not much if anything...Now how much do you think it will cost if Congress passes nationalized health care? ....probably our economy and if continued it will create such a polarizing force it will divide our great nation and could lead to its demise. As a very wise man said:

You cannot help the poor ... by destroying the rich.

You cannot strengthen the weak ... by weakening the strong.

You cannot bring about prosperity ... by discouraging thrift.

You cannot lift the wage earner up ... by pulling the wage payer down.

You cannot further the brotherhood of man ... by inciting class hatred.

You cannot build character and courage ... by taking away men's initiative and independence.

You cannot help men permanently ... by doing for them what they could
and should do for themselves.

-- Abraham Lincoln

Advertisement