Mainers to vote — again — on casino referendum

OXFORD (AP) — Backers of a proposed $165 million casino and resort in western Maine are betting the sour economy and high jobless rate will spur voters to approve a project they say will create well over 1,000 jobs and pump tens of millions of dollars into the economy.

Robert F. Bukaty/Associated Press

Floyd Thayer, owner of the Big Rig truck repair and chairman of the Oxford Board of Selectmen, poses at his business in Oxford. Thayer is hoping voters approve a casino that would be built in Oxford.

Voters two years ago rejected by a margin of 55-45 a similar referendum calling for a $180 million resort and casino in this town of about 4,000 an hour north of Portland.

This time around, there's a new set of homegrown investors who are confident that voters will give the OK for Maine's first casino with black jack, craps and other table games, in addition to slot machines.

People are hungry for jobs and economic opportunity, said Jim Boldebook, one of the investors in Black Bear Entertainment LLC, which would own the casino. The unemployment rate in Oxford County was 10.6 percent in July, much higher than the 7.9 percent unadjusted statewide rate.

"When you cross into Maine you see that big sign that says, 'Maine, the way life should be,'" Boldebook said. "Well, I have news for you. When you've got 70 percent of the people in western Maine who are on either Medicare or Medicaid, when you've got 22 percent of the people living on some kind of general assistance, I ask the question, 'Is that the way life should be?'"

Maine is home to Hollywood Slots in Bangor, which has 1,000 slot machines but no table games, which was made possible through a statewide referendum that voters approved in 2003.

But Mainers have rejected three other referendums since 2003 calling for casinos with slot machines, table games, hotels, restaurants and other amenities. There's no reason to think the outcome will be different this year, said Dennis Bailey, executive director of CasinosNo!

"It's not economic development. It takes as many jobs out of the economy as it will add, and probably more," Bailey said. "We aren't going to be the next Foxwoods. We aren't going to be the next Atlantic City, and who would want to be? It'll just take money away from local economies and regional economies and put it into the pockets of slick casino operators."

Question 1 on the Nov. 2 ballot asks: "Do you want to allow a casino with table games and slot machines at a single site in Oxford County, subject to local approval, with part of the profits going to specific state, local and tribal programs?"

Black Bear Entertainment is comprised of Boldebook, the owner of Creative Broadcast Concepts ad agency in Biddeford; Steve Barber, former president and CEO of Barber Foods in Portland, and his wife; Bob Bahre, former owner of Oxford Plains Speedway and the founder of the New Hampshire International Speedway, and his business partner son, Gary; Rob Lalley, co-owner of the Mt. Abram ski resort in Greenwood; and Suzanne and Rupert Grover, who owns a precision metal drilling company in Norway.

As in past elections, talk of a gambling hall has ignited strong feelings.

The idea of a casino just a few miles from her Otisfield home has prompted Zizi Vlaun to organize a political action committee to oppose the plan. Black Bear Entertainment says it has several sites under consideration for the casino on or near Route 26, but it won't divulge the exact locations.

If a casino comes to town, area restaurants will close, retail sales will go down, unemployment will go up, drunk driving will increase, domestic abuse will rise, Vlaun said. She quotes billionaire investor Warren Buffett, who once called gambling a "tax on ignorance."

"This will not solve our problems," Vlaun said. "It will create problems. It's a short-tem fix for bad long-term problems."

Another coalition that includes Pennsylvania-based Penn National Gaming Inc., the owner of Hollywood Slots, has formed a political action committee in opposition to the referendum.

But many people along Route 26 will tell you most folks in this neck of the woods want a casino for the jobs.

A study by a University of Maine economics professor estimated that the gambling operations alone would require 879 full- and part-time employees, and the resort with its hotel, restaurants and conference center would need still more workers. The study was commissioned by Black Bear Entertainment.

The casino and resort would generate $126.7 million in gambling revenues and at least $60.9 million in taxes for the state each year, and casino visitors would spend $51.3 million in area restaurants and lodging facilities, the study said.

Evan Thurlow, 85, is no gambler, but he likes those numbers.

The region has been hurt in recent times by the loss of housing manufacturers, a woolen mill, wood-products plants and other businesses, he said.

Busloads of Mainers with wallets full of money regularly travel to the Foxwoods casino in Connecticut to try their hand at gambling, he said.

"If they're going to gamble, the money might as well stay here in the state," Thurlow said as he packed green peppers into cardboard boxes at the Crestholm Farm Stand.

The Oxford Board of Selectmen has given its unanimous endorsement to the project. But it may be a tougher sell elsewhere. Voters in 12 of Maine's 16 counties rejected the 2008 casino proposal.

"I have a feeling it'll pass this time," said Chairman Floyd Thayer. "People are finally opening their eyes that we need jobs."

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Comments

Sandra2's picture

oj, is that a red herring?

oj, is that a red herring? you really don't think Main street in Lewiston can handle another 1,000 cars a day, when it already handles over 20,000. and they would be off peak at that?

You'd rather pay tax dollars to upgrade 20 miles of RTE 26?

Manufacturing or retail in Mill 5 would bring a lot more people and they would all be peak hour drivers.

eddie's picture

you must have something better then that

rt 26 is already being upgraded and the oxford resort will pump sufficent dollars into the Oxofrd municipal budget to take care of any local road issues.

ojhuig's picture

huh?

I don't know what you think you are asking, but you need to look up "red herring". I lived in Ellsworth and on MDI for many years. Trust me, you don't want tourist traffic mixing in with the rest of us trying to get to work. One thousand might as well be ten thousand, for all the hassle it will cause. bring them out route 26 where they have clear sailing and plenty of parking.

mbthedragon's picture

The big problem with the

The big problem with the Lewiston site is the people connected to it. Non Starving Monstrosity and his group would make anyone think more than twice.

WideStanceRepublican's picture

Why?

Gambling should not be the way we stimulate the regional economy. Poor people throwing away their savings just some schlubs can deal cards and pour drinks is a poor alternative to training people to work in various industries which could prosper in this area, such as biofuels and wind power.

ojhuig's picture

I was against it last time

I thought it was dishonest to vote for any casino that didn't have the Indians involved, because they asked first. But now I have heard they don't even want it anymore, since it has to be run by an out of state company anyway to make it viable.

ojhuig's picture

living in Auburn

I'd love to see something done with Bates 5, but traffic on Main Street is already a mess. There still isn't enough parking. Casinos belong out in the open where the buses will not be a problem.

123abc's picture

Give it to Oxford

I agree with previous comments about the casino location being better in Oxford than the Lewiston-Auburn area (and I'm an Auburn resident who would love to go to the casino.) The roads could not handle additional traffic on the roads in Lewiston because they have some of the most difficult traffic patterns I've ever seen (including Portland). Everything is a one-way and if you miss your turn, you have to go around the block, down narrow streets, dodging people walking out into the streets from between cars. And it really isn't as easy to get to the downtown area from the Turnpike as you might think, especially with all the changes in the on and off ramps.

If a casino was built in Lewiston, you'd have this nice little gem amongst a lot of dilapidated buildings in the area, but have you seen what they'd like to build in Oxford? That picture is beautiful and would look great in that area. And it would bring business to other areas, including Lewiston/Auburn, since the nearest decent shopping centers, restaurants, and hotels are there and only 20 minutes or so away from Oxford.

eddie's picture

When is the Penn Coalition going to get exposed!

I am all for the Oxford Casino, and if they want to vote in one in Lewiston a year later, well its a free country, but what i am opposed to is what i see as a concerted effort of the press statewide in giving Penn National and Company a free pass on this so-called coaltion. The "coalition" is nothing but a power move by an out of state billion dollar corportation trying to keep its gaming monoploy in Maine and at the same time set the ground work to take over all casino gaming in Maine in the future. The did it in Ohio, they are under investegation for referendum interference in Maryland by the state gaming commission and attorney genrals office and they will do it in Maine if they are not stopped. They hold up the horsemen, tribes and maine fairs as shields for them, when they could care less. By the way those groups stand to gain almost 7 million from the Oxford resort if passed. Don't let this sham being purpotrated on the Maine voters take hold...vote yes on 1

Hmmm's picture

Have you BEEN to Oxford

Have you BEEN to Oxford lately? Do you live in Oxford? The areas they were talking about putting the casino last time are just sitting there undeveloped and have been for years. It's not like they are tearing down a gorgeous family friendly park with lots of trees and walking trails.

If L/A is struggling, it has nothing to do with Oxford or the casino they want to put there. As a matter of fact, most people in the Oxford Hills area and whole county for that matter have to travel to L/A or Portland for most stores and restaurants. We have been adding to your cities' businesses for decades.

I drive through Lewiston/Auburn pretty regularly. Traffic there sucks. I don't think the infrastructure handle it any better than Oxford at this point. You may want a casino in your area, but so do we. We want businesses, jobs and opportunity here too. If you think L/A is struggling, come spend a week in Oxford and take a good look around.

sandra2's picture

Get real. This is not about

Get real. This is not about economic development. Its about tearing up 80 acres of land in Oxford to make a ton more money for a bunch of rich people. Unless you own a gas station on route 26, you won't see a penny of this money.

The LA casino benefits two existing and struggling cities and is next to 95 and can handle the traffic.

These people haven't even told us where exactly they plan to build.

eddie's picture

what are your folks just doing it for the fun of it

Please get real, you make it sound like the Lewiston Group are a non profit organisation. What would not suprise me right now is if they were already trying to flip the deal for a quick buck.....however the Oxford proposal is up first and personally i feel it is a much better deal for Maine then the Lewiston Proposal....but be that as it may.....vote for Oxford this year and vote for lewiston next year, voting for Oxford does not stop the Lewsiston vote from going forward. I say bird in hand, bird in hand.

candiceanne's picture

Are you really going to throw away another opportunity?

Are you really going to allow petty jealousies and greed stop yet another economic development project and keep jobs out of Maine? New Hampshire, Massachusetts, and Connecticut are going to be laughing all the way to the bank, not to mention the Pennsylvania-based Penn National Gaming Inc. known in Maine as Hollywood Slots shuffling money from Bangor right out of the state. Keep voting NO folks so nothing gets built anywhere in the state to help the whole state. This is what keeps Maine the number 1 for federally subsidized getting $1.79 back for every $1 paid in federal income taxes. With the economy being what it is, how much longer do you think the fed will be able to keep taking from others to send here? Maine has 4 times the national average of nonprofits but definitely not 4 times the population. Those nonprofits depend on grants from the federal government, from private and public foundations and individuals to survive mostly outside the state. That money is drying up, too. You cannot keep expecting handouts and the outside world has come to understand aid sent to Maine is not a hand up. Hand ups are used to change conditions so help is no longer needed. Maine keeps blocking change. Are you really going to block this opportunity also?

sandra2's picture

We already said No to Oxford.

We already said No to Oxford. Its time to give Lewiston-Auburn a chance.

Those 2800 jobs would do a LOT more good in our downtown.

An Oxford Casino will kill Feel, Gritty's and Fishbones, people from LA will be going to Oxford and eating there rather than our downtown.

It needs to be in a city with the infrastructure to handle it, like Bangor.

ojhuig's picture

that's snobbish

They were first and they can handle it.

sthistle's picture
staff

Poll added

Hi All,
We've added a simple, non-scientific, poll above on this ballot question. Please feel free to vote.
Scott

t's picture

"When you've got 70 percent

"When you've got 70 percent of the people in western Maine who are on either Medicare"

So?

Maine's population is aging. It's one of the oldest in the country. Mr. Boldebook makes it sound like being 65 and on Medicare is a bad thing.

Mr. Boldebook, are you going to wave your Medicare benefit when you turn 65?

ojhuig's picture

true!

It has reached a point in this country where health care is a guaranteed right for poor people, the severely disabled, and the elderly. Why not the rest of us, especially since we are the ones paying in! If you work and have insurance, you pay for health care twice.

what if's picture

The elderly

have paid into the programs all their lives as well.

ojhuig's picture

agreed

Absolutely they have paid in. I didn't mean to imply they hadn't. My point is that everyone should be entitled to health care, just by virtue of being American.

Hal's picture

All For One, One For ALL....

But you must unerstand that what happens to Oxford is going to happen to Auburn, Lewiston and all its surrounding communities. The advantages as well as disadvantages of a casino in Oxford will be felt for many miles around.

ojhuig's picture

let them decide for themselves

As an Auburn resident, I don't feel comfortable voting on a casino for Oxford. Do we want Oxford County deciding what we should do in Androscoggin?

eddie's picture

you should not feel that way

Right now this is our only system to deal with casino gaming in Maine. You should not feel uncomfortable, just remeber the Oxford community and munipal leaders are behind the project and they could use your vote as well as Andoscoggin County voters.

ojhuig's picture

I agree

If it seems like the majority of my friends in Oxford county want it, I will help them out with a vote. I just don't think it should be up to me.

my view's picture
verified

YES

YES

Advertisement

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...