Public hearing set on extending Rumford wind moratorium

RUMFORD — Selectmen on Thursday night voted 5-0 to hold a public hearing Nov. 18 on whether to extend the six-month moratorium on wind energy development.

Terry Karkos/Sun Journal

Rumford Town Manager Carlo Puiia, left, reads Maine's legal definition of a moratorium at Thursday night's selectmen's meeting as Selectman Mark Belanger listens.

The move followed Tuesday's defeat by voters of a proposed wind ordinance that was widely believed to ban such projects.

The hearing is set for 6 p.m. Thursday, Nov. 18, followed by a selectmen's meeting at 7 p.m. to decide whether to recommend extending the moratorium.

It ends Saturday, Nov. 27, Chairman Brad Adley told fellow board members, Town Manager Carlo Puiia and a crowd of about 35 people.

When Selectman Mark Belanger asked about the time period, Puiia said it could be extended up to 180 days, “if that's your choice.”

Selectman Greg Buccina asked Puiia to define “moratorium,” which Puiia did by reading a definition from a Maine law book.

“In this case, you could not permit the construction of a wind energy facility within that moratorium,” Puiia said of Rumford.

Buccina said he read a different definition and thought that is how it should be interpreted.

“Moratorium in Webster's dictionary says, 'All activity shall cease,' and that certainly hasn't been the case in my opinion,” Buccina said.

“What is the reason for having a moratorium? Is it to benefit our citizens to make informed decisions or is it to, I mean, it just seems there's a lot of lobbying being done, a lot of paid advertisements, and I just think that's not what should be happening while the moratorium is in place.”

Belanger quickly responded, telling Buccina, “No. 1, you can't stop people from talking, you can't stop people from advertising, you just can't stop that.”

“A moratorium was basically to prevent permitting until we adopted something. That's all,” Belanger said. “Not that you can't talk about it, not that you can't lobby something. I mean, we're in America.”

Buccina said he is aware of that, but doesn't believe wind power developer First Wind LLC of Boston should be buying land or lobbying Rumford residents during a moratorium.

Earlier this year, First Wind proposed building up to 12 turbines for more than $60 million on Black Mountain and adjacent North and South Twin mountains.

Belanger then said both pro- and anti-wind factions lobbied for and against the ordinance, before speaking his mind about what he called “false advertising” by a pro-wind ordinance group.

“The Wind Education Committee paid for an advertisement that was very misleading to the public, stating we had voted to accept the (ordinance), which we did not — you guys voted to put it on the ballot — and that the Planning Board voted to accept the (ordinance), which they had not,” Belanger said.

“You guys voted to put it on the ballot, so that (ad) was totally misleading. That was a lie!”

“There were many lies,” Buccina acknowledged.

Puiia then explained that because Rumford didn't have an ordinance in place to regulate wind development, a moratorium was enacted to enable that to be done.

The board's attempt to provide such regulation, however, was defeated on Tuesday.

“So you can go out and contract with landowners and do everything but put up the wind towers, and that's considered within compliance of a moratorium?” Buccina asked.

“Right,” Puiia said.

Belanger then attempted to steer discussion toward ending the moratorium.

“After this last vote, it's very clear, I mean, the people have spoken twice, once 2-to-1 in favor of looking at wind, and they voted this time and felt that the wind ordinance was too restrictive, so I don't think it should take too long,” he said.

Selectman Jeff Sterling then motioned to convene a public hearing on the matter and vote by selectmen at the board's next meeting.

tkarkos@sunjournal.com

In order to make comments, you must verify your account.

In order to comment on SunJournal.com, you must use your real name and include the town in which you live in your profile. A member of our staff will call you to verify this information. To join in, fill out your user profile completely and check the box "please verify my status." We'll get back to you within one business day to verify your account.

Login or create an account here.

Our policy prohibits comments that are:

  • Defamatory, abusive, obscene, racist, or otherwise hateful
  • Excessively foul and/or vulgar
  • Inappropriately sexual
  • Baseless personal attacks or otherwise threatening
  • Contain illegal material, or material that infringes on the rights of others
  • Commercial postings attempting to sell a product/item
If you violate this policy, your comment will be removed and your account may be banned.

Advertisement

Comments

gempaint's picture
verified

mountain views

Ask Bethel, Newry how much their tax base grew in 10 years?
They are running out of mountain views. The development will come our way.
A Casino in Oxford County does mean influx of people.

Better than that; most of these developments are vacation homes.
Associations plow their roads. They have private septic and wells.
Towns gain tax base without town service increase.

Save our mountains.

Thinking maybe rich out of staters want a totally green home, self sustainable and care taken by locals.

gempaint's picture
verified

voting rights, right to know

Voters have right to know the wind projects are not about power but money.
2 new projects in Maine (Spruce and Saddleback) will turn down or off 1/2 the turbines because of noise cautions.
An industry with a 20% capacity onset now drops in half.
It is not about green. Making a huge wind turbine leaves more of a carbon foot print than can be redeemed.
As suggested; loss in development versus destruction of our views has not been evaluated.

KNSaisi's picture
verified

moratorium

The board needs to extend the moratorium to give them time to put together a reasonable ordinance (the one that should have been proposed in the first place). The ordinance will put reasonable restrictions on the wind power companies and provide requirements for upkeep and removal of towers when they are no longer in use.

Genisek2004's picture
verified

If the people have voted to support wind power development...

what right does any special interest group have to sustain a moratorium. Do the people have a voice through voting in this state or not???

candiceanne's picture

Gentlemen, we all know the

Gentlemen, we all know the drill. The voters have shown up at the polls twice in droves twice and expressed their intentions loudly and clearly; they favor wind power development in Rumford. We know that few people show up at public hearings and town meetings because they are working, are senior and don't go out at night, are disabled or otherwise would vote absentee which is not an option for town meeting or are otherwise unavailable with prior commitments, etc. That leaves the special interest anti-wind power group to take advantage again with something like 35 people showing up and contradicting the will of more than 1000 in the lowest count of the two australian votes we have had on this issue and continue a moratorium a third time we didn't want the first two times. The only way the anti-wind power special interest has been able to get their way has been by forcing special town meeting where they can make sure a limited number of voters have the ability to participate and can control the vote, mis-use of the "advisory" committee, and through threatening and intimidating the town manager and selectmen. It is time to put this moratorium behind us and move on inaccordance with the will of the people.

verified

35 anti winders

Enough is enough! Moritorium was extende once already. The poll was 2to1 in favor of wind power coming to Rumford. The vote was taken and the anti d ordinance did not pass. And you want to play right into the hands of the anti winders again. What is wrong with this picture? I'll tell you what is wrong the selectboard still refuses to listen to the people. Give this minority another chance like you did with Black Mountain. How the heck did you people get elected? It looks like some must be working for these minority special interest groups.

verified

35 anti winders

Enough is enough! Moritorium was extende once already. The poll was 2to1 in favor of wind power coming to Rumford. The vote was taken and the anti d ordinance did not pass. And you want to play right into the hands of the anti winders again. What is wrong with this picture? I'll tell you what is wrong the selectboard still refuses to listen to the people. Give this minority another chance like you did with Black Mountain. How the heck did you people get elected? It looks like some must be working for these minority special interest groups.

Advertisement

Stay informed — Get the news delivered for free in your inbox.

I'm interested in ...