Ex-worker says atheism got him fired by DeCoster
By Christopher Williams
,
Staff Writer
Friday, May 4, 2007
LEWISTON - A state investigator says a worker at a Poland farm owned by Austin "Jack" DeCoster has reasonable grounds for claiming he was fired and lost his home because he is an atheist.
Cacy Cantwell, who was hired as a manager at the farm in 2003, says DeCoster told him shortly before he was fired that they would have to "part ways" because the manager didn't believe in God and DeCoster was a Christian.
Three years after he was hired by Maine Contract Farming L.L.C., Cantwell told the Maine Human Rights Commission that he was fired and denied housing because of his belief. The state agency's investigator, Barbara Lelli, agreed. The case is expected to go before the Human Rights Commission, said Patricia Ryan, executive director.
Cantwell also claimed he was fired because he was a whistle-blower. Lelli disagreed with that claim.
When he was hired, Cantwell was given housing owned by Turner Realty LLC. Cantwell lived there with a non-married partner, two of his children and three of her children.
Three years later, in November 2006, Cantwell was fired and told to vacate his apartment. A consultant to DeCoster and a supervisor to Cantwell told him he was let go because of his poor job performance.
Cantwell met DeCoster in August 2006, three months before he was fired. They toured the farm and strolled into one of the barns. At that point, when the two men were alone, Cantwell later told Lelli, DeCoster said to him: "If you do good by me, God will do good by you."
Cantwell said he responded to DeCoster's remark by saying he was an atheist and didn't believe in God. DeCoster put his hand on Cantwell's shoulder and told him: "I can't have someone like you here. We might need to part ways," Cantwell recalled in an interview with Lelli.
DeCoster then berated Cantwell for having used the Internet on which he had met a woman, Cantwell recalled. DeCoster had called it "blasphemy," Cantwell said.
About a month later, while touring one of the barns, DeCoster criticized Cantwell for living in one of his homes with a woman to whom Cantwell wasn't married, Cantwell said. DeCoster said the living arrangement was a sin in his - and God's - eyes. After reminding DeCoster he was an atheist, Cantwell said the owner told him: "You're living in my house, you'll do as I say." He also told Cantwell: "We'll part ways if you don't change."
A consultant to DeCoster confirmed that the owner doesn't approve of people who aren't married, Lelli said. Shortly before he was fired, one of Cantwell's supervisors noticed a poster in a garage that housed a lawnmower. Cantwell had hung a poster that was an ad for an energy drink depicting a woman in a bikini. The supervisor told Cantwell to take down the poster. "You know Mr. DeCoster is a Christian and is not going to like that." Cantwell said he responded: "Don't Christians like breasts?"
On Nov. 17, 2006, the same supervisor came to the farm and fired Cantwell. The man said something like, "You know, Mr. DeCoster is a Christian man and he can't have someone like you working for him," Cantwell told Lelli.
The supervisor denied having made that statement, Lelli said. He told Cantwell he was fired for "poor job performance." The supervisor said he consulted with another supervisor and DeCoster before making the decision to fire Cantwell.
Cantwell had received no written warnings or suspensions before he was fired, the investigator said. The supervisor said other farm managers had been fired without written warnings.
Cantwell's complaint also was filed with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
Lelli said DeCoster was given a chance to respond to the human rights complaint, but failed to in a timely fashion.
Over the past decade, DeCoster has been involved in legal cases dealing with environmental and labor law violations at farms in Maine and elsewhere. |
CLICK HERE To Show/Hide Discussion Thread - (6 Comments)
Comments
 |
Posted By:jv at May 4, 2007 6:28 AM (Suggest Removal) Knowing Jack DeCoster, I would so believe this employee's story. The thing that stinks is that it's going to be near impossible to prove.
| Add your comments
|
Posted By:unknown at May 4, 2007 8:15 AM (Suggest Removal) What's it any of his business who's not married or doesn't believe in god?
| Add your comments
|
Posted By:garry at May 4, 2007 8:57 AM (Suggest Removal) Jack Decoster, a Christian? with the way he has treated his employees for years. when did this happen?
| Add your comments
|
|
Posted By:Bill Clarke at May 4, 2007 10:06 AM
The fact is, an employee is accusing his former employer of saying something which, if true, would be certainly be a violation of the law. The problem is, there are no witnesses. It's the fired employee's word against the supervisor's word.
The Human Rights Commission should never have let this complaint get this far. It is a waste of taxpayer money.
This employee simply cannot prove his case. He ought to be forced to pay DeCoster's attorney's fees.'>(Suggest Removal) It doesn't matter if DeCoster is a Christian, Muslim, Jew, Atheist, or whatever.
The fact is, an employee is accusing his former employer of saying something which, if true, would be certainly be a violation of the law. The problem is, there are no witnesses. It's the fired employee's word against the supervisor's word.
The Human Rights Commission should never have let this complaint get this far. It is a waste of taxpayer money.
This employee simply cannot prove his case. He ought to be forced to pay DeCoster's attorney's fees.
| Add your comments
|
Posted By:Kelly at May 4, 2007 10:14 AM (Suggest Removal) If a judge can be fired for displaying the 10 commandments because people find it offensive, why shouldn't this guy be fired for offending others. It's not that he is an atheist, its that he went out of his way to insult another's religion and ridicule it. If he had put up a ham sandwich instead of a half naked woman, you can be sure he'd be out of work and facing hate crimes. can you say double standard?
| Add your comments
|
Posted By:ski at May 4, 2007 5:55 PM (Suggest Removal) The only thing i see that the employee did wrong was putting up the poster and then saying to the supervisor don't christians like breasts. Every job i've worked did not allow those sorts of posters in order to prevent lawsuits and such. It is no business of the owner what religion or not the guy had and whether or not he's married.
| Add your comments
|
|
Advertisement

|
 |
| “Paint Your Heart Out: Embracing Art and Healing” |
a collection of watercolor paintings, will be exhibited at the Central Maine Medical Center Rotating Art Gallery from November 7 through December 1. |
read more >>
|
| Central Maine Obstetrics-Gynecology |
is the first Midwifery Service in Maine and only the second in New England to be recognized by the American College of Nurse-Midwives with its Golden “With Women for a Lifetime” Commendation. |
read more >>
|
| Deborah Taylor |
associate director of the Central Maine Medical Center Family Medicine Residency Program, has been elected to the Society of Teachers of Family Medicine (STFM) Board of Directors. |
read more >>
|
| Erwey A. Teng, M.D. |
a pulmonologist and intensivist, has been elected to the Central Maine Medical Center Medical Staff. He is practicing with Pulmonary and Critical Care Associates in Lewiston. |
read more >>
|
| Medicare Program |
Central Maine Medical Center and SeniorsPlus will offer individual counseling for seniors who want to review their Medicare drug coverage for 2009. |
read more >>
|
|
|