Levesque suing Fox to deter 'reckless' reporting
By Bonnie Washuk
,
Staff Writer
Sunday, July 1, 2007
The lawyer representing Lewiston School Superintendent Leon Levesque said Saturday that Levesque is suing the Fox News Network "for what they dragged him through," and to deter "irresponsible and reckless" reporting.
Lawyer Bernard J. Kubetz of Bangor said he fully supports the right of the media to report the news, "but when a broadcast giant like Fox acts this irresponsibly and reckless without regard to the impact it can have, there should be an opportunity for a jury to hear what happened."
Levesque is suing Fox News Network and two of its anchors for libel and slander as part of a civil complaint. The complaint is seeking damages in excess of $75,000, and was filed by Levesque, not in his role as superintendent for the Lewiston School Department.
Levesque said Saturday he would not comment on the lawsuit because his lawyer advised against that.
His lawyer called the case a compelling one.
"It appears to me that Fox News acted in a grossly irresponsible way and took some information that was really not very plausible, did not do any substantial fact checking, and put it out as hard news," Kubetz said.
Fox News either broadcast false statements knowing they were false, or in reckless disregard of the truth, he said.
The lawsuit was filed June 22 in U.S. District Court in Portland. The defendants - Fox News and anchors Steve Doocy and Brian Kilmeade - had not responded as of Saturday, Kubetz said.
A receptionist who answered a call to Fox News in New York on Saturday refused to forward a call to anyone at Fox, referring the Sun Journal to the Fox Web page. E-mails to Fox went unanswered. How a ham became a ham sandwich
On April 19 the Sun Journal published a story about a Lewiston Middle School student who was suspended after he left a ham steak on a table where Somali students were having lunch, knowing ham is offensive to Muslims. The Sun Journal later was told it was a ham bone leftover from an Easter meal.
In the story Levesque said the incident did not reflect the moral values of the school. "We need to take a look at this and review how a careless act is degrading and causes hurt to other people," Levesque said. "All our students should feel welcome and safe in our schools."
A parody of the story was displayed April 23 on the Web site Associated Content. The parody changed the ham steak to a ham sandwich. The Associated Content story quoted Levesque saying ridiculous things he never uttered, including that, "Children have got to learn that ham is not a toy, and that there are consequences for being nonchalant about where you put a sandwich." Kubetz said he suspects Fox saw the fake story and aired it without fact-checking.
"Clearly if they checked with the Sun Journal, or the Lewiston School Department, with Leon Levesque, the Attorney General's Office in Maine, or Nicholas Plagmen who wrote the fake story, Fox would have discovered it was not a real news story."
Instead, "Fox and Friends" anchors Doocy and Kilmeade aired the story three or four times, each time assuring viewers, "We've checked this out and it's true," according to Kubetz.
Doocy said on the broadcast that they were "not making this up" and that he had "looked it up on a couple of different Web sites up there, from local papers."
Doocy also said, "I can understand that (rolling a pig's head into a mosque) is a hate crime. But for a kid to put a sandwich on a table, that is crazy. Here's our question this hour: a ham sandwich - is it a hate crime or is it lunch?"
Another Doocy comment was that Levesque, "who looks as though he's going to the hilt with this, says it's akin to making these kids feel like they're being shot at back in Mogadishu and being starved to death."
After the Fox anchors assured viewers what they reported was "100 percent true, they then went so far to invite viewer feedback and comment," Kubetz said.
The "ham is not a toy" fictitious comment may make someone grin, but the Fox broadcast did personal and professional harm to Levesque, Kubetz said.
"Anyone who Googles him is going to be immediately faced with this so-called ham sandwich incident. It makes him look foolish."
After Fox aired the broadcasts, Levesque was overwhelmed for days with phone calls and hate mail. Threatening calls were made to his home, which made Levesque and his wife uncomfortable. Based on Kubetz's review, most of the hate e-mail "were from across the United States," not from Lewiston or Maine.
After Levesque asked Fox News to correct the story, Fox did a brief on-air retraction, but it was unsatisfactory, Kubetz said.
Levesque deserves a fair compensation "for what they dragged him through," Kubetz said. He's hoping suing Fox for libel and slander will serve as a deterrent, "so no other innocent person is subjected to this."
He expects a jury trial will be held in Portland in 10 months to a year.
Kubetz is with Eaton Peabody in Bangor. He represents some media outlets, including the Bangor Daily News. He also specializes as a defamation lawyer. |
CLICK HERE To Show/Hide Discussion Thread - (10 Comments)
Comments
 |
Posted By:Dr. Hassan Bin Sobah at July 1, 2007 6:34 AM (Suggest Removal) "He's hoping suing Fox for libel and slander will serve as a deterrent, "so no other innocent person is subjected to this."......So, it really isn't about the money. I see.
| Add your comments
|
Posted By:rob at July 1, 2007 9:32 AM (Suggest Removal) FoxNews is grossly inaccurate with a story that they ran with on one of their morning shows. The "journalists" on-air said they did fact-checking, when clearly not even the most perfunctory investigation was done. The result was defamation to Mr. Levesque. I have no problem with this lawsuit, which is for a relatively small amount of money (had he been suing for, say, millions, he'd be going too far). Instead, this lawsuit serves as yet another reminder to the media that too often, when they sacrifice accuracy for speed, there are real-life consequences.
| Add your comments
|
Posted By:LHS - 20 and counting at July 1, 2007 10:24 AM (Suggest Removal) the true test to how levesque truly feels about this situation is when FOX attempts to settle this lawsuit. They are a multi-billion dollar company and will not hesitate to throw 75K (the amount being sued for, yet pocket change to FOX)to make the suit disappear. If levesque accepts this settlement, he will be admitting he is only in it for the money. If he refuses and his case is heard, he will be backing up his statement that he is doing this so that "no other innocent person is subjected to this." Only time will tell.
| Add your comments
|
Posted By:blackhawkdown at July 1, 2007 11:23 AM (Suggest Removal) i do agree with levesque i like what your doing in putting fox in there place and not sueing for millions just 75k its a principle thing i think you should once recieve puplicly then throw a somolian american party at the school and invite fox then show them how the schools are working on all the students mending as one school
| Add your comments
|
Posted By:reader at July 1, 2007 1:55 PM (Suggest Removal) isnt just for the money? just rationalize this, the more people make an issue of something the more it becomes a problem. is it justified probably not but then time will tell. If the money can go into a fund to educate somalian refugees and our students about the cultures it could would make a difference
| Add your comments
|
Posted By:Dr. Hassan Bin Sobah at July 1, 2007 3:30 PM (Suggest Removal) 1. First of all, Levesque is suing for $75,000 or more. $75,000 is the minimum amount you can sue for and get into the Federal court system. I suspect he will be pushing for far more than a mere $75,000. 2. How was Levesque harmed? He still has his job and is probably pulling down more than ever these days (around $100 grand a year, I'd suspect). I suspect his reputation will be hurt more by filing a wacky law suit/money grab. 3. Fox and other networks are continually being sued by people who see "deep pockets". They vigorously defend themselves. 4. Why didn't Levesque sue the people who wrote the parody that Fox personnel referred to? Maybe, just maybe, the author is a struggling stiff like the rest of us?
| Add your comments
|
Posted By:ojhuig at July 1, 2007 3:57 PM (Suggest Removal) Levesque is doing the right thing. Fox news is following the lead of Anne Coulter. Yellow journalism at its worst.
| Add your comments
|
Posted By:amal at July 1, 2007 5:48 PM (Suggest Removal) I think Clifford you are so wrong, somali are not poachers/cd, they are human who have good culture, respect, etc. I don't know why you hate somalis. I think you are jealous about them
| Add your comments
|
Posted By:Bill in NC at July 1, 2007 8:43 PM (Suggest Removal) When's Levesque going to represent George Bush against Dan Rather? Was that even a story. Certainly not yellow journalism, right jhuig?
| Add your comments
|
Posted By:Jim at July 4, 2007 8:43 AM (Suggest Removal) 1. I don't see what your problem is with this lawsuit. The Fox anchors obviously ran a false story and claimed they had checked the story and that it was absolutely true. Turns out they didn't, it wasn't. Purely lazy journalism.
2. The harm to Levesque comes in the form of harrassing and threatening mail and telephone calls to his home. Placing him in fear for himself and his family.
3. Really, show me other networks that have been sued for airing the truth.
4. Levesque couldn't sue the people who made the parody. Remember if you can back to the case of Falwell v Flynt. Falwell sued Larry Flynt because of a parody ad that Flynt ran in Hustler magazine. The Supreme Court ruled that parodies were a protected form of speech. One that people would obviously know were not true and that even the slightest checking into the background of the parody would show that is was not true.
| Add your comments
|
|
Advertisement

|
 |
| “Paint Your Heart Out: Embracing Art and Healing” |
a collection of watercolor paintings, will be exhibited at the Central Maine Medical Center Rotating Art Gallery from November 7 through December 1. |
read more >>
|
| Central Maine Obstetrics-Gynecology |
is the first Midwifery Service in Maine and only the second in New England to be recognized by the American College of Nurse-Midwives with its Golden “With Women for a Lifetime” Commendation. |
read more >>
|
| Deborah Taylor |
associate director of the Central Maine Medical Center Family Medicine Residency Program, has been elected to the Society of Teachers of Family Medicine (STFM) Board of Directors. |
read more >>
|
| Erwey A. Teng, M.D. |
a pulmonologist and intensivist, has been elected to the Central Maine Medical Center Medical Staff. He is practicing with Pulmonary and Critical Care Associates in Lewiston. |
read more >>
|
| Medicare Program |
Central Maine Medical Center and SeniorsPlus will offer individual counseling for seniors who want to review their Medicare drug coverage for 2009. |
read more >>
|
|
|