Rich Lowry

By all means, let’s take a star who is drawing new attention to a women’s sports league that could definitely use it, and make her into a hate figure.

If her critics have their way, this will be the fate of Caitlin Clark.

Of course, Clark is the former University of Iowa basketball legend who has now embarked on her rookie season in the WNBA with the Indiana Fever, generating new interest in a league that has survived for almost two decades, but hasn’t set the world on fire.

The other WNBA players don’t like Clark very much, an animosity exemplified by a flagrant foul against Clark by a player with the Chicago Sky last weekend.

The old Rodney Dangerfield line is, “I went to a fight and a hockey game broke out.” Well, the body check of Clark was worthy of an NHL game, and her former LSU rival now on the Sky, Angel Reese, cheered the takedown lustily.

As a hyped newbie, Clark is inevitably in for some rough treatment from longer-tenured opponents, but she shouldn’t get abused for the offense of being a bright new star — or for, according to her more perfervid detractors, being too white or attractive.

Advertisement

On the “The View,” co-anchor Sunny Hostin accused Clark of benefiting from white privilege, pretty privilege, tall privilege and straight privilege.

That’s a lot of alleged privilege, and still leaves out the most important — shooting- and passing-ability privilege.

If Caitlin Clark were a pedestrian player, no one would know her name. It’s her ability to make long-distance “logo threes” and her extraordinary pass-making skills that make her exceptional.

The sports commentator Jemele Hill has complained that Clark’s “race and her sexuality played a role in her popularity,” and that she’s symptomatic of how Black players are “erased.”

A player for the Las Vegas Aces, A’Ja Wilson, has said much the same thing.

These interpretations are non-falsifiable. Testing the proposition would require a black LGBQT+ player becoming the highest-scoring college basketball player of all time — in both the men’s and women’s game — and averaging an insane 31.6 points per game in her final season. Since only Clark has achieved this, there’s no way to make a comparison. But it seems likely that if Clark’s non-white, non-straight hypothetical equal pulled this off, she’d probably get a Nike contract, too.

Advertisement

For anyone who values the WNBA, it is self-sabotaging to treat Clark as a white interloper. She’s an incredible draw and an invariably courteous emissary for the game. She has inspired girls around the country and patiently signed their signs, jerseys and sneakers.

Her Iowa team didn’t just routinely sell out at home, but sold out on the road against teams that were otherwise meager draws. The Caitlin Clark effect led to the women’s college championship game this year easily drawing more viewers than the men’s championship.

It’s not as though the WNBA is in a position to turn its back on a potential generational talent. If the league has been making gains, it still badly lags the NBA. The clinching game of the WNBA championship last year averaged 889,000 viewers, and the post-season averaged 470,000 viewers. In contrast, the clinching game of the NBA finals averaged 13 million viewers, and the post-season 6.4 million. The WNBA generated about $200 million in revenue in 2023, whereas the NBA generates roughly $10 billion.

Caitlin Clark isn’t going to make up this disparity (she’s a point guard, not a miracle-worker). Anything to draw more people to the game should be profoundly welcome, though. Clark so far has struggled, at least by her standards. She is 16th in the league in points per game. But she’s only played 11 games so far. Already, she scored 30 points in one game, and she’s the fastest WNBA rookie to 150 points, 50 assists and 50 rebounds.

Who knows if she will eventually be the GOAT of the WNBA, but she’s certainly not the villain.

Rich Lowry is a syndicated columnist.


Only subscribers are eligible to post comments. Please subscribe or login first for digital access. Here’s why.

Use the form below to reset your password. When you've submitted your account email, we will send an email with a reset code.