Let’s start with a simple answer to a simple question: No, Androscoggin Bank is not offering interest-free loans to members of the Islamic community — or to anyone else.
The confusion was generated when the Sun Journal published a column written by a Bates College student. The opinion piece described a class project in cultural anthropology that examined issues related to banking among Muslims.
Androscoggin Bank cooperated with the project (as we often do when approached by students), but the conclusions and recommendations were those of the students, not Androscoggin Bank. They do not reflect Androscoggin Bank policy.
The column did, however, accurately reflect some interesting aspects about life for Muslim immigrants in our communities.
Muslims, like anyone else, require access to financial services. Here’s the challenge: practicing Muslims are prohibited by their faith from either paying or collecting interest. Muslims can certainly borrow and lend money; both are permitted. So is banking, and so is making a profit. But interest — a percentage of the borrowed amount in return for the loan — is not allowed.
Like everyone else, Muslim residents in our communities require and deserve access to financial services. So area banks have, and continue to, develop programs to serve these members of our communities. For example, Androscoggin Bank currently offers a demand deposit account (DDA) that provides the security and convenience of a bank checking account but doesn’t pay interest.
It’s available to anyone who asks.
But what about loans? How do banks serving Muslims, globally and regionally, provide loans and maintain profitability? Is it possible for Androscoggin Bank to offer these products to the Muslim community locally? If so, what are the steps we need to take to do so? Answering these questions was the goal of the project with Bates.
One of the answers is this: banks loaning money to practicing Muslims charge fees instead of interest. These fees, based on the cost of the loan, are presented up front to the customer and are typically paid over time, as is the principal of the loan. When viewed in terms of cost and payment schedule, it’s virtually indistinguishable from a conventional loan.
The difference between a fee-based loan and a conventional one might strike you as a purely semantic one, but to practicing Muslims, it’s an important and permitted solution to the prohibition on interest. And it’s along these lines that you may very well see new products offered by Androscoggin and other banks at some point in the future.
Will they be “interest free?” By definition, yes — but because they’ll include fees instead of interest, the total loan cost will be roughly at par with conventional loans. These, too, will be available to anyone who wants them.
So when will these be available? It’s hard to say. Banking is one of the nation’s most heavily regulated industries and the creation of this type of program takes time to implement. These products must be created in such a way that we can both meet customer needs and satisfy state and federal banking laws. That will take time.
Some might view this type of program as unnecessary, believing that members of our communities who hold different value systems should simply adapt to ours. But it’s not that simple. Most of the Muslims living in our communities are refugees from a terrible conflict. They came to Maine, as did all immigrants, to find new opportunity and a better life.
We are all stronger if every person in our community has access to essential services, including financial services. As a bank, we have a mission to help residents own homes, own businesses and have a secure financial future.
It’s also important to remember that banks create specialized products for certain groups of citizens all the time — different types of mortgages, different types of credit lines, different types of checking accounts.
In fact, serving new communities is at the root of Androscoggin Bank’s history. Androscoggin County Savings Bank was initially formed in the 1870s, when officers and directors of First National Bank of Lewiston recognized a need for banking services for the thousands of immigrants arriving in the Lewiston-Auburn area.
When it comes to financial services, there’s no so such thing as “one size fits all.” There never has been. Androscoggin Bank has always created products and services based on the needs of those we serve. When the time comes to offer products aligned with the beliefs of our Muslim neighbors, we will simply be continuing that tradition.
Paul Anderson is chief operating officer of Androscoggin Bank.
Comments are no longer available on this story