DEAR DR. ROACH: When you lose weight through diet and exercise, where does the weight go? — L.A.J.

ANSWER: Weight gain and weight loss in the very short term can be related to body fluid, but I think you are really talking about people who have made a long-term loss of, say, 10 pounds. Those 10 pounds can be fat or muscle. In people who are eating very few calories and not exercising, it will be a combination of both of these body components. Unfortunately, losing muscle is unhealthy, which is why it’s best to exercise in combination with changing the diet, so that the weight loss is all fat. I’ve had patients who have lost fat and gained muscle, who can be frustrated that their weight isn’t going down, but in reality they are much, much healthier.

From a physics standpoint (the study of medicine starts with physics and chemistry), a pound of fat represents about 3,500 calories. Eating 3,500 more calories than you expend means a pound of fat gain, while the reverse means a pound of weight loss. In weight loss, the fat is used to provide energy for the body’s metabolic processes and is (almost literally) burned away into carbon dioxide.

However, the physics doesn’t properly address the complexity of weight gain and loss in humans. Simply eating less and exercising more doesn’t lead to the expected weight loss, as the body has ways of adapting to lower food intake. Also, as people lose weight, their energy needs decrease further, and the ”3,500 calories per pound” rule becomes a very poor approximation. Finally, the processes controlling eating behavior are complex, and in some people, the body uses every trick it can, including overpowering hunger, to stay at the same weight. For these reasons, I don’t find simply telling people to eat less and move more to always be an effective therapy.

DEAR DR. ROACH: I have been told by my doctor that I have prostate cancer. He has given me two options: One is to have radioactive seeds implanted, and the other is to freeze the cancer. Which of these has the lower chance of erectile difficulty? — H.K.E.

ANSWER: Radiation seed implants (called brachytherapy) and freezing (cryotherapy) are considered reasonable options for some men with localized prostate cancer. There probably are differences in effectiveness and in other side effects, which may make you consider how these treatments affect you and the cancer.


However, in terms of sexual function, although I am unaware of them having been directly compared, my understanding of the literature suggests that brachytherapy has less risk of poor function.

DEAR DR. ROACH: Seventy-five-plus years ago, authorities said to avoid cooking with aluminum. As I understand it, aluminum deposits are found in the brains of those who have died from Alzheimer’s disease. I realize that modern science makes no connection with this (so far), but it’s pretty easy to avoid aluminum. My mother died from Alzheimer’s and had been cooking with aluminum for at least 45 years. — G.M.

ANSWER: Aluminum was of concern, especially back in the 1980s and ’90s. However, it is no longer thought that using aluminum utensils or cookware affects Alzheimer’s risk.

In a previous column, I discussed what can be done to reduce risk of dementia. I did not include quitting smoking, but that may be the most important factor for a person who is still smoking. Thanks to B.G., who wrote in.

* * *

Dr. Roach regrets that he is unable to answer individual letters, but will incorporate them in the column whenever possible. Readers may email questions to or request an order form of available health newsletters at 628 Virginia Dr., Orlando, FL 32803. Health newsletters may be ordered from

(c) 2017 North America Syndicate Inc.

All Rights Reserved

Only subscribers are eligible to post comments. Please subscribe or login first for digital access. Here’s why.

Use the form below to reset your password. When you've submitted your account email, we will send an email with a reset code.