LEWISTON — Authorities said Tuesday there was no credible evidence of criminal wrongdoing or violations of state election laws by former Mayor Shane Bouchard.

Shane Bouchard resigned as mayor of Lewiston during a March 8 news conference at City Hall. Sun Journal file photo by Russ Dillingham

Lewiston police conducted a joint investigation with the Maine Attorney General’s Office into possible crimes alleged earlier this month by a local woman who said she’d had an affair with Bouchard when he was running for mayor in 2017.

Heather Everly Berube lodged public accusations against Bouchard during a City Council meeting in early March. She said she had funneled campaign emails from Ben Chin, Bouchard’s opponent in that race, to Bouchard. Many of those same emails ended up being made public, having been posted on a GOP website, and may have influenced the outcome of the mayoral election.

After making her initial allegations against Bouchard, Berube shared with the Sun Journal more than 150 texts between her and Bouchard — the bulk of which were from 2017 — that included a racist joke. The Sun Journal published a story that included the joke. In another text, he appeared to compare a meeting with his fellow Republicans to a Ku Klux Klan gathering.

A day later, Bouchard resigned from his post as mayor.

Last week, Berube made more allegations against Bouchard at another council meeting. The allegations involved a student at Oak Hill High School in Wales during his time there as a wrestling coach. According to Sun Journal archives, Bouchard coached at Oak Hill for at least four years, leaving about a decade ago.


Androscoggin County Sheriff Eric Samson said Tuesday that the Maine Attorney General’s Office referred those Oak Hill allegations to his department. After interviewing an alleged victim who was a student at the school at the time, the Sheriff’s Office found no crime was committed, he said.

Through his attorney, James Howaniec, Bouchard released the following statement Tuesday in reaction to the investigation’s findings.

“Shane Bouchard is grateful for the prompt investigation by the Lewiston Police Department and Maine Attorney General’s Office,” the statement said. “He was the victim of false accusations and is pleased to put this matter behind him. He will continue to pursue his legal options to ensure that he is not subjected to such harassment in the future. We continue to call upon the Lewiston City Council to implement procedures to ensure that such wildly defamatory allegations are not allowed at public hearings in the future.”

Berube has questioned the accuracy of the investigation, saying no one from the Attorney General’s Office spoke with her, and Lewiston police did not seem to take her seriously. “There was never an investigation,” she said in a statement released Tuesday.

In early March, Berube said she had passed along to Bouchard emails from Ben Chin’s 2017 mayoral campaign.

Berube acknowledged to the Sun Journal at that time she had shared the emails in a covert effort to boost Bouchard’s chances of becoming mayor by using the Chin campaign’s data and statistics.


She said she believed Bouchard or his wife then gave the emails to Jason Savage, head of the Maine GOP and owner and operator of the conservative Maine Examiner website that published the leaked emails.

Bouchard has acknowledged getting internal Chin emails from Berube, but denied having a sexual relationship with her and denied that he or his wife forwarded the emails to Savage for publication.

Earlier this month, after Berube publicly shared texts between her and Bouchard that included the racist text, he apologized. Bouchard said he was not racist and the comment was not a reflection on the way he feels about black people in general or Lewiston’s black residents in particular.

“I say stupid things and stupid jokes occasionally,” he said.


Staff writers Lindsay Tice and Andrew Rice contributed to this report.

Comments are no longer available on this story

filed under: