Chester Carlson, Charles Darrow and Caleb Bradham. You might not recognize their names, but you know their products.
Carlson’s working career began early in life, becoming his family’s main provider before he started high school. A few years later, he was working as a patent clerk for Bell Labs in New York when inspiration struck.
Tired of having to manually retype patent descriptions and redraw patent drawings whenever copies were needed, he set out to devise a method of making photocopies. Chester patented his method in 1937. It took 22 years for him to become an overnight success after teaming up with a small paper manufacturing company named Haloid. The product became known as the Model 914, and Haloid soon changed its name to Xerox.
Where would some of America’s largest office products companies like Staples and Kinko’s be without Chester Carlson’s invention? They would be nonexistent.
Despite all of Carlson’s success, he was rejected at first.
IBM, Kodak, General Electric and nearly 20 other companies rejected his idea.
The precursor to Monopoly was a 1904 game called “The Landlord’s Game,” which taught people the unfairness of realty and tax systems. Soon people were customizing the game to reflect their own neighborhoods. After Darrow of Germantown, Pa. played one of these games at a friend’s house, he changed the game to what became Monopoly and began manufacturing the games himself and selling them for $4 apiece.
Despite all of Darrow’s success, he was rejected at first.
Parker Brothers rejected it in a big way, sighting 52 fundamental flaws. So Charles did what any determined inventor would do — he continued selling the game himself. When Parker Brothers saw the success Charles was having during the Christmas season of 1934, the company agreed to buy the rights from him.
Bradham, a North Carolina native, created Pepsi in 1893, although it wasn’t originally called Pepsi. He named it after himself and called it “Brad’s Drink.” Bradham poured a sample of his mixture into a beaker and gave it to his assistant to taste. When he saw his assistant’s face light up upon tasting it, Bradham knew he had created a winner.
He later renamed it Pepsi Cola after its two main ingredients, pepsin and the cola nut. Pepsi Cola was successful until sugar prices went bad in 1923. Eight years later, the Loft Candy Company purchased a bankrupt Pepsi Cola Co.
Despite all of Pepsi’s early success, it was rejected at first.
When the Loft Candy Co. struggled with Pepsi just as its founder had, the company offered to sell it to Coca-Cola. Unfortunately for Coca-Cola, it rejected it without even making a bid.
So the common theme here is … ?
That’s right – each invention was rejected before the world figured out what a great invention it was.
You can’t really blame the companies that rejected them, though. Carlson’s Xerox technology, with terms like “electrostatics” and “photoconductivity,” was so new and so different from anything that had ever been created that no one else understood it.
Monopoly made Darrow the world’s first millionaire board game inventor, even though he wasn’t the person who designed the original version of the game.
Pepsi, on the other hand, was just one of many cola companies of that era, and its early bankruptcy made it less than an ideal prospect.
From the Department of Useless Trivia, Pepsi spawned the first advertising jingle in history. Called “Nickel Nickel,” the jingle also became a hit record.

© 2009 Paul Niemann. This story is part of the Invention Mysteries series by author Paul Niemann. For more information, visit

Activity guide for students
Thoroughly read the Sun Journal over the next seven days to find three stories about items that are considered to be failures. Write out your answers to the following questions:
1. Why is this product (or company) failing?
2. Are any of the three stories similar to the situations that Xerox, Monopoly or Pepsi faced? If they are similar, how?
3. What do you think needs to happen for each one to improve its situation and become successful? (For example: Would product (or company) benefit by being renamed, by improving its image, etc.?)

Only subscribers are eligible to post comments. Please subscribe or login first for digital access. Here’s why.

Use the form below to reset your password. When you've submitted your account email, we will send an email with a reset code.